Work Text:
The crackling campfire cast flickering shadows across the faces of the Foxes, huddled together against the encroaching chill of the autumn night. The scent of burning pine mingled with the earthy aroma of moss, creating an atmosphere ripe for storytelling.
"Alright, who's next?" Dan's voice cut through the silence, her eyes scanning the circle expectantly.
Matt Boyd cleared his throat, a mischievous glint in his eye. "I've got one. And it's not your typical 'hook on the car door' cliché."
Neil leaned forward, intrigued despite himself. He'd heard his fair share of campfire stories, but Matt's enthusiasm was infectious.
"This one's set in Charleston," Matt began, his voice dropping to a hushed tone. "You know, since we're all South Carolina folks now."
As Matt launched into his tale of the laundress and the Army of the Dead, Neil found himself drawn in. The story of Confederate ghosts marching through the streets of Charleston was far-fetched, yet Matt's delivery made it oddly compelling.
Neil's mind wandered to his own ghostly past, the specter of the Butcher of Baltimore looming in the recesses of his memory. He shivered, and not just from the cool night air.
"...and when she came out of her daze, her arm was paralyzed," Matt concluded dramatically. "She never did a full day's washing again."
A chorus of "oohs" and nervous laughter rippled through the group. Neil forced a smile, trying to shake off the unease that had settled over him.
"Nice one, Matt," Allison drawled, rolling her eyes. "Very spooky."
But Neil could see the slight tremor in her hand as she reached for her drink. Matt's story had affected them all, whether they wanted to admit it or not.
As the next person began their tale, Neil's thoughts drifted back to his own haunting past. He wondered, not for the first time, what stories his teammates would tell if they knew the truth about Neil Josten and the real horrors that lurked in his history.
As the firelight flickered, Dan leaned forward, her eyes glinting with mischief. "Alright, my turn. Let me tell you about Julie, the girl who stayed home alone."
Neil stifled a sigh, recognizing the well-worn tale. He'd heard it countless times during his years on the run, in different towns with different faces. Still, he settled in, watching Dan's animated gestures as she spun the yarn.
"Julie was 14, and her parents were going out for the night," Dan began, her voice dropping to a conspiratorial whisper. "She begged them not to leave her alone, but they insisted she was old enough."
As Dan continued, Neil found his attention wandering. His gaze drifted across the campfire, settling on Andrew's impassive face. The orange glow of the flames danced across Andrew's features, highlighting his sharp cheekbones and casting shadows that made his eyes seem even more intense.
"...and then she heard it again, the whimpering sound," Dan's voice faded into the background as Neil studied Andrew.
Andrew's blonde hair seemed to glow in the firelight, and his amber eyes reflected the dancing flames. Neil couldn't help but stare, mesmerized by the play of light and shadow across Andrew's face.
Suddenly, Andrew's eyes flicked to meet Neil's. "Staring," he stated flatly, his tone as apathetic as ever.
Neil felt a small smile tug at his lips. He knew Andrew better than to be fooled by his apparent indifference. "You like it," Neil murmured, just loud enough for Andrew to hear.
To anyone else, Andrew's expression remained unchanged. But Neil caught the slight reddening at the tips of Andrew's ears, a telltale sign that his words had an effect.
Neil's grin widened, a warm feeling spreading through his chest. It was moments like these, quiet and unnoticed by others, that made him feel truly safe and content.
"...ALL NIGHT LONG!" Dan finished with a flourish, snapping Neil's attention back to the group.
The others laughed and groaned, the familiarity of the story eliciting more eye-rolls than scares. But Neil barely noticed, his focus still on Andrew, the connection between them provided a sense of comfort in the chilly autumn air.
As the laughter from Dan's story died down, Neil found his thoughts drifting to his history with Andrew. The crackling fire and murmur of voices faded into the background as the memory of their first meeting flooded back to him, a time when he was still known as Abram and Andrew was under the care of foster parents. His heart clenched at the thought of those days, the uncertainty and loneliness that had defined them both. But in that moment, there had been a glimmer of hope and connection between them, a spark that would eventually ignite into their nothing that they have today.
"Your turn, Nicky," someone called out, but Neil barely registered it.
He felt a light touch on his hand and looked down to see Andrew offering his pinky. Without hesitation, Neil intertwined his pinky with Andrew's, a small gesture that spoke volumes.
"You're thinking too loud," Andrew murmured, his voice low enough that only Neil could hear.
Neil squeezed Andrew's pinky gently. "Just remembering."
Their moment was interrupted by Seth's booming voice. "Alright, losers. Time for a real story. Ever heard of the Butcher of Baltimore?"
As Neil's eyes locked with Andrew's, his body went rigid and he could feel the weight of those piercing blue eyes bearing down on him. Every muscle in his body tensed, his breath catching in his throat as he waited for Andrew's judgement. The intensity of his gaze filled the air, creating an electric tension that crackled between them. Neil felt like a deer caught in headlights, unable to move or look away from the scrutiny of Andrew's stare. In that moment, he knew that Andrew saw right through him, assessing every inch of his being with an unnerving precision.
"Oh, I've heard of that one," Allison chimed in. "Isn't that the serial killer from a few years back?"
Neil's heart raced. Had they found out? Did they know who he really was? His instincts screamed at him to run, to disappear into the darkness beyond the fire's reach.
"Rabbit," Andrew's voice cut through the panic, barely above a whisper. "You are Neil Josten. Starting Striker for the Palmetto State Foxes. You are safe. You are with me."
Neil forced himself to take a deep breath, Andrew's words anchoring him to the present. He felt the tension in his shoulders ease slightly, though his guard remained up.
"Yeah," Seth continued, oblivious to Neil's inner turmoil. "This guy was a real piece of work. They say he had a special knife for each victim..."
As Seth launched into his story, Neil found himself torn between the urge to correct the inaccuracies and the need to maintain his cover. He settled for gripping Andrew's pinky tighter, grateful for the small connection keeping him grounded.
Seth's voice droned on, "...and he'd always leave a signature mark on his victims, like a butcher's stamp or something."
Neil couldn't help but scoff quietly. He knew there was never any "signature mark." His father had been far too practical for such theatrical flourishes.
"Something funny, Josten?" Seth's eyes narrowed.
Neil shrugged, aiming for nonchalance. "Just seems a bit cliché, doesn't it? The whole 'serial killer signature' thing."
Seth bristled. "Oh yeah? And what would you know about it?"
A ghost of a smirk played on Neil's lips. "I wrote about it for a paper back in Millport. Did a lot of research, ya know?"
Andrew's pinky tightened around Neil's, a silent warning.
"Well, enlighten us then," Seth challenged, crossing his arms.
Neil leaned forward, the firelight casting eerie shadows across his scarred face. "For starters, he didn't use a special knife for each victim. He had a favorite cleaver, sure, but he wasn't picky about his tools."
The group fell silent, all eyes on Neil. He could feel Andrew's gaze burning into him, but he couldn't stop now.
"And the victims weren't random," Neil continued, his voice steady despite the memories threatening to overwhelm him. "Most were people who owed him money or crossed his business partners."
Seth scoffed and rolled his eyes. “Okay Mr. Know-It-All, do you want to tell the story or can I continue?”
Neil motioned for Seth to go ahead without saying a word. Andrew’s gaze was still glued to Neil’s face assessing him.
Seth cleared his throat, a hint of annoyance in his voice. "Right, so the Butcher of Baltimore's reign of terror finally came to an end when he was killed in 2008. The whole city breathed a collective sigh of relief, blah blah blah." Seth's retelling lacked the eerie finesse that Dan's had possessed, but Neil could sense the tension simmering beneath the surface as Seth glanced at him now and then.
As Seth wrapped up his version of the tale with a dramatic flourish, Neil couldn't help but roll his eyes and interject. "Actually," he began, his tone measured but authoritative, "the Butcher wasn't caught due to public outcry or police efforts. It was a personal vendetta that led to his downfall."
The group turned to Neil, their expressions a blend of curiosity and skepticism. Andrew's gaze never left Neil's face, silent communication passing between them. Andrew squeezed Neil’s pinky in a reassuring gesture.
"He hated his son," Neil continued, his voice low but firm. "Nathaniel has escaped from him years before with his mother. The Butcher chased after them for years.”
Neil's words hung heavy in the air, the crackling fire providing the only soundtrack to his revelation. The group listened intently, drawn in by Neil's storytelling with a mix of fascination and unease.
"The Butcher tracked them down one last time, determined to punish Nathaniel for daring to escape him," Neil explained, his eyes flickering with a mixture of pain and defiance. Memories of that fateful night flooded back to him, the fear, the agony, the loss.
Neil took a steadying breath before continuing. "Nathaniel watched as his mother was tortured and killed in front of him," he stated, each word heavy with the weight of truth. "And then it was his turn. The Butcher wanted to break him, to make him pay for every moment he had spent free from his clutches.”
A shiver ran through the group, the darkness of Neil's tale seeping into the crackling firelight around them. Andrew's grip on Neil's pinky tightened, a silent anchor in the midst of Neil's haunting words.
A hush fell over the campsite, the flickering flames casting twisted shadows that danced across Neil's face. His eyes bore into each member of the group, daring them to challenge his account.
"The Butcher met his demise at the hands of his own kind," Neil concluded, a solemn finality in his tone. "And Nathaniel Wesninski died in that basement in Baltimore with his father."
A wave of emotions washes over the group as they process the story. Some are visibly shaken, others sit in somber contemplation. Nicky springs into action, determined to break through the heavy atmosphere and bring a sense of levity to the group. His infectious laughter fills the room, and he tells a few jokes that elicit genuine smiles and chuckles from his friends. Slowly but surely, the mood begins to shift and lighten, thanks to Nicky's quick thinking and natural charm.
When the fire dies down and everyone heads into their cabins, Neil followed Andrew up the ladder to the roof lookout on their cabin. Andrew pulled out two cigarettes and lit them both before handing one to Neil.
They sat in companionable silence, the orange embers of their cigarettes glowing in the darkness. The cool breeze rustled through the trees, carrying with it a sense of peace that seemed to elude Neil even in the quiet of the night.
Andrew finally broke the silence, his voice barely above a whisper. "You didn't have to tell them."
Neil took a drag of his cigarette before responding, his gaze fixed on the distant stars twinkling above. "They were getting it all wrong, Andrew. I couldn't let them believe a distorted version of what happened."
"I know," Andrew acknowledged, his tone softening slightly. "But you don't owe them anything. Your past is yours to keep."
Neil turned to look at Andrew, the faint moonlight casting a soft glow on his features. "It's not just my past, Andrew. It's our past."
The weight of those words hung heavy between them, the unspoken truth of their shared history lingering in the air.