Actions

Work Header

BEAUTIFUL LIAR

Summary:

Everybody wants to be somebody. Diana wants to be unforgettable.
New York, 1983. Diana is young, beautiful, and hungry for something bigger than herself. As the singer of THE VIOLETS, she is ready to conquer the world, and she has no intention of letting anyone stand in her way.
She wants the spotlight. The recognition. The kind of fame that makes people remember your name.
But somewhere between late-night parties, rising ambition and two brothers, Diana begins to lose sight of where the performance ends and reality begins.
Two brothers. One lie.
Some stars shine. Others burn everything in their path.

Notes:

Hi hi !
The story you are about to read is told from the alternating perspectives of several characters.
I’ve always wished I had been young during the 80s. My mother experienced that era in her teenage years and passed it on to me through its culture—the music, films, books, and artists. So, I wanted to try writing a story with a vibe that transports you back to the past...
PLEASE keep in mind that English is not my native language and that I am a beginner; be sure to check the tags for trigger warnings, even tho they might change, maybe I'll add new ones with the story progression.
I’ve also created a playlist, check it out:
https://open.spotify.com/playlist/5sOlLwDJmdf9de7HO6g7sC

Chapter 1: THE GIRL WHO WANTS EVERYTHING - Diana

Chapter Text

New York City, October 1983.

There were three things I could do better than most people: lie, sing, and make men believe they had a chance with me.

In that order, probably.

I had never considered these talents particularly incompatible. On the contrary, they had served me rather well so far, even if I wasn't quite where I wanted to be just yet. My apartment, located on the second floor of a rather run-down building in Brooklyn, smelled of stale cigarettes, cheap perfume, and coffee that had been sitting there since the day before. The radiator had been banging against the wall for a good twenty minutes, as though it were trying to tell me something, but I was ignoring it. I had other concerns, namely deciding whether my hair needed one last brush or whether its natural volume was already spectacular enough for the evening.

I stood in front of the cracked mirror in my bathroom, a record playing in the background, blasting Play That Funky Music by Wild Cherry — my favourite song since I was sixteen — with a lipstick in my fingers and my lips slightly parted. The tube was almost empty. I had bought that exact shade at a Brooklyn drugstore three weeks earlier, pretending to the saleswoman that I was looking for something subtle. She had laughed, and so had I, because we both knew that this deep, bloody red was anything but subtle. I applied it slowly, taking care not to go over the edges, before stepping back slightly to admire the result. My hair fell in cascades over my shoulders, thick, brown, almost black under the yellowish bathroom light. My skin had that terracotta complexion, a golden brown with copper undertones that I thought looked particularly lovely in natural light, and my hazel eyes seemed lighter whenever I wore enough eyeliner. I tilted my head slightly, studying my reflection from another angle. Not bad, girl.

I had never understood girls who claimed they didn't care about their appearance. It was a particularly stupid form of lying. The world looked before it listened; you had to give it something worth looking at. At twenty-three, I still had no record deal, no record, and no pictures in magazines. Not even an invitation to a party where someone important might have remembered my name. And yet, I already had a pretty clear idea of the life I wanted to lead. I wanted dresses I couldn't afford, apartments with huge windows overlooking Manhattan, photographers asking me to turn my head slightly, and journalists writing my name without having to check how to spell it. I wanted to walk into a room and feel conversations come to a halt, to be recognised in the street, to hear my songs playing in taxis and find my face on the covers of magazines I casually flipped through at newsstands. I didn't just want to make it in music. I wanted to become a personality, one of those women people talked about even when they weren't around. I wanted girls to copy my hairstyle, my clothes, the way I did my makeup. I wanted my name to be associated with something, with an era, with an image no one could ever quite reproduce.

Three knocks against my door pulled me out of my thoughts.

"Diana!"

Sam's voice travelled across the little apartment before I even had time to answer.

"If you're here to tell me you've found a million dollars, come on in!"

Samantha Blake walked in without waiting for an invitation, just as she had been doing ever since we became friends. She considered my apartment an extension of her own and didn't seem particularly concerned with the possibility that I might want to be alone. She placed her bag on the little table by the window before looking around at the mess, the clothes abandoned on a chair, the magazines piled up near the bed, and the two coffee cups desperately waiting to be washed.

"Did you sleep with your shoes on again?"

"Why?"

"I'm serious."

"So am I. You look so pretty today."

She rolled her eyes. Sam was twenty-two, with lovely red hair and a delicate face with fine features. She often gave the impression of being somewhere else, lost in thoughts no one else had access to. She was intelligent, reserved, and particularly observant, observant enough to notice the things other people preferred to ignore. That was probably why I loved her so much. She knew me well enough to recognise my lies, even the good ones, and could always tell when I was broke, when I hadn't eaten, and when I was pretending not to care about something that was eating me alive. It was annoying, but I supposed friendship came with a few inconveniences.

"Have you eaten?" she asked, taking off her coat.

"Why is everyone asking me that today? Do I look like a rejected Muppet?"

Sam didn't answer immediately. She simply rummaged through her bag before pulling out a package wrapped in paper.

"Because you've probably forgotten, and I refuse to watch you pass out on stage. Here."

I took the sandwich she handed me with a grateful smile.

"You're an angel."

"I know. It's exhausting."

I sat on the edge of my bed and started eating while she walked over to the window.

"Where's everyone else?"

"Nick and Vince are already at the club. Adrian left twenty minutes ago."

I smiled when I heard the last name.

"Is he still as charming as ever?"

"More than ever."

Adrian Monroe, twenty-four, guitarist and, in his own opinion, the rightful owner of THE VIOLETS. Everyone called him Ace. He had founded the band with Nick Jackson long before I came along, back when they played in little bars for a few dollars and spent their nights writing songs in apartments that were far too small. Nick had written most of their early songs, while Ace had helped build their musical identity through his guitar work and arrangements. They had worked hard to give this band a life, and I knew that perfectly well. The problem was that ever since I joined, things had changed, and Ace had never really learned to appreciate that.

"Think he's going to complain about the setlist again?" I asked.

Sam gave me an amused look.

"You know perfectly well he doesn't like you changing songs five minutes before going on stage."

"It's not my fault some songs need improving."

"They're Nick's songs."

"And I'm the one singing them."

She stared at me for a few seconds before shaking her head.

"One day, you're actually going to drive him insane."

"He should thank me. I give him a reason to live."

I finished my sandwich, grabbed my bag, and quickly checked that I'd packed my cigarettes. We were supposed to meet at the Mercury Room, a small club on the Lower East Side where THE VIOLETS were playing that night. A cab would have cost too much, so we took the subway instead, squeezed between students, workers, and a few guys who seemed to have already started their evening. Sam told me a story about a synthesizer she'd spotted in a music shop, but I was only half listening. I was thinking about our gig, the venue, and the possibility of an interesting face in the audience. I had learned to recognise people who could be useful. Producers, journalists, photographers, men who knew other men. Sometimes all it took was a conversation, a smile, or a phone number scribbled on a piece of paper to open a door. I didn't know which door I was supposed to find yet, but I was certain it existed somewhere.

The Mercury Room was located in the basement of a building that had probably seen better days. There was something desperately pretentious about the place, with its torn posters, graffiti-covered walls, and red lighting that made everyone look slightly sick. It was the kind of club where people came to pretend they had discovered something before everyone else. I would have liked to say we were that discovery. For now, we were mostly just five people who had agreed to play for an insulting amount of money.

"Finally!" Vince called out as we walked down the stairs.

Vincent Callahan was sitting behind his drum kit, a cigarette tucked between his lips and his brown hair a mess. He raised his arms when he saw me.

"Our big star has arrived."

I took off my coat with a smile.

"I know you're happy to see me."

"I was starting to think you'd abandoned us to marry a millionaire."

"He'd have to be interesting first."

Nick burst out laughing from the other side of the stage. Sitting on an amplifier, his bass resting against his leg, he was casually tuning his instrument. He had a magnificent afro and was wearing a wide-collared shirt, high-waisted trousers, and a jacket whose colours looked as though they'd come straight out of a seventies Motown photograph. Nick had that natural warmth that made you want to tell him things. He was funny, sociable, patient, and probably the most reasonable person in the band, which wasn't particularly difficult.

"Have you eaten?" he asked me.

I turned towards Sam, who had just put her bag down beside the keyboard.

"Not this question again?"

Nick smiled.

"You look like you're about to pass out."

I planted a kiss on his cheek.

"You're my favourite."

He rolled his eyes.

"You say that to everyone."

"That's because I have a lot of love to give."

Vince placed a hand over his heart.

"She's lying."

I gave him an exaggeratedly offended look.

"Nobody asked for your opinion, Callahan."

He laughed before picking up his drumsticks again.

Sam was starting to check the connections on her keyboard when I heard a voice behind me.

"Can we start rehearsing, or are we waiting for everyone to finish putting on a show?"

I didn't even need to turn around to know it was Ace. Adrian Monroe was standing near the amplifiers, his guitar slung over his shoulder. He had long, slightly wavy brown hair framing his face and was wearing a dark jacket with a pair of worn-out jeans. There was something naturally theatrical about the way he carried himself, even when he wasn't making the slightest effort. He was handsome, he knew it, and he would probably rather die than let me tell him so.

"Hello to you too, sweetheart."

"Don't start."

I tilted my head slightly.

"I've missed you."

He looked at me without expression.

"You're late."

I checked my watch.

"Seven minutes."

"Twenty."

"Your watch is fast."

Nick coughed to hide a laugh while Vince lowered his head behind his drums. Ace placed his guitar on its stand and ran a hand through his hair.

"You're insufferable, Coleman."

I smiled even wider.

"And yet, you keep coming back to see me."

He ignored me and announced that we were going to start the third song again from the beginning. I grimaced slightly, which earned me an exasperated sigh.

Rehearsal lasted almost an hour. Nick handled most of the arrangements and had an almost instinctive way of putting songs together. He could add a bass line, change a rhythm, or alter a chord progression until everything made sense. Ace, on the other hand, was much more demanding when it came to the guitars and could spend twenty minutes working on a transition that lasted only a few seconds simply because one note didn't sound quite right to him. Sam worked on the synthesizers and harmonies. She had a musical sensibility I found fascinating, even if we rarely agreed on the direction certain songs should take. As for Vince, he seemed to consider the drums an excellent excuse to make as much noise as possible. And me, I sang. I gave a voice to everything they built, a personality to the songs, and something for the audience to hold on to. At least, that was how I preferred to see it.

We were working on one of Nick's songs when I decided to interrupt the rehearsal.

"Wait. I think we should slow down during the last part and let the song breathe before the final chorus."

Ace immediately looked up from his guitar.

"No."

I blinked.

"Excuse me?"

"I said no."

I crossed my arms.

"I heard you perfectly well."

He sighed before adjusting his guitar against his body.

"It's a band song, Diana. Not your little cabaret act."

I felt my smile freeze slightly.

"I didn't know you'd become a singer."

Nick placed a hand on his bass.

"Ace."

But he seemed determined to carry on.

"I'm just saying not everything needs to be changed so you can have your little moment in the spotlight."

I stared at him for a few seconds before shrugging.

"I didn't realise suggesting a musical change had become a crime."

Sam stepped in before the conversation could escalate any further. She calmly explained that slowing things down could work and that it might be interesting to try it without changing the entire arrangement. Nick nodded. Ace ran a hand through his hair, visibly annoyed, before giving in.

"Fine. We'll try it once."

I gave him a satisfied smile.

"See? Wasn't that difficult?"

He shot me a dark look.

"Sing, Diana."

I laughed softly and returned to my place in front of the microphone.

The owner of the Mercury Room had promised us forty dollars for the evening. Forty dollars to be split between five people, after hauling our equipment, rehearsing for hours, and agreeing to play in his damp basement. At first, I thought he was joking. When I asked him if he was serious, he simply shrugged and explained that it was all he could offer. I pointed out that some waitresses made more than that in one night. He told me I could always become a waitress. I gave him my prettiest smile and explained that I'd rather sing. He laughed, and I didn't find it funny. I had learned very young that you shouldn't always let people see when they've hurt you. Some of them enjoyed it. At sixteen, I had left Brooklyn with a bag of clothes, a few crumpled bills, and the certainty that I would never set foot in that house again. Since then, I had gone through one odd job after another, temporary rooms, unpleasant bosses, and men who promised a lot and delivered nothing. I had learned to pay my rent, take care of myself, and never rely on anyone else to get me out of a bad situation. I hadn't gone through all that just to give up over forty dollars.

At ten thirty, the show began. The room was almost empty, and I had to make a considerable effort not to let my disappointment show on my face. A few people were smoking near the bar, two girls were talking at a table, and a man was reading his newspaper as though he were waiting for a bus rather than watching a concert. Sam leaned towards me to ask if I'd seen how many people were there. I quickly glanced around the room before answering that there must have been seven. She reminded me that she could only count five. I explained that the guy near the exit counted as two because he had a big head. She stifled a laugh and shook her head. Behind us, Nick gave his bass one last tune-up, Vince spun a drumstick between his fingers, and Sam adjusted the volume on her synthesizers. Ace checked his tuning with almost religious seriousness. I took a breath, straightened my shoulders, and stepped onto the stage. The microphone immediately crackled, causing an unpleasant squeal to come through the speakers. Someone in the audience sighed. I briefly closed my eyes before smiling.

"Good evening, New York."

My voice echoed through the room with a slight distortion. Nobody answered. I tilted my head, amused.

"You're a little shy tonight."

A girl near the bar raised her glass. That was enough.

"Well, that's alright. I'm not."

Vince struck the first beat on his drums, followed by Nick's bass and Ace's guitar. Sam's synthesizers filled out the opening notes and, almost immediately, something changed in the room. It was no longer just a poorly lit basement with sticky tables and a few strangers who probably had no intention of remembering us the next morning. When I sang, I wasn't there anymore. I wasn't the girl counting her bills before paying rent, the one working one odd job after another, smiling at the wrong men and pretending she wasn't hungry. I was Diana Coleman, and for a few minutes, the world had no choice but to listen to me. I sang as though the room were packed, as though hundreds of people were hanging on every word, and as though the front row was filled with photographers ready to capture my face. I sang for the magazines I had only ever secretly read at newsstands, for the photographs nobody had taken yet, for the dresses I couldn't afford, and for everyone who had ever looked at me as though I wasn't destined to become somebody. During the final chorus, I noticed a girl in the front row taking a small notebook out of her bag. She was writing something. I had no idea what, but I immediately straightened my shoulders and gave her an even bigger smile. When the song ended, a few scattered claps filled the room. I bowed as though I had just sold out Madison Square Garden.

"Thank you, New York. You've been wonderful."

The man with the newspaper folded it up. The girl near the bar whistled, and I winked at her before turning back towards the band. Nick was smiling, Vince was tapping his drumsticks together, and Sam looked pleased. Ace, however, wasn't smiling. I noticed, of course. I always noticed.

After the show, we gathered near the bar. Nick was ordering beers for everyone while Vince told an endless story about a girl he'd met the night before at another club. Sam was talking to the owner about the faulty equipment, and Ace was smoking near the exit, standing slightly apart from the rest of the band. I decided to join him.

"You played alright tonight," I told him, leaning against the wall beside him.

He slowly turned his head.

"Thanks. That's very sweet of you."

"I know."

He took a drag of his cigarette before speaking again, without looking at me.

"You know, this band existed before you."

I stayed silent for a moment.

"I know."

He reminded me that he and Nick had spent two years building something, playing in places where nobody showed up, writing songs, rehearsing, and trying to find their sound. I knew the story. I'd heard it enough times to be able to tell it for him.

"So stop acting like everything revolves around you," he concluded.

I felt a slight irritation rising inside me, but I didn't let him see it. I hadn't founded THE VIOLETS, I hadn't written their first songs, and I hadn't spent two years playing in basements with Nick before someone decided to let me take the microphone. But I was here now. And I certainly wasn't going to stay in the shadows just to protect somebody else's ego.

"I never said the band didn't exist before me."

Ace stubbed out his cigarette.

"You don't have to say it."

I turned my head slightly towards him, a smile tugging at the corner of my lips.

"Maybe the band just needed me."

He stared at me for a few seconds before shaking his head.

"You're unbelievable."

I shrugged.

"I know."

He walked away without answering and rejoined Nick and Vince.

Sam appeared beside me a few moments later. She had that amused expression she always wore whenever she witnessed one of my arguments with Ace.

"Did you annoy him again?"

I took a sip of my beer before answering that, as far as I was concerned, he had already been annoyed when I arrived. She smiled and explained that he was afraid I was going to steal his place. I turned towards her.

"I don't want his place."

She raised her eyebrows slightly, clearly waiting for me to continue. I looked at the empty stage, the cables abandoned on the floor, the amplifiers still humming faintly, and the microphone resting on its stand. I had never wanted to be a guitarist, a founder, or even the person who decided the band's musical direction. What I wanted was much simpler and much bigger at the same time.

"I want something better."

Sam burst out laughing before briefly resting her head against my shoulder. I smiled at her and took one last look around the room. It was almost completely empty now. The girl with the notebook had left, and I had no idea what she had written. Still, a part of me clung to that tiny possibility, ridiculous as it might have been. Maybe she knew someone. Maybe she'd liked our music. Maybe she'd tell someone else about us. We had to start somewhere.

It was past midnight when we left the club. Nick and Vince decided to go for a drink somewhere else, probably somewhere Vince could find another girl to tell his stories to. Sam had to go home, and Ace had disappeared without bothering to say goodbye. I walked a few metres with Sam before we went our separate ways. She asked me to call her the next day because she knew perfectly well I would forget to eat and would probably spend the entire day looking for work or chasing after someone who could get us a gig. I laughed and promised I would, even though we both knew I wasn't particularly reliable when it came to keeping that kind of promise. She kissed me on the cheek before heading towards the subway.

I was left alone on the pavement, my hands tucked into the pockets of my coat. The November air was cold, the streets were damp, and the shop lights reflected off the asphalt. A taxi drove past me, splashing a little water onto my shoes. I swore before bursting out laughing, because I had no intention of going home looking as miserable as I sometimes felt. I was twenty-three years old, with forty dollars to split between five people, a tiny apartment, and a band that didn't even know how to fill a room yet. But I had a voice, a face, legs that could carry me a very long way, and an ambition nobody around me seemed to truly understand. I wanted interviews, photographs, magazine covers. I wanted to be recognised in the street, invited to Manhattan's most exclusive parties, and photographed on the arm of men whose names would turn heads. I wanted people to talk about me, to love me and hate me enough to keep talking about me long after I had left the room. I wanted to become the face of an era, and I had absolutely no intention of settling for anything less.

I wanted 1984 to be my year, and I had absolutely no intention of asking anyone's permission.

My name was Diana Coleman. They didn't know it yet, but they were going to have to learn to remember it.