Work Text:
Rafael Barba was not, by nature, a man who shared. He didn't share his tactical insights until they were ready to be weaponized in court; he didn't share his umbrella if it meant his bespoke tailoring would suffer; and he most certainly did not share his food. In the Darwinian landscape of a New York childhood and the subsequent climb through the legal ranks, what was yours was yours by right of conquest or purchase.
Yet, as he sat in a dimly lit booth at a diner on 10th Avenue at 2:00 a.m., he found his entire philosophy under siege.
"You're doing it again," Olivia said, her voice a low, tired rasp that somehow still managed to be the most commanding sound in the room.
Rafael looked up from his plate. He had ordered a slice of New York cheesecake—dense, ivory-white, and topped with a single, perfectly glazed strawberry. It was his reward for a sixteen-hour day that had ended in a guilty plea from a particularly slippery defense contractor.
"Doing what, exactly? Enjoying my victory sugar in peace?"
"You're guarding the plate, Rafael. Your elbow is practically a barricade." Olivia leaned forward, her chin resting on her hand. She hadn't ordered anything but black coffee, and the steam was curling around her face like a soft-focus lens. "I just want one bite. For the sake of the partnership."
Rafael looked at the cheesecake. Then he looked at Olivia. She looked exhausted—there were faint shadows under her eyes that no amount of concealer could hide, and her hair was a messy tribute to the humidity outside.
"A 'bite' is a gateway drug, Detective," Rafael said, though he was already shifting his elbow. "First it’s the cheesecake. Then it’s my favorite fountain pen. Before I know it, you’ll be asking for half my closing arguments."
"I don't want your pens, Barba. They're too heavy. I just want the strawberry."
Rafael sighed, a theatrical sound that echoed in the nearly empty diner. He picked up his fork and, with the precision of a man performing a delicate surgical graft, sliced the strawberry in half. He slid the plate toward the center of the table.
"Fifty percent," he declared. "This is a communal property agreement, not a total surrender."
Olivia laughed, a genuine sound that made the fluorescent lights of the diner feel a little less harsh. She took the fork—his fork—and made quick work of her half.
"See? That wasn't so hard," she said, her eyes bright with victory. "Sharing. It’s a core human value. They teach it in kindergarten."
"I skipped kindergarten," Rafael muttered, taking the plate back. "I went straight to the part where you learn how to litigate for what’s yours."
But as he watched her take a sip of her coffee, he realized the "sharing" had already begun. It wasn't just the cake. It was the silence. It was the way they could sit in a booth at 2:00 a.m. and not feel the need to fill the air with case files or trauma. They were sharing the quiet, and for Rafael, that was a much more significant concession than a piece of fruit.
The rain began just as they stepped out onto the sidewalk. It wasn't a drizzle; it was a deluge, the kind of New York rain that turned the streets into a blurred, neon-lit watercolor.
"My car is six blocks away," Olivia said, pulling her jacket tighter.
"And mine is in the shop because the universe hates me," Rafael replied, looking at the wall of water. "I live four blocks from here. We can attempt a sprint, or we can stand here and wait for the city to develop an ark."
Olivia looked at the distance, then at Rafael’s charcoal wool coat. "Your coat will be ruined."
"The coat is replaceable. My patience with this weather is not." He stepped out into the rain, then turned back, holding his briefcase over his head like a makeshift shield. "Come on, Benson. We’re sharing the misery. My place is closer."
The "sprint" was more of a frantic, splashing dash. By the time they reached the foyer of his building, they were both soaked to the bone. Rafael’s hair, usually so perfectly coiffed, was plastered to his forehead, and Olivia was shivering, her leather jacket dripping a small pond onto the marble floor.
"Welcome to my humble, and currently very damp, abode," Rafael panted as they entered his apartment.
The space was dark, the only light coming from the city skyline through the floor-to-ceiling windows. It was a place of glass and steel and expensive solitude.
"You need to get out of those clothes," Rafael said, his voice dropping into a more grounded register. "I’m not having a Detective of the NYPD catch pneumonia on my watch. The paperwork would be endless."
"I don't have a change of clothes, Rafael."
"Sharing, remember? Core human value." He walked toward his bedroom and returned a moment later with a thick, navy blue silk robe and a pair of gray lounge pants. "The pants will be a little big, but they have a drawstring. The robe is... well, it’s comfortable."
Olivia took the clothes, her fingers brushing his. The contact was brief, but in the quiet of the apartment, it felt like a match being struck in a dark room.
"Thank you," she whispered.
"The bathroom is through there. I’ll... I’ll find something for myself."
When Olivia emerged from the bathroom ten minutes later, the apartment felt different. The "Barba" scent—sandalwood, old paper, and expensive scotch—was now mingling with the scent of his soap on her skin. She looked smaller in his clothes, the sleeves of the silk robe rolled up, the drawstring of the pants tied tight.
Rafael was standing in the kitchen, having changed into a simple black t-shirt and cotton pajama bottoms. He was pouring two glasses of a deep, peaty Islay malt.
"A peace offering," he said, handing her a glass. "To share the warmth."
They sat on the large velvet sofa, the rain still lashing against the glass behind them. For a while, they didn't speak. They just watched the city—the reds of the taillights, the whites of the office towers, the blues of the bridges.
"I've never seen your place like this," Olivia said, her voice soft. "It’s so... you."
"Controlled? Empty? Overpriced?"
"No. Quiet. It’s like a fortress." She turned to look at him, her knee brushing his. "Thank you for sharing it with me tonight."
Rafael set his glass down on the coffee table. He looked at her—the way the navy silk clung to her shoulders, the way her hair was still damp and dark. The "sharing" was no longer a joke or a necessity. It was an invitation.
"I spent a long time building this fortress, Olivia," he said, his voice a low vibration. "I didn't think I’d ever want to give anyone the keys."
He reached out, his hand sliding behind her neck, his thumb tracing the line of her jaw. Olivia didn't pull away. She leaned into the touch, her eyes searching his with a vulnerability that few people ever got to see.
"Maybe you don't have to give them away," she whispered. "Maybe you just have to... let someone in."
Rafael kissed her then. It wasn't the sharp, performative kiss of a man used to winning. It was a slow, tentative exploration—a sharing of breath and intent. Olivia responded with a fervor that surprised him, her hands finding the hem of his t-shirt, pulling him closer as if she were trying to bridge the gap between their two worlds.
The trip to the bedroom was seamless, a continuation of the night’s shared rhythm. Rafael found himself fascinated by the sight of her on his bed—his sheets, his pillows, his space.
As he moved over her, the sharing became literal. He shared the heat of his skin, the weight of his body, and the absolute focus of his attention. He explored her with a reverence that was rooted in the realization that this wasn't just a physical act; it was a surrender.
Olivia was an active participant, her hands guiding him, her voice a low, urgent soundtrack to their movements. She shared his pleasure, her body arching to meet his, her eyes never leaving his face. There was no "ADA" here, and no "Detective." There were just two people who had spent years guarding their perimeters finally deciding to lower the gates.
The intimacy was raw and explicit—the sound of skin against skin, the sharp indrawing of breath, the way the silk of the discarded robe felt beneath them. But it was also profoundly gentle in its tenderness. Rafael spent long moments simply holding her, kissing the pulse point at her throat, murmuring things he would never admit to in the light of day.
When the end came, it was a shared, breathless peak that left them both clinging to each other in the quiet of the room, the rain finally subsiding into a gentle patter against the glass.
The sun was a pale, filtered light through the curtains when Rafael woke up. He didn't feel the immediate, sharp need to check his phone or his watch. Instead, he felt the steady, calm weight of Olivia asleep against his side.
He watched her for a moment, the way her chest rose and fell, the way she looked perfectly at home in the middle of his fortress.
He realized then that sharing wasn't about losing something. It wasn't a zero-sum game where one person’s gain was another’s loss. It was an expansion.
Olivia stirred, her eyes opening slowly. She looked up at him and smiled—a sleepy, radiant thing.
"Still guarded?" she asked, her voice a low murmur.
Rafael leaned down and kissed her forehead, pulling the duvet tighter around both of them.
"The perimeter has been compromised," he whispered. "And I find I have no intention of calling for reinforcements."
Olivia laughed and buried her face in his chest. "Good. Because I’m not done sharing your bed yet."
"Take all the time you need, Detective," Rafael said, closing his eyes. "The world can wait for its half."