Actions

Work Header

Unexpected

Summary:

Emma Swan comes to Storybrooke expecting to find out whether her ten-year-old son needs rescuing from his adoptive mother. Henry is convinced Regina Mills is the Evil Queen, the town is cursed, and Emma is the only one who can save them. In a canon divergance, we meet Evan, Emma's oldest friend and roommate the night Henry arrives.

Evan never expected to find himself caught between two mothers, a boy with a storybook, and a town that is considerably more complicated than anyone gives it credit for and he certainly never expected to fall for Regina Mills. But as Emma begins to discover that Henry's stories might be true, something unexpected happens. Henry begins to see his mother differently. The boy who once wanted to defeat the Evil Queen starts to realize he doesn't necessarily want to lose Regina. And Regina, who has spent so long terrified of losing her son, is finally beginning to rebuild the relationship she thought was slipping away, just as Emma becomes convinced she needs to intervene.
The curse may be real and Regina's past may be darker than Evan can imagine, but the family slowly taking shape around Regina is real too.
Slow burn, family and fluff.

Notes:

A Note on Canon Divergence
Unexpected is a Season 1 AU of Once Upon a Time and serves as the origin story for Unbroken. While the story begins with the familiar premise of Emma Swan arriving in Storybrooke, several important changes to the show's canon shape this version of events.
A few things to know before reading:
Rumplestiltskin / Mr. Gold: Gold is not the secret architect of the Dark Curse, nor is he orchestrating events to reunite with his son. Regina's decision to cast the curse is her own, and its purpose is rooted in her desire for control and her own happy ending.
Baelfire: Bae does not exist in this universe. Consequently, Gold's history, motivations, and involvement in the curse differ substantially from the television series. Henry’s father isn’t revealed.
Sheriff Graham: Graham does not die. He remains Storybrooke's sheriff, with Emma working alongside him as his deputy. His continued presence changes several important relationships and events.
Evan: Evan is an original character and Emma's longtime best friend. His presence introduces a different perspective on Storybrooke, particularly regarding Regina Mills, Henry, and the question of whether someone's past defines who they are.
Regina, Henry, and Emma: Their relationships will not follow the same trajectory as the show. Henry's feelings toward Regina, Emma's understanding of the curse, and the complicated relationship between both mothers are central to this version of the story.
The timeline: Season 1 unfolds over a longer period, allowing relationships and events to develop differently. The story also extends beyond the breaking of the curse rather than treating that moment as its conclusion.
A final note: Some familiar events will happen differently, some may not happen at all, and others will have consequences that extend well beyond their original roles in canon. The intention isn't to erase the characters or their histories, but to explore how changing a few important circumstances might lead them somewhere unexpected.
Welcome to a slightly different Storybrooke.

Chapter Text

 

Their apartment smelled like garlic, basil, and the comforting illusion of normalcy. Evan was in the kitchen of their little Boston place, stirring sauce with dramatic flair, a Coors Light on the counter, and Classic Rock playing in the background. Emma lounged on the couch in her tank top and jeans, watching him move expertly around the kitchen, thankful to not be involved. They'd agreed long ago that Emma's safest role in the kitchen was not being in it. The further she stayed from the stove, the better their odds of eating something edible. Fortunately for them both, Evan had learned to cook young. Emma once asked how a foster kid who bounced around as much as he did ever managed it.

"Easy," he'd said, sliding a pan onto the burner without looking up. "It made me more valuable to keep around. Families like kids who pull their weight. Being helpful bought me time. Being invisible kept me safe."

Emma hadn't pushed, because she didn't have to. She knew that survival trick. Knew it in her bones. They'd recognized that about each other early, two kids shaped by too many front doors and too few people who stayed. Trust came faster than either expected. Now, with a glass of wine in hand, Emma found herself marveling, not for the first time, at how well they'd turned out. 

At the stove, Evan dragged a hand through his hair with a sigh, his beer sweating on the counter. His hair was the same sandy-gold shade as hers, though his never quite cooperated, short, messy, perpetually defiant. Back then, trust had not arrived gently. It had clicked into place out of necessity. His shoulder between her and whoever was yelling, her hand on his sleeve when he looked ready to disappear into himself. By the time Emma aged out two years after him, Evan had a spare room, a TV, and a place for her if she wanted it. He never made it sound like a rescue. That was why she came. Well-adjusted was probably generous. But they paid rent on time, kept plants alive sometimes, and knew who would answer at two in the morning. That counted. People were always trying to name them: siblings, exes, roommates, something. Emma usually let them exhaust themselves. Evan usually just said family and moved on. 

He glanced at the simmering pot, then at her. "Remind me how I got roped into this again?" She convinced him to make Italian because it was her birthday even though she knew he'd started counting his carbs.

"I'm out of practice on pasta…If this sauce turns out too salty, I'm blaming whatever chaos the universe sends our way tonight because another trip around the sun apparently means garlic bread," he called out to Emma.

"You say that like dinner isn't usually the calm before the storm. You know we always get interrupted." she yelled back and gets up to meet him in the kitchen.

At the stove, Evan turned his head to her, " And whose fault is that? I work from home, it not my clients that are needing to be chased all over town." Emma rolled her eyes at him. Evan chuckled, "You know I'm right. I'm just saying—"

Of course, the next sound in the air was a knock at the door. 

Emma opened it, and there he was. A kid, maybe ten or eleven. Brown hair. Brown eyes. Book clutched to his chest like a shield. Henry beamed, "Are you Emma Swan?"

Emma paused and answered slowly, "Yeah. Who mwants to know?"

"Me. I'm Henry. I'm your son."

The knock at the door had barely faded before Evan appeared behind her still holding the sauce spoon and blinking at the sight of the kid. Emma turned to him, “Um, He says he’s my son.” Henry shifted the book under one arm and looked past her at Evan with open curiosity. “Are you my dad?!” Henry asked with added excitement, clearly not expecting to see Evan there. 

Evan just stared, and then he found his voice, “Uh… absolutely not.” He had been friends with Emma since their time in foster care, so of course he was there when Henry was born…When Emma decided to give him up…When she finished out the jail sentence left behind by Henry’s actual father. Evan fucking hated that guy. 

“You better let him in Em, it’s like eight pm kid, where are your parents?” Evan closed the door behind him and Henry took a seat at the kitchen counter. “How old are you?” 

“I’m ten, well, eleven, in February.” Henry replied, even though it was September, without looking up. He was already flipping through the giant ornate book he walked in with and Evan stared at Emma, eyes widening with a look that said,  Timing lines up… 

“Okay Henry, let’s say we believe you. Why are you here?” Emma began. Across the kitchen Evan grabbed his cell off the table. “What are you doing?” she redirected her attention to her best friend for a second. 

“Calling the police because there is a random ten year old at our doorstep?” Evan said holding up his phone like this was obvious. 

“You can’t call the police! Please! I need Emma’s help. Not the police.” Henry exclaimed, all calm out of his voice. “Emma has to come back with me. I live in Storybrooke. In Maine. My mom adopted me when I was a baby.” He looked at Emma. “But you’re my real mom.”

Emma’s jaw tightened almost imperceptibly at that as Henry opened the book. The pages were thick, filled with elaborate illustrations that looked older than the book itself. Castles. Forests. Queens. Knights. Evan saw titles of stories he knew from his childhood as Henry flipped through the pages: Snow White, Cinderella, Little Red Riding Hood, Pinocchio.  

“Everyone in Storybrooke is in here,” Henry continued. “They’re fairy-tale characters. They just don’t know it because they’re cursed. They can’t remember who they are.”

Emma closed her eyes briefly at this revelation, but Henry was undeterred. “The Evil Queen cast the curse and sent everyone to this world to ruin their happy endings. All the stories in here, they’ve all been messed up in Storybrooke. No one remembers who they are. Everyone is trapped.” 

Emma pointed toward the open book, “Okay Henry, I am going to stop you right there. That sounds like a very cool story, but…” 

“It’s not a story!” Henry cut in. He flipped several pages quickly and turned the book toward her. A drawing of Snow White and Prince Charming filled the page. On the next, a dark haired woman in a sweeping violet gown stood beneath a black sky, magic swirls curling around her hands. Henry tapped the picture of the solitary woman. “That’s my mom. Regina. She is the Evil Queen.” 

Emma just stared at him. Then at the book. “That’s your mom?” 

Henry nodded. “She is the mayor of the town.”

Evan leaned over Henry’s shoulder to look at the picture. He looked up at Emma, a considering expression on his face, and Emma rolled her eyes at him. Henry turned a few pages back and stopped on an illustration of a baby being placed inside an ornate wooden wardrobe. “ You are Snow White’s daughter. She and Prince Charming sent you here before the curse struck so you could come back and save everyone by breaking the curse. You are the Savior.”

Evan’s eyes went wide at the word. “See Em, you worried you’d never reach your full potential.” Evan chuckled at his own joke, but nobody joined him. Emma just glared and Henry was already turning to a new page. “Uh, Henry, right?” Evan asked, his tone changing, “Can I see the book?”

Henry reluctantly slid it over in front of Evan and he began to flip through the beautifully illustrated pages until something made him stop. “Emma…” he said with his fingertips lightly touching one of the pictures. A man and a woman, in the middle of a nursery. The woman was cradling a small baby at her chest, wrapped in a white blanket, with the name Emma embroidered at the top. “You need to see this.”

Emma leaned over Evan and for the first time since Henry walked in, the sarcasm and armor dropped completely off her face. She stared at the picture, the blanket, and then at Henry. It wasn’t even the name. The blanket in the picture looked exactly like the one Evan had come to know over the years. The only thing Emma had from her parents. The blanket they left her in. 

Henry’s whole expression brightened as he watched her face change. “See? I told you.” 

Emma straightened sharply, “No, you told me I’m Snow White and Prince Charming’s daughter and your mother is the Evil Queen. What you have proven is that there is a book that coincidentally has a blanket that looks like one I have.” 

Evan looked from Henry to Emma, and damnit if he didn’t see the similarities. “Okay, I know that I believe someone in Maine is missing you, so if we can’t call the cops, how about we get you home? Does your mom know you are here?”

Henry’s expression shifted a little. For the first time, he really looked like a little kid. “My mom is probably mad, but not because she loves me, just because she doesn't know where I am. All she cares about is keeping the curse going.” 

Emma let out a short breath through her nose, “I highly doubt that is true. Your mom probably has every police station in the northeast looking for you by now.” 

Henry looked down, “Yeah, cuz I’m her prisoner too. You have to come with me. I’ll go home, but only if you take me there. Otherwise, I’ll just come back next weekend.” Henry’s mouth pulled into the faintest satisfied smile, like he was already counting that as a win and then he looked over at Evan “You’re coming too.”

“Oh, please, you think I’m somehow not tagging along to see how this plays out? Plus where Emma goes I go.” Evan said, grabbing their jackets from the hall closet.  The three of them piled into Emma’s yellow bug and took off toward Maine, Henry babbling about the town as if trying to fit everything in before they crossed state lines.