Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Category:
Fandom:
Relationships:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Series:
Part 1 of podcast 'verse
Stats:
Published:
2024-07-21
Updated:
2026-01-02
Words:
104,256
Chapters:
15/?
Comments:
834
Kudos:
1,033
Bookmarks:
308
Hits:
30,332

What Happened To Little Nathaniel?

Chapter 15

Notes:

this is the shortest chapter of this fic. i simultaneously celebrate my own restraint and vow to never write a chapter less than 4k words again.

for real, though: thank you for the lovely, insightful comments and support on this fic. i don't tend to keep track of metrics so imagine my surprise when i saw this fic has 900+ kudos. that is genuinely insane and the aftg fandom is far bigger than i realised. thank you!

Content warnings for this chapter:

Discussions of abuse and references to sexual assault / rape throughout.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

 

Group Chat: FUCK YOU ALL 

 

Nicky: yikes kevin that ferdinand bitch won’t leave you alone will she

 

Dan: Is she a bitch or is she just a woman you disagree with?

 

Nicky: GENDER NEUTRAL BITCH 

 

Allison: Nah seconding Nicky she’s a real fucking bitch lol

 

Nicky: kevins a guy and hes the biggest bitch ever and ive been saying that since day one dont revoke my feminist card 

 

Allison: No worries there, you have never qualified for a feminist card 

 

Allison: Also omggg this gc is a throwback

 

Allison: Hated half of you guys but the texts were fun </3

 

Nicky: anyways kevin how are you doing? do you need a hug? pls let me finally hug you i will sell my left kidney to pay for it

 

Matt: dude aren’t you married now???

 

Nicky: kevin’s one of my free passes

 

Dan: Wtf is a free pass??

 

Allison: Dan my sweet summer child what rock have you been living under

 

Nicky: i get to sleep with kevin if the opportunity ever arises. and isn’t a hug basically just a very underrated form of foreplay??

 

(Dan Wilds has muted Nicky Klose)

 

Dan: I’m suddenly remembering why we haven’t used this gc in a year

 

Dan: Anyways @Kevin is there actually anything we can do to help? 

 

Allison: Loll what can we do?? Send an angry letter to Ferdinand?? Tell the internet to stop talking about it??

 

Aaron: Nicky says “fuck u dan this is homophobic” 

 

Aaron: And Kevin has this GC permanently muted. Going to take inspiration.

 

Allison: It was soo nice speaking to you Aaron!

 

Allison: @Renee tell Tall Hot & French to make Kevin open this chat

 

Renee: Not his name, Allison. And I’m sure Kevin wouldn’t appreciate us adding to his stress right now

 

Allison: We are conducting a welfare check on our dear friend Kevin. If you don’t tell Tall Hot & French to make Kevin check his phone then I will be forced to message my bestie Neil for the gossip instead

 

Dan: Allison who tf are any of these people

 

Renee: Alright! 

 

Kevin: What is it?

 

Allison: kevin do you not have TWO working hands now?? Use them to scroll up bitch

 

Matt: dan wants the lowdown on this ferdinand bullshit!!!!!

 

Dan: So do you MATTHEW 

 

Dan: Seriously people keep dming me on insta asking about the ravens and That Guy

 

Allison: Samee it’s getting annoying. posted a thirst trap yesterday and half the comments were about YOU. men ruin everything

 

Kevin: My condolences for your plight

 

Allison: Make it up to me by giving me the lowdown xoxo 

 

Kevin: There is literally nothing to say. I heard she has some true crime podcast now and she’s doing a season about the Ravens. So what? I have more important things to focus on. It’s not a big deal.

 

Matt: u sure??

 

Kevin: It’s fine, no one should even care. I have a career to focus on.

 

Dan: Oh

 

Matt: ah sorry bud :(

 

Allison: ohh

 

Kevin: What?

 

Allison: oh no kevin girl i kinda feel bad now for joking :( 

 

Dan: You’re having the crashout of the century over this aren’t you?

 

Kevin Day has left the groupchat.

 

Seth: lol

 


 

Andrew’s (and now also Neil’s, allegedly) house is surprisingly cosy. By no stretch of the imagination is Andrew a man with a desire to engage with interior design, but Neil’s stayed in enough places to recognise the signs of a home. 

 

The Minyard-Hemmicks aren’t framed-photos-on-the-wall kind of people. But, the evening he moves in, Neil reads through the patchwork of paper haphazardly attached to the front and sides of the refrigerator by mismatched magnets. 

 

One is a photocopy of Aaron Michael Minyard’s acceptance letter to medical school. Another is a horrendously explicit postcard addressed to Nicholas Hemmick from Erik Klose. Neil’s favorite, buried beneath layers of more recent college-era additions, is a high school report card commending one Andrew Minyard for ‘atypical academic performance, made all the more remarkable given his attendance, attitude to learning, and affinity for joyless destruction’. Someone wonkily highlighted ‘academic performance’; another, neater hand underlined ‘joyless destruction’ repeatedly. 

 

It’s the evidence of a life lived; that a unit of people spent enough time in the same space to leave a lasting imprint.

 

Neil took the empty downstairs bedroom. It’s the largest and originally belonged to Nicky; Neil invents the backstory that he reserved it for himself under the guise of avoiding arguments between the twins. It seems like the kind of bullshit a nineteen-year-old guardian would pull if given half the chance. 

 

The bathroom is upstairs, which gives Neil the excuse to explore that evening once Andrew leaves for his shift at Eden’s. The staircase curves around, split into two mini-flights, with the door to the bathroom at the end of the hall, two doors on the left, and one on the right. The first door on the left is a disappointment; towels and sheets. The second door, however, redeems the first.

 

The room is empty enough that its inhabitant is immediately obvious. There’s all the standard hardware– bed, closet, desk, bedside table– but it’s missing everything which could feasibly be removed. Only a bare mattress remains on the bed. There’s an empty mounted bracket above the desk where a desktop monitor once sat. Even the lightbulb from the ceiling fan is gone. 

 

This is not the bedroom of someone who intends to return. 

 

Something builds in Neil’s chest the longer he stands in the threshold; the sense that he is unwelcome and out of place, never far from his mind, rears its ugly head. Stupidly, he thinks of the shell of the Wesninski mansion after the Feds were done with it. 

 

He’s back in the hallway before he can dwell any further on that train of thought. The last door, the one that can only be Andrew’s, looms in front of him.

 

This time, though, he hesitates before entering. For good reason, too; he spots the tiny piece of tape on the top corner between the door and the frame. The slightest movement of the door would make it peel away. A way of keeping track of unwanted visitors. Mary drilled it into him as protocol in every safehouse they inhabited. It only works, though, if the person entering doesn’t know to look for it. 

 

Neil opens the door. Tape is hardly a difficult thing to replace.

 

Andrew’s bedroom is stark, unsurprisingly. No art on the walls and no fluffy rugs. But it’s clear that select areas have been deemed worthy of effort. 

 

The closet is larger than Aaron’s, with a mirror set into the right side. There’s plants by the window– Neil would have expected cacti, perhaps, but instead they’re all tall and heavy-looking, with massive leaves and wide, plastic pots. The kind of things that take effort to keep alive. The nightstand doubles as a small bookshelf, with two neat rows of paperbacks tucked beneath a shallow drawer. 

 

And the bed is heaped with at least three blankets, excluding the comforter, though no cushions beside the solitary main pillow. It’s also shoved into the back corner farthest from the window and door. He might as well have voluntarily cornered himself, Neil thinks, then sees the heavy deadbolts set into the window and door. Those definitely weren’t in Aaron or Nicky’s rooms. 

 

Safety is a fickle thing; it took Neil a month before he could let his guard down with the Wymacks, and even then those walls came straight back up whenever David raised his voice or Abby got terse. He looks again at the placement of the bed. It lets Andrew sleep with his back to a wall, in a room with the entrances and exits as secure as possible.

 

Neil isn’t one for shame, nor guilt, but something unpleasant settles under his skin, like brittle layers of ice have taken up residence in the space between his capillaries. 

 

This space is not his to invade. 

 

He wipes his fingerprints from the door handle once he leaves– old habit– but doesn’t replace the tape. Andrew stares at him across the kitchen that evening but doesn’t call him on it.

 


 

THE NEW YORK TIMES

The Edgar Allen High Controversy: the Facts, the Fiction, and the Curse

By Winona MacDonald

 

The phrase ‘Edgar Allen High’ means little to the average person. A cursory observer could assess that: a) it’s probably a high school, and b) it’s maybe an artsy high school, given the ‘Edgar Allen’ portion of the name. You would be correct on both counts. These two pieces of information are simultaneously minor and incredibly telling in the grand scheme of things.

 

Searches for ‘Edgar Allen High’ quintupled two weeks ago following an announcement from hit podcast host Kathy Ferdinand that the next season of her award-winning show, ‘Killings With Kathy’, would focus on the so-called Edgar Allen High Controversy. It’s a lesser-known scandal in the grand scheme of things, thanks in no small part to discomfort around the circumstances of the story breaking back in 2019. It’s a faux pas to speak ill of the dead, after all.

 

For the uninformed, the core, agreed-upon facts are as follows.

 

Edgar Allen High hosted the best high school hockey team in recent memory, with star centres Riko Moriyama and Kevin Day serving as the team’s representatives for 2015 to 2017. However, tragedy soon befell the duo: in spring of 2017, Kevin Day sustained a severe injury to his left, dominant hand and withdrew from the Edgar Allen Ravens. Over a year later, on December 10th 2018, Riko Moriyama died from a gunshot wound to the head. It was ruled a suicide two months later. 

 

In January of 2019, reports of an abusive and toxic environment in the Edgar Allen High team began to emerge. All came from anonymous alleged former team members and the allegations were initially levelled exclusively against the coaching team. Tetsuji Moriyama, legal guardian of Riko Moriyama (and, at the time of the alleged abuse, Kevin Day) and head coach at the time, would allegedly berate and issue beatings to students as a ‘corrective measure’. By July, the reports developed further to allege that Riko Moriyama purposefully caused Kevin Day’s injury. They also alleged that Riko Moriyama perpetuated the physical and verbal abuse of a second, unnamed team member. This allegedly eventually escalated to Moriyama organising the supposed sexual assault of the unnamed team member. It is relevant to note that Tetsuji Moriyama issued a statement in August of 2019 denying all allegations against his nephew. Notably, he has never denied the allegations against himself nor his colleagues.

 

From April to December 2019, the West Virginia Police Department, West Virginia School Board, and National Hockey League separately investigated the Edgar Allen High Ravens. At the time of writing, no criminal charges have been filed, but the Edgar Allen Ravens have been dissolved and Tetsuji Moriyama is not an active member of the teaching nor hockey community. 

 

The continued rumors surrounding the circumstances of the Edgar Allen Ravens remain a hotbed for speculation and misinformation. However, Kevin Day has never publicly commented upon the allegations against his former teammate.

 

(Continue reading)

 


 

Direct Message: Neil Josten to Jean Moreau

 

Neil: how’s kevin doing?

 

Jean: It’s been two weeks and yet he shows no signs of processing.

 

Neil: are we really surprised?

 

Jean: He says he’s ‘compartmentalizing’. He has a meeting with his publicist next week to ‘get ahead of this’, whatever that means

 

Neil: predictable

 

Neil: and you?

 

Jean: https://www.nytimes.com/2024/07/01/sports/edgar-allen-high-rumors-truth.html 

 

Jean: “Alleged” “allegations” “allegedly” 

 

Jean: I assume this is a taste of your life these past few months. In which case I acknowledge your restraint in not reminding us of the various times we implied your reactions were irrational. 

 

Jean: That being said you definitely didn’t act like a sane person. But those in glass houses can’t throw stones I guess. 

 

Neil: you have such a unique outlook on life :)

 


 

Twitter Search: “Kevin Day”

 

yola | @daytoday  

KEVIN DAY IS SO BABYGIRL I CANT EVEN. LIKE LOOK AT THIS MAN HE IS SO GORGEOUS I AM FOAMING AT THE MOUTH

[Image]

62 Comments | 231 Retweets | 3.2K Likes



Bradley | @bradwracken

Kevin Day really is miles above the rest of the Titans (except Knox). Look how he set up this score– and look at his teammates! They expected him to solve their missteps. He’s effectively alone on the rink. Shocking.

[Video]

4 Comments | 13 Retweets | 94 Likes



P | @foreverno

No shade but the amount of “Kevin Day fans” who are only just learning who Riko Moriyama is… #fakefans

13 Comments | 21 Retweets | 92 Likes

 

Replying to P

tish | @columbiat1t4ns

No truly, he’s an integral part of Kevin’s lore and it’s so jarring how many people only just heard of him!!! 

3 Comments | 4 Retweets | 13 Likes

 

Replying to tish

Maria | @peonyx

ok well literally no one talks about him so how tf was i supposed to know who he is 

7 Comments | 3 Retweets | 5 Likes

 

Replying to Maria

P | @foreverno

Google is free… and there’s a reason we don’t talk about him that much. Should still be common knowledge if you’re calling yourself a Kevin Day stan

3 Comments | 4 Retweets | 8 Likes

 

Replying to P

dina | @day2day

Stop gatekeeping this shit oh my god. @peonyx essentially a bunch of Riko & Kevin’s former teammates came forward a couple years back after Riko died talking about how their high school team was crazy abusive and toxic. then some of them said Riko was the main perpetrator (other than his uncle who was their head coach) [1/?]

8 Comments | 11 Retweets | 42 Likes

 

Replying to dina

dina | @day2day

and some of them said there were some major open secrets within the team. including that riko broke kevin’s hand and that riko got a bunch of teammates to SA another, underage teammate. kevin hasn’t confirmed anything and the teammate who got SAed wasn’t named and didn’t file a report so yk. nothing rly came of it. [2/?]

23 Comments | 17 Retweets | 61 Likes

 

Replying to dina

dina | @day2day

But the fact that Kevin never denied it happened is kind of an indication that some messed up shit went down bc yk… Riko was his adopted brother and surely you’d want to defend your dead family if they were falsely accused of maiming you and some heinous other shit. [3/3]

15 Comments | 26 Retweets | 69 Likes

 

Replying to tish

Maria | @peonyx

i wish i hadn’t asked

2 Comments | 3 Retweets | 5 Likes






From: [email protected]

 

Hi Kevin, 

 

I hope this email finds you well!

 

As discussed, sending across the top-line findings and recommendations following our review of current online sentiment around yourself and the ongoing interest in Edgar Allen High. 

 

Let me know if you have any questions! Please forward on any requests for comment to myself.

 

Best,

 

Raul 

 

Key Details

 

  • Overall Sentiment:
    • Relating to ‘Kevin Day’: 25.3% positive | 53.7% neutral/undetermined | 21% negative 
    • Relating to ‘Riko Moriyama’: 17.1% positive | 52.7% neutral/undetermined | 30.2% negative
    • Relating to ‘Edgar Allen High’: 8.7% positive | 23.2% neutral/undetermined | 68.1% negative

 

  • Repeated Conversation Points:
    • General surprise at Riko Moriyama: This point relates to both the overall existence of Riko Moriyama (5.8K posts) and his alleged actions (15.1K posts). Additional shock came from users who expressed disbelief at other fans not knowing of RM or the allegations (48.7K posts).
    • Polarizing discussions: Users expressed dislike and confusion around perceptions that others believed the various allegations against RM (9.1K posts). Common evidence to the contrary was cited as the lack of public comment by involved parties (0.8K posts) and the posthumous nature of all allegations (3.2K posts).
    • Discomfort around subject matter: Significant discomfort related to the allegations that RM injured Kevin Day (6.2K posts), with users referencing the ‘brotherly’ bond expressed in interviews from the time as evidence to the contrary (1.5K posts).
      • As expected, the most significant source of self-proclaimed discomfort and stress among users were the allegations of sexual assault (4.1K posts).
      • In line with recent trends, users typically self-censored discussions around this subject with coded language and indirect references, limiting research into this dimension due to parameters of data collection tools.
    • Perceptions Around Lack of Comment: Some users, typically while expressing support for RM, insisted that KD had not yet commented due to the traumatic nature of RM’s passing and the ‘ridiculousness’ of the allegations (6.1K posts). Essentially, silence was also interpreted as subtle support for RM.
    • Perceptions of Disrespect: Users in support of RM (and, oftentimes, those new to the conversation) often described the allegations of abuse as overblown and distasteful given the nature of RM’s passing (19.8K posts).
      • It is important to note that these sentiments were contained within those with positive feelings towards RM– the vast majority of sentiments towards RM were either negative or neutral (see above)
    • Edgar Allen as ‘True’ Villain: Following on from the above finding, users on both sides of the spectrum affirmed that the toxic environment of Edgar Allen High, as well as the adults in authority positions, held the most responsibility for the allegations of abuse on the team (3.9K posts).
      • Though limited, fringe discussions (often seeming to cite the alleged group nature of the reports of sexual assault [<100 posts]) reiterated perceptions of overall toxicity and a ‘cult mentality’, often constructing RM as subsequently absolved of guilt due to questions of responsibility (0.3K posts).
  • Suggestions:
    • No (Specific) Comment at this Time: KD should avoid expressing agreement or disagreement with specific allegations.
    • Potential Future Support: However, if discussions relating to allegations of interpersonal abuse and sexual assault in the wider Ravens team continue to escalate, it may be beneficial for KD to express support for one of our approved charities in order to maintain personal branding and avoid suggestions of implication.
    • Team Support: Previous guidance to disengage from conversations around the topic remains in place. Columbia Titans members should continue to express support for KD and limit media conversations relating to Edgar Allen High. 

 

Raul Esperanza | Publicity Manager | NHL Columbia Titans 

 

Please consider the environment before printing this correspondence 🍃




 

VIDEO: Kevin Day and Jeremy Knox: The Puppy Interview

 

Video by BuzzFeed Celeb

  4.07M subscribers

 

807K views | 6 hours ago   #nhl #kevinday



Comments:

 

@atmostofall 2 hours ago

golden retriever x pampered fluffy white cat energy 

👍 3.1K | 👎

   ↓  3 replies

 

@idriselmo 4 hours ago

Anyone else feel like Jeremy was ready to smuggle all of them home?

👍 5.5K | 👎

   ↓  2 replies

 

@bad4u  44 minutes ago

the way none of the questions address the elephant in the room 

👍 1.3K | 👎

   ↓  103 replies

 

@albaonce1981  12 minutes ago

13:20 I feel like they cut something, look how hard Kevin’s breathing between the two shots

👍 379 | 👎

   ↓  22 replies

 

@strayaway  44 minutes ago

15:58 the note about one of the dogs getting adopted by kevin’s friend was so cute!!!! Wish they gave us pictures!! 

👍 769 | 👎

   ↓  9 replies

 

@prin19013  39 minutes ago

Ohh Kevin Day in green… my ovaries exploded

👍 1.1K | 👎

   ↓  67 replies




 

Direct Message: Neil Josten to Jean Moreau

 

Neil: why are so many people attracted to kevin?

 

Jean: No idea.

 


 

Your Search History

 

By date   |   By group

 

Today – 15 July 2024

05:43 AM       kevin day

05:44 AM       finding mary reddit

06:23 AM       kevin day

06:29 AM       finding mary reddit 

06:30 AM       mary wesninski body found

07:01 AM        kevin day 

09:43 AM       kevin day

11:32 AM        finding mary reddit

11:36 AM        kevin day

01:16 PM         finding mary reddit

01:23 PM         kevin day 

03:39 PM        kevin day

05:01 PM         finding mary reddit

05:21 PM         kevin day

09:32 PM        finding mary reddit

10:21 PM         kevin day

10:36 PM        finding mary reddit

 

Yesterday – 14 July 2024

05:37 AM       kevin day

05:58 AM       finding mary reddit

06:19 AM       finding mary reddit 

06:31 AM       mary wesninski body found

08:54 AM       kevin day

11:13 AM        finding mary reddit

11:56 AM        kevin day

01:16 PM         finding mary reddit

02:53 PM         kevin day 

03:14 PM         kevin day

04:42 PM         finding mary reddit

05:21 PM         kevin day

08:37 PM        finding mary reddit

11:43 PM         kevin day

12:01 AM        finding mary reddit

 

[Show more]

 


 

Direct Message: Aaron Minyard to Andrew Minyard

 

Aaron: Monthly check in text

 

Andrew: Is that it? 

 

Aaron: I texted first it was your invitation to carry on the conversation

 

Andrew: [image3.jpeg]

 

Aaron: Is that Renee’s cat?

 

Andrew: Yes. I plan to steal her.

 

Aaron is typing…

 


 

tish | @columbiat1t4ns

Guys we’re now 3 weeks post Ravensgate and Kev STILL hasn’t released a statement…concerning no?

18 Comments | 21 Retweets | 293 Likes

 

Replying to tish

Mel <3 | @librarytod4y

Girl the guy has no actual personality outside of Media Friendly (affectionate!!!) pls don’t expect that much from him

6 Comments | 9 Retweets | 71 Likes

 

Replying to Mel <3

annie | @passontome

I mean why would he? Nothing’s actually happened yet, we’re all just assuming there’s some nefarious secrets that are gonna come out?? And that podcast might be a bunch of eps of nothingburger yknow??? We already know most of what went down at edgar allen 

4 Comments | 5 Retweets | 12 Likes

 

Replying to annie

tish | @columbiatit4ns 

The guys high school team and adopted brother turned out to be a bunch of creeps and this girls talking about nothingburger!! Imagine getting your hand crushed or getting graped and years later some idiot on Twitter is saying your trauma is too boring for them!! Weirdo behavior

7 Comments | 18 Retweets | 31 Likes

 

Replying to tish

annie | @passontome 

girl when the fuck did i say any of that 

11 Comments | 7 Retweets | 25 Likes

 


 

Killings with Kathy | @killingswithkathyofficial 

It’s time, people 👀 Season 2 of Killings With Kathy launches NEXT SATURDAY @ 12pm EST. We cannot wait to share this with you 🐦‍⬛

512 Comments | 15K Retweets | 101K Likes

 

Notes:

this chapter is mostly a bridge to get us to the next proper story beat, because opening this chapter on an abrupt time jump didn't feel right. little easter egg, too: i used my real-life job skills for a very specific part of this chapter.

some developments not represented in the content of this chapter:
- the internet still cannot find mary wesninski's body.
- jabberwocky likes to sleep on kevin's head now. jean is secretly offended.
- andrew and neil have started occasionally watching deeply shitty, late-night paranormal tv shows together.

Notes:

Kudos & comments are always appreciated <3 Feel free to come talk to me on tumblr

Series this work belongs to: