Chapter Text
Haley is writhing under the weight of his body as Nathan slips a finger into her panties and explores the outer areas of her vagina, which she had recently decided to allow him to make contact with. While she still hesitates away from any penetration, this was sort of okay. His index finger flicking her clit was more than okay.
Nathan is concentrating fully, he’s always interested in knowing exactly what makes her squirm. He wants to know Haley’s body so well that when they finally have sex, he knows exactly where to tease her, touch her, taste her. And by the way her hips her bucking up towards his touch, he figures small and quick circles in a clock-wards motion on her clit is always the right answer.
He leans down to suck on the soft, fleshy part of her ear lob, another thing which he knows is a crowd favourite.
“You’re always so soft and wet, Hales.” He licks the shell of her ear. “Do you feel good, baby?”
She turns her head to look at him and while the shallow pants escaping her lips are enough of an answer, it makes him swell with pride when she nods her head frantically.
“N-Nathan it feels so good.” Her chest is heaving, words stuck in her throat. “You feel so good, Nathan.”
Grinning triumphantly, he uses another finger to spread her labia apart further and then uses the pad of his thumb to cover more surface area, making sure to retain the quick tempo. When her breathing grows more laboured and she snakes her hand up his back to violently grip his t-shirt, he knows it’s only a few more seconds until she is about to cum.
He was right. She whimpers softly while the orgasm rips through her body, leaving her slack against the mattress.
“Nathan…” She sighs happily, eyes opening wide to look at the dazzling boy on top of her. Gosh, did he have to be so attractive.
“Yes, baby?” He nuzzles her neck, all the while supporting his body on his forearms so he doesn’t crush her.
She pulls at the waistband of his jeans from behind. “Your turn.”
Nathan grins again, this time against her skin and thinks about the previous time they were in this position and it was the first time she had touched his cock, sure, over the fabric of his boxers, but still she had touched him and stroked him until there was a stain on the fabric there. His spine tingles at the thought of that happening again.
They kiss for a bit, both lost in their own thoughts of desire for the other and Haley breaks away first, her hand pressed to his toned chest. She bites her lip and smiles shyly. “Um, so, I was thinking that maybe this time… You’d I dunno… Maybe you want to… maybeyouwanttohumpme?”
By the time she’s finished that sentence, she’s bright red but Nathan arches a brow with interest. He feels so smug right now.
“I’m not sure I really understand you, Hales.” He drives his crotch straight into hers and flutters his hips a bit. “Is this what you’re talking about?”
She’s glaring at the idea that somewhere he finds this funny but she can’t deny that the way his lower half of the body is moving into hers is kind of delicious and it makes her ache.
“You know that’s what I meant.”
He chuckles and then looks at her tentatively, pulling his shirt over his head and throwing it aside.
“Haley?”
“Hmmm?”
“Can I take my jeans off? Just my jeans.”
She bites her lip and nods. “Okay.”
He gets up and shimmies out of his pants before climbing back on top of her. He’s so glad she trusts him with parts of herself that are so guarded and private. He also can’t believe that this is the closest their bodies have ever been to each other. He has to close his eyes and think of Whitey so he doesn’t cum instantly.
“Haley, if you feel like it’s too much… You just let me know, okay?”
He presses against her, his bare chest making contact with her own, her hardened nipples feeling great against his skin. They lay like that for a second before he straightens up ever so slightly and guides her legs around his waist. Haley’s watching him just a bit nervously but with much more anticipation.
The first contact is a bit uncomfortable on his part but as the wetness seeping through her panties becomes more pronounced and spreads to his boxers, he begins to dry hump her more closely. The tip of his dick is between her lips, separated by their respective underwear’s but god if it isn’t just so good, even like this. Nathan lets out a groan as he continues to rub himself against her pussy, hands on her hips and eyes wide open to study every reaction she has to this new sensation.
It’s not surprising to Haley that she’s completely riveted by this. She’s still wet and sensitive from a couple of minutes ago and the sounds he’s making aren’t helping. She had no idea Nathan Scott could be this wrecked.
She’s getting too turned on, she needs something, another step, another first, so she doesn’t find herself giving into the big one.
“Baby…” She just about whispers.
Nathan, who by this point has closed his eyes against his will because his hips have found just the right angle, halts immediately and his eyes fly wide open. What did he do? Gosh, maybe he’d gone too close to her entrance?
“What is it, Hales? Is everything okay?”
He’s so concerned and it makes her heart flutter. If only he knew.
“Nathan, I wanna see it. You. I mean, all of you.” She timidly rubs three fingertips up the length of his cock just so it’s clear what she’s asking for.
Nathan, on the other hand, sits back on his ankles and thinks, the feeling of her fingers strumming against him making it hard to think straight, but okay, after all, she had asked for it.
“You’re sure, Haley?”
“I’m sure.”
He feels completely under a microscope as he lowers the waistband of his boxers down and lets his hard member be released. He gulps, swallows, aware that most girls weren’t gawking at it the way Haley was. He watches her reactions carefully, while she tilts her head to the side and licks her very suddenly dry mouth.
Her voice breaks the tension. “It’s so big…”
Nathan can’t help but smirk. What man doesn’t like hearing that. “Thank you, Haley.”
She blushes at her admission, aware how cheesy and porn-o that must have sounded. But gosh, wow, while she hadn’t had any real life interactions with one before, she wasn’t clueless. And all of that lack of experience didn’t stop her from acknowledging that her boyfriend was well endowed. Her thoughts began slipping again, how much that thing could fill her up…
“Earth to Haley…”
She looks up to see Nathan completely naked before her and she shivers, beckoning him closer.
“Sorry. Um, you can… you can continue.”
“Haley. Are you sure?”
“Yes.” She smiles up at him. “Please continue.
Neither one can deny that the absence of his boxer shorts goes unnoticed. Her panties are so wet and worn that they don’t really hinder him from being able to feel her through them. His cock fits perfectly against her, no matter which angle he approaches her from. Nathan finds that good rhythm again, finding a spot that he knows feels good for both of them because Haley is moaning quite loudly, caught up in how amazing it is to be this close to him, with him.
In a moment of immense pleasure and clouded judgement, she moves her panties to the side and he doesn’t even notice until he realises that he’s now rubbing her, skin against skin and it’s just killing him. Haley is so wet and warm, his dick is pulsing. It’s all of his fantasies coming alive.
“Haley…” He all but whines. “Haley, do you have any idea how good you make me feel? Fuck.“
The way he’s gliding against her is too much, she’s doing everything in her power not to just have him go all the way. But no matter how hard she is trying to calm herself, the more she wants him. Maybe just a notch higher, she thinks.
“Just the tip.”
Nathan halts again, his entire body like a live wire but he’s laughing out loud still. “What did you say? How do you—?”
“I don’t live under a rock.” She interrupts him, tone steady and under control to showcase that she is sure about this next step. “I’ve seen a movie or two.”
He can’t believe it. But the look in her eyes is pretty adamant.
“Okay. But just the tip, okay.”
“I trust you, Nathan. Completely.”
And that’s the perfect thing to hear as he pushes the head of his cock into her, not enough to completely break through the skin of her hymen but just bump against her opening. He can tell he’s just made an embarrassing sound but somehow this was better than sex itself with most anyone. Haley wasn’t just anyone.
She holds onto both her breasts and squeezes on the mounds of flesh. It wouldn’t take much convincing to let him inside her but it’s a road she’s not ready to take. She tries not to move too much, aware that this must be taking every ounce of his self control already. Her hands move to his back, trailing her pink fingernails across his fair skin. Did all of him have to feel so good?
“Haley. I love you.”
He tries out her latest request a few more times before deciding no matter now good it made him feel to be that much closer to her, he was having a hard time not pushing in further. Which is why he had to stop, because Haley trusted him and he wouldn’t let her down. Nathan’s hips shift up and he drives achingly in to her, he knows he’s close and he tries to recall that someone once told him that semen stays in the vagina for 7 days, and whether that’s true or not. Shaking his head, Nathan decides he won’t take that risk.
She’s obviously not thinking of that though, eyes rolling back into her skull as she truly understands how much she loves him. And his recent declaration makes it all the better. She leans up to kiss him passionately and he matches her fervour. Which is why she doesn’t like when he stops moving against her body.
“Nathan?”
He laughs, pushing the hair out from in front of her eyes. “Uh, Haley, you do realise that I would be, uh.” He’s trying not to be crude. “Leaving a mess behind in a tricky place.”
Her eyes bulge wide, how stupid of her for not to be thinking about that certain function of his body. But how sweet of him to be practical here. She rewards him with a kiss.
“Yeah, I see how that could be a problem. How about I just…?” She wraps her hand around him and wow, his skin is burning and it is just so stiff. Again, she wonders, what must that feel like inside her.
Nathan nods in earnest, arching into her touch and it’s not long before the muscles in his back begin to tense. He knows it won’t be long now.
“Haley, could you focus on the tip. Please.”
It’s incredible how soft his voice is. Almost pleading, no where near commanding.
She follows his instruction carefully and pumps the head of his cock and delights in watching his face scrunch up wonderfully as he grunts through his teeth. The next thing she knows is that there’s something warm and sticky leaking onto her stomach.
He rolls over so he doesn’t collapse on top of her and falls flat onto his stomach. Nathan can’t feel his legs. That was the single strongest orgasm he’s had since they’ve started dating, most others were just him alone, thinking about her in the shower. He wants to say something to her, tell her how thankful he is that she allows him to be this close to her. But he can’t, his breathing won’t normalise. His body needed this like no one could know.
“Baby? You okay there?” Haley smiles to herself as she shifts into a comfortable position to massage the taught skin between his shoulders.
He moans at the sensation. Finally catching his breath. “Yeah. I just, wow. That was incredible.”
“I’m so glad you think so.” She kisses the back of his head and then stands to wrap a towel around herself. “I really need to go clean up, okay? Do you want Chinese?”
She doesn’t miss the fact that he’s half asleep. And fair enough, he’s been up since 6am and he’s had 3 hours of non-stop practice— not to mention he’s had something just short of sex. She can’t help but feel some immense pride in that. Haley turns on her heels, quietly shutting the door so her lover (wow, lover) can rest in peace.
Before she can completely close the door she hears him mumble something that really makes her remember why she loves him.
His voice is so strained with sleep. “Don’t forget the egg rolls. You love the egg rolls.”