Actions

Work Header

Colors of Healing

Summary:

Creating is a better outlet than violence. I firmly believe this, but I don't know what I'm supposed to do with these emotions…with old wounds that won't heal no matter how much time has passed. (Long one-shot set in the five-year time gap in route A of NieR: Replicant. Spoilers for The Red and the Black short story.)

Notes:

This story was originally written to answer one question, that question being, "Why does the protagonist end up letting his hair down in the second half of the game?" What this long one-shot turned into, while it answers that question that didn't necessarily need answering beyond a single sentence, is an exploration of what it takes to overcome trauma and forgive. Sometimes that isn't always possible. However, I have learned from my own experiences that hatred often turns people into monsters and true healing isn't possible with hatred as a factor. I don't know what else to say about this work other than that. Re-playing Nier Replicant just brought this out of my brain. I hope you guys will enjoy it and be able to gain something meaningful out of it. Thank you for reading. Best wishes and God bless you all.

Disclaimer: NieR Replicant is a property of Square Enix and does not belong to me. I only own my original character that was created for this work.

Warnings: This story heavily references the NierR short-story, The Red and the Black, which means there will be mentions of sensitive subjects such as child-abuse and molestation. The story is rated M for that alone. Additionally, there will be heavy blood/gore toward the end of this massive one-shot. There were points while writing this that I considered splitting this one-shot in half, but ultimately chose not to for the overall cohesion of the piece, so it's over 15,000 words. Lastly, this is an emotionally heavy story that takes place in the gap between the first and second half of Route A in the game. There will be no major spoilers for anything in the game beyond that point in the narrative.

Extra note: In this work, the nameless protagonist of the game is given the name "Nier" and he is eighteen in the main narrative of this work. The OC character is twenty. Italic sections are first person narrations outside of the main narrative taking place. Okay. That should be everything worth mentioning. Enjoy!

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:


Colors of Healing


Three years have come and gone in a blur of aimless tasks given out of a strange mixture of pity and desperation. Shades are increasing in number at a rapid pace. It's likely that trade with places like Seafront won't be possible soon, and any excursions through the Northern Plains for game are a gamble.

Most of the men sent out for hunts don't return alive.

But I do. I must.

My feet hurry along familiar paths. Carcasses of shadow fall at my feet in wild sprays of blood.

It's not enough. It's never enough.

…

The blade I've carried for so long has rusted from overuse. Weiss keeps badgering me to fix it or find a replacement, but no one in the village has the proper materials or skillset necessary for the repairs, and trips to the Junk Heap aren't feasible with the overabundance of Shades inhabiting the plains. I'm training with a spear now to counteract that problem, but progress is slow going.

It would be suicide to use it in a real battle with those monsters.

Dying isn't an option.

Getting a new sword isn't either. I don't have enough gold to make the purchase responsibly.

So, as far as I'm concerned, a rusted weapon is better than no weapon at all.

Weiss disagrees vehemently but he can't change my mind. All he can do is complain about using his arcane magics for menial hunting every chance he gets. It's a little annoying, but with Yonah missing and Kainé sealed within the village library, his presence is the only constant I have.

Emil sends letters every so often to check in and share little updates about his research efforts. He's determined to find a way to reverse the petrification curse on his eyes and free Kainé, but he's found next to nothing so far. With the Shade situation being what it is throughout all the villages and towns in the area, he can't visit me safely, and the needs of the townspeople keep me moving constantly.

Popola tells me I need to slow down, but I can't. Not even for a second.

…

Emil is doing what he can. He believes a breakthrough will come in time, and I believe in him.

…

But time is a cruel thing.

There's no holding on to it – no way to make it stall.

…

I'm taller now. Stronger.

And yet none of that progress is enough.

…

It's maddening - this weakness that prevents me from tearing every last Shade apart.

…

The Shadowlord took my sister from me, and I won't be able to rest peacefully until she's home safe again.

…

But time is a cruel thing.

I don't even know if she's still…

…

No. I won't let myself think that.

…

Yonah is alive. I know she's still breathing…still waiting for me.

But I can't save her as I am now. I can't save Kainé either.

Her frozen expression of quiet agony greets me every...single...day.

…

It's another agonizing reminder of my failure – my weakness.

…

I visit her hut outside of the Aerie as often as I can just to touch the petals of the Lunar Tears hanging along the old, crayon portrait of her grandmother. Weiss is usually with me to fill the silence with unnecessary quips about her foul language or how we should save some of the gold we earn from the odd jobs we're given to buy her a decent outfit.

It's his way of reassuring us both that she'll be back - that her absence isn't permanent.

I want to believe that. I do believe that.

…

I just believe a little less with each day that passes.

…

Sometimes, when I can't sleep, I sneak away from the village to make the trip to the hut alone. A floral scent clings to every inch of her old home, one that's different from the fragrance of Lunar Tears yet comforting all the same. Her fierce eyes and soft smile return to me in the silence, followed by the rough yet lovely timbre of her voice hurling half-hearted insults and endless waves of sarcasm. She'd been a powerful and ferocious presence. Crass. Abrasive.

Our battles together showed the contrast between the woman she was and the warrior she had to be to live on for any stretch of time. She moved with a subtle elegance, like every strike against a Shade was part of an intricate dance of unpredictable steps.

Back then there were moments I stopped fighting just to watch her.

She was beautiful and alive.

…

Now she's encased in stone with her expression stuck in a solemn lament that crushes my soul a little more every time I'm forced to visit the library to request tasks from Popola.

…

Alone in Kainé's hut…I break.

I lay across the wooden plank that served as her bed and weep until I'm spent.

…

I miss her.

…

Sometimes… I miss her more than I miss Yonah.

…

What kind of brother does that make me? Nothing should be more important to me than finding her. Nothing should inhibit me from tearing the world asunder until I get her back...because she never should have been taken in the first place.

…

All I wanted was to stop the bad things from happening - to hold on to the family I had left.

There was no task too demeaning or too low for me to sink to, and no amount of suffering was too great for me to stomach.

I'd do it all again and more to get Yonah back.

…

Time isn't like money. It can't be saved or wasted because it moves forward without pause regardless of how we choose to spend it. No one told us how much of it we're allowed to have either, so it's practically impossible to make the most of it.

Every choice we make is subject to time, and it holds no pity for us.

It's cruel.

So unfathomably cruel.

…

I train, fish constantly to keep myself and the villagers fed, and kill every Shade I come across with a rage that's familiar yet foreign…as if the feeling itself is a memory I'd rather shut out of my heart completely.

But memory is another cruel thing. Worse than time.

Time moves.

Memories stagnate and fester. They're wounds that don't heal unless they disappear altogether.

Even the good ones can rot a man's soul.

…

Such memories are why these three years have been such a miserable, frustrating existence.

My body is a slave to time. My soul is a prisoner of memory.

There's no satisfaction or comfort to find beyond the constant company of a book.


At the squawking of a perturbed rooster, Nier awakens, his heart rate climbing in a fierce panic before the following quiet forces it to sink into a calmer rhythm.

There's no danger to address – no immediate problem to solve.

He heaves out a shaky breath and carefully pulls back the thin blanket covering his body while glancing around at the familiar space, a home that holds a torrent of memories, good and bad, that he'd rather not think about in the silence of the early morning. He knows that his mystical book companion, Grimoire Weiss, is waiting in Yonah's room for any signs of his movement to use as a cue to dramatically announce his presence.

The book doesn't sleep. He can fall into a meditative state for a few hours, but it usually ends before Nier wakes up.

Right around now is when the young man should yawn to give Weiss the go ahead to come downstairs, but he doesn't.

For a few fleeting seconds, he basks in the stillness, in the emptiness encasing his fragile heart in another layer of stone that hardens his resolve to keep going even though it's becoming increasingly difficult to hold on to any hope.

Another day without them.

Nier leans over the side of his bed to open the dresser where he keeps his usual hunting clothes. His hands clutch at the fabric lazily while his eyes rove over thinning threads along the hem of the shirt he was supposed to patch up the previous evening but didn't.

He's not sure if there's a point to it…to any of this anymore.

But the usual movements of his routine are so hardwired into his body that he's in the house's small washroom before his mind registers that he got out of bed. He undresses, tosses his night tunic and the loose work pants he'd slept in into a basket for washing later, then sets about cleaning himself quickly without a glance at the cracked glass serving as the room's mirror.

He's not interested in his reflection or its reminders of traumas etched into his skin.

True healing can never be found while avoiding despairs of the past. There are lessons to be found in scars, lessons that will shape him into something better if he can ever find the courage to face himself, but such things are hard to ponder when trapped in a daily cycle of chaos for survival.

Running low on soap. Not sure if I have enough thread to patch up this hole either.

His thoughts loop through lists and tasks that keep him busy so he doesn't have to feel.

…

Once clean and dressed in his slightly damaged hunting gear, he steps out of the washroom and tightens the bands keeping his hair up with an exaggerated yawn to signal to his friend that he's ready for a new day.

He doesn't anticipate anything new or meaningful actually happening, but such thoughts are things Nier is content to keep to himself as Weiss descends from upstairs to meet him at the front door.

"Good morning, lad."

He finishes tugging on his boots with a grunt. "Morning."

"No breakfast today?"

"Not hungry." With a sigh, he straps on the lightweight spear he's been practicing with recently. "And I'm anxious to restock on some…"

His words taper off when he opens the door to blinding sunshine.

The planet stopped rotating over a millennia ago, thus his view of the world is never completely void of light, but cloudless days tend to be rare around these parts.

Three years ago, Nier would have been happy for this shift in the atmosphere. Intense sunlight withers Shades down to nothing, and, though some of them have started to adapt to it by wearing thin shields over their bodies, this development isn't a widespread dilemma just yet. The eighteen-year-old warrior and the citizens of his village can still rely on favorable weather conditions to schedule hunts and important deliveries, but back then a sky without clouds meant far more to him, as it allowed him to get more done and make trips back home more easily so he could spend quality time with Yonah. Then, after Weiss and Kainé entered his life, those days became ones of easygoing laughter, sassy quips of disdain, and belligerent cursing while they completed simple tasks from various townspeople to acquire gold for that night's dinner, dinners Kainé never experienced despite his insistence that she could come into the village long enough to eat something at his house.

Their bickering sessions usually ended with her kicking him in the gut, and he would go home sore yet happy as he relayed the day's adventure to Yonah…minus the cursing and friendly violence.

But time is a cruel thing.

He prefers the gloom of an overcast sky now. It gives him an excuse to fight, to claim a fleeting rush of endorphins that eliminate every other sensation as the blood of those accursed Shades spills over the dirt. Those battles are blissful distractions where instinct triumphs over contemplation. He knows how to function in a life-or-death struggle, can accept lacerations, bruises, strained muscles, and the metallic tang of blood on his tongue.

What he can't endure is the continuous sting of his failures.

…

At this point, Nier would have gladly welcomed the greater shadows of the fabled nighttime to shroud out the brilliant azure sky and the blazing star of flame altogether to maintain that sense of mental oblivion, but the machinations of this world are firm in their intent to mock him this day, heck, this whole week.

Seven days of uninterrupted sunshine have come and gone.

This marks the eighth day of perfect peace for everyone except him.

"You have got to be kidding me. Again?"

The words are caked in a quiet bitterness, eliciting an immediate sigh from Weiss.

"What is it now?" he drones, hovering by Nier's head. "Don't tell me you're pissy about the sunlight again."

Groaning, the young man stomps his way toward the mailbox. "Since when did you start using language like that, Weiss?"

"Do not change the subject."

The book flies in front of his face, interrupting his quest to check if there was a new letter from Emil.

"You have been insufferable this entire week and I demand to know why! Your villagers are well fed for once, goods from Seafront were able to arrive without incident, and not a single soul has fallen victim to the Shades. The good fortune this glorious sunshine has bestowed should be met with a spirit of gratitude, yet you keep sulking at it as if it's scorned you like some unfaithful lover."

Nier rolls his eyes at the book.

"Are you done?"

"I most certainly am not! YOU WILL ANSWER MY INQUIRY OR THOU SHALT BE SMITED BY THE GREAT WRATH OF…"

"Weiss. Stop."

The white book sputters in pure indignation.

"N-Now see here!"

"I'm just…"

Nier pauses, thinks over what he wants to say, then shakes his head in defeat.

"Sorry."

"I'll say you are," Weiss mutters irritably, his pages clearly ruffled by the whole exchange as he watches the young man open and peer into the red mailbox next to them only to come up empty. "But I suppose the lack of meaningful activity has made you restless. Why not seek out Popola? She may have a chore outside of town for you to do today. Frankly, I could use a little change in scenery myself."

"Then it's settled," the young man answers mechanically, adjusting the strap holding the spear to his back as he walks to the stairway leading to the library. He drags his feet a bit on the journey, dreading the sight of Kainé's pained visage along the sealed door to the basement, but it can't be helped. Popola rarely leaves the place, and Devola has been frequenting the tavern more often than usual, her singing more pronounced and joyful than he's ever heard it.

That fact irritates him more than he thinks it should.

…

A few minutes later, Nier stands before the large doors with a sinking heart, but there's no hesitation in his hands as he pushes them open. It's a performance of detachment he puts on to prevent Weiss from worrying, but he's not sure if the act is working anymore…or if it was ever really convincing in the first place.

They don't speak of Yonah unless Emil brings her up in one of his letters.

They speak of Kainé even less…because no words are necessary to explain the pain there. It's a sensation that tears through them both the instant they enter this space filled with old tomes and littered with fragments of plaster and stone no one bothered to remove. Residents of the village don't visit anymore, save for an elderly man who continues with his research of the old world without pause.

However, what should have been another step in his regular routine is interrupted by a new presence, one that gives Nier pause as his ice-blue eyes narrow on a young woman with shimmering waves of golden hair kneeling in front of the stone image of his friend.

She twists slightly, having heard his footsteps.

Time stalls when her eyes - the color of liquid emeralds - meet his.

…

The intensity of her stare rings familiar…and not in a good way, yet the smile she offers him holds a gentleness that softens the sharp angle of her nose and the blood-red staining her full lips.

His throat tightens as he shifts his gaze to her clasped hands.

Had she been praying? Did this woman believe Kainé was a village idol - a thing crafted by human hands?

…

The woman tilts her head and her smile falters into something awkward when she notices him gritting his teeth.

...

Kainé isn't an object. She's a person. His person.

But even while thinking that, Nier can't stop himself from admiring the bronze shimmer clinging to the woman's alabaster skin, nor can he resist wondering if she's some mythical being that had been kissed by the sun itself.

"Good day? Are you feeling alright?"

Her voice holds a subtle, seductive quality that makes him deeply uncomfortable as he nods in acknowledgement of her greeting and in answer to her question. She turns away immediately afterward, her attention back on Kainé as she stands up. The fabric of the luminous, white dress she wears sways delicately with her movement, enhancing the angelic image she presents, but Nier can't shake the feeling that her outward appearance only serves to hide something ugly.

…

He's being unfair. She only said two sentences to him and nothing in that collective of words hinted at any malice.

Even so…the uneasiness remains.

…

Weiss, of course, is the first to break the tense silence.

"Is something the matter, lad?" he whispers, turning toward him. "You look like you have fallen ill. Do you feel faint? A stomach bug, perhaps?"

Nier doesn't offer an answer immediately. His gaze stays fixed on the woman as she paces in an arc around Kainé. She forms a box with her fingers several times while mumbling to herself about colors, textures, and angles. An instant later she's lying down on her side against the floor with her eyes squinted and her nose scrunched. Then she's on her feet again, her quiet rambling shifting into a rapid-fire contemplation concerning chalk or charcoal or some other substance he's not familiar with.

"Lad?"

"Huh?" He strains to focus on Weiss, anxious to keep the woman within his line of sight in case some manner of demon decides to come out when he isn't looking. "What is it?"

Weiss floats in silence for a beat.

"Tell me, has this woman caught your fancy by any chance?"

"N-No." Nier shakes his head fiercely, an immediate nausea filling his chest. "I just… Something's not…"

"You don't have to deny it," the book interrupts, chuckling softly. "It is not a sin to admire a lovely woman."

"That's not what I'm doing! I'm… I just…"

Exhaling a loud sigh, the woman twists sharply on her heel and places both hands on her hips in a show of exasperation.

"Could the two of you be quiet, please," she murmurs, fighting to remain calm and polite even as her eyebrow twitches repeatedly. "I can't concentrate with all the yapping and loud thinking back there. If you don't have any business with me, carry on like I'm not here."

An instant later she's talking to herself again.

"If anyone's thinking loudly it's her," Nier groans, crossing his arms in front of his chest.

"I CAN STILL HEAR YOU! HUSH!"

…

"Madame, ignoring a presence such as yours is no easy task," Weiss quips with an air of teasing. "I believe my good friend here has been struck by your beauty and wishes to…"

"NO! WEISS! WHAT THE HECK ARE YOU SAYING!?"

This time her expression is firmly set in a frown as she peers at them from over her shoulder. The fiercer aspects of her visage are clearer now, granting her an almost feral look that only disappears once a gleam of curiosity begins to shine in those unnaturally green eyes.

Nier can feel his skin crawling the more he stares into them.

"W-Who are you and why are you here!?"

His voice comes out far more harshly than he meant it to. Weiss immediately sputters, bewildered and more than prepared to chastise him for his sudden rudeness, but the woman merely laughs while bringing her fingertips up to her chin.

"I'm nobody worth a reaction like that," she offers, her lips quirking up into a half-smile. "Just a girl visiting from Seafront."

A grimace takes over Nier's expression, his mind whirling back to flashes of memory he thought he'd dismissed ages ago, but if the woman notices his turmoil, she doesn't comment on it. Once more, she pivots away to stare at Kainé's sealed form.

"Some of my relatives call this village home…and they told me about her."

An uncomfortable silence takes hold of the room for a moment.

"She saved this place, yes?"

Nier follows the woman's gaze to the frozen image of his friend, his heart racing from a danger he can't see but knows.

"Yeah. She did."

Nodding, the woman clasps her hands behind her back.

"I felt it was important to see what happened to her for myself," she continues, her voice taking on a softer timbre. "To offer some thanks, but I didn't count on how striking her image would be to me. I'm a painter by trade, and over the last few months I've been in a terrible creative slump…"

"She's not an attraction for you to make a profit off of!"

Another sharp reaction that's gone way too far too fast.

Nier groans inwardly, all too aware of how irrational he's being right now.

"Calm down, lad," Weiss hisses. "This is not the time or the place to lose your temper."

"I know… I just…"

The woman turns back, crestfallen as she locks her gaze with his once more.

…

Those eyes convey a million messages, all of them too personal, too raw…

…

"You knew her."

It's not a question.

…

Nier releases a shaky exhale.

"S-She's my friend."

"Our friend," Weiss chimes in, drawing closer to the stranger. "And we intend to release her from this predicament one day, although our progress on this task has been…minimal."

"I see," she answers, her gaze falling towards her feet. "I will pray over your efforts to rescue her as soon as possible, but could I…"

The woman pauses abruptly, clearly unsure of how to proceed with what she wants to say.

"What is it, madame?"

"I…have heard of you two as well," she begins, her voice coming out in a timid whisper. "And I was hoping that…you could help me with something."

Weiss pivots toward Nier.

"Well, considering how uncommonly dreadful his behavior has been in this exchange, I believe you are owed a favor as recompense."

The woman bites down on her lip and shakes her head.

"No. It's fine." She waves her hand in front of herself as if to dismiss the entire thing. "And really, if it's going to cause either of you trouble, you don't have to…"

"What do you need?" Nier interrupts coolly.

She looks at him like the thought of asking him anything scares her.

…

Maybe he's wrong. Maybe he jumped to conclusions too quickly.

But…

…

"Would you mind going back to my house in Seafront to collect my art supplies?"

"Sounds simple enough," Nier answers immediately, softening his tone as a means to reign in his churning emotions. "I can be there and back with the supplies in a few hours."

Weiss hums beside him. It's a sound the warrior knows well and one he wishes he weren't hearing right now.

"Is there a reason why you can't complete this task yourself?" he questions, his voice carrying a hint of annoyance despite being the one who volunteered their services this time.

"I can't afford to leave the subject of my inspiration," she tells them, reaching into a pocket of her dress to withdraw a key, a small pad of paper, and a black pen decorated with accents of gold. "That reminds me, I'll need you to bring me a spare canvas too. There's several of them in my house by the desk where I keep my supplies." She scrawls some numbers and letters across the paper, rips it out of the little pad, then hands it and the key to Nier. "This is the address. Please hurry back. I don't want to lose the image I have of her in my head."

"Okay…"

"I'm serious," she continues, stars in her eyes as her gaze returns to Kainé. "This work will be my magnum opus, and your friend will be immortalized for generations to come."

Nier nods once, distracted by other features he recognizes in her face.

…

It's unlikely. Very unlikely and yet…

…

There's something off here. It had been sunny all week, sure, but that didn't make the Southern Plains any safer to travel through, especially alone. Nier can easily see that this woman doesn't have the look or demeanor of a seasoned warrior. Even if he were to ignore the opulence of the pen she'd used just now, the white, sleeveless sundress and wedge-heeled sandals are well-made and undamaged, clear signals of hailing from the upper echelon of merchants and locals of Seafront.

She's even wearing a heart-shaped locket fashioned out of pure gold.

It's wasteful. All of it. Everything about her.

…

What place does art even have in a dying world?

…

"Can I ask you something?"

"Technically you just did," the woman answers, already pacing again. "But you can ask me something else."

Weiss lets out a chuckle. "Clever."

Nier didn't think so.

"Does all your family live here in the village?

She shakes her head. "My parents are still in Seafront but despite the distance I constantly hear their inane yammering to quit painting and get a real job…" Groaning, she sends him a chilling glare. "Wait. How are my family matters any of your business?"

"They're not," Nier replies placatingly. "Just curious."

"Well, stop it," she growls frostily, waving them away. "Questions like that are terribly invasive, not to mention distracting! Keep this up and you'll find your pay for your services lacking."

"Right. I guess I'll be going."

He hurries out of the library and back into the courtyard with a fleeting sense of embarrassment.

"Do you care to explain what that was about?" Weiss asks.

"Not really."

"Of course not." The book hovers behind him as he rushes back to his house to exchange his spear for the more trustworthy sword. "You have been rather secretive lately."

"Everyone has secrets, Weiss."

"But it is no secret that you have been bewitched by our client," he mutters, positively giddy. "How I wish the hussy were already free so she could be a witness to you bumbling your way through flirtation."

Making haste to strap his sword to his back, Nier forces himself to swallow the acid crawling up his throat.

"She isn't my type. Trust me."


Color.

Texture.

Shape.

Hue.

Tint.

Highlight.

Shadow.

These components, when combined, can craft an epic within a singular image. Fantastical narratives of love, trust, anguish, destruction, and chaos exist in my heart, but words are not a reliable medium for me.

Words are easily misunderstood - twisted.

Words are easily ignored too.

…

And sometimes…words hold no meaning or truth for the listener.

Thankfully, art doesn't need to speak. It shows what lies within the soul of the painter without a sound, but for most onlookers, a piece only serves as a mirror for their own soul. A few find healing in that view. Others are disturbed by the ugliness captured from the deepest depths of their heart - the wretched beast no one should have ever been able to see or know.

But I know. All artists know.

The human heart is beautiful and grotesque all at once.

…

Color.

Texture.

Shape.

Hue.

Tint.

Highlight.

Shadow.

…

The same tools I use to paint are reasons people hate one another.

…

There's someone I hate, and I don't know if my reason is just or not. It probably isn't.

…

The hatred exists because I loved him once.

Loved him instantly, really.

His colors are the most beautiful. The textures and patterns weaved into his clothes are a strange fascination for me, and even now my heart leaps at the curve of his smile and the vibrant hue of his haunting eyes. Brilliant sunlight casts his hair in an ethereal glow while his shadow stretches along the sand, marking the hour of day without having to move a single step.

Focused. Determined. Strong.

…

Sad. Deeply sad.

…

He had a good reason to do it. I know that.

…

Perhaps what he took from me was never truly within my right to have. Thinking of it that way, I shouldn't hate him. There's really no point in hating anyone in a world on the brink of total ruin. Such emotions are a waste of energy.

I know this all too well.

…

The colors of vengeance aren't pretty. They're the same mixture of moss green, ebony, and gold that consumes the monsters terrorizing these lands. A fleeting beauty can only be found when they burst apart in a shimmering veil of crimson…and then it fades into shadow and gnarled voices.

Such an end for my beloved wouldn't satisfy me at all.

I like how his eyes shine too much to want him dead, but his suffering is an exquisite palette.

I have heard his screams.

I wish I could taste his tears.

…

Creating is a better outlet than violence. I firmly believe this, but I don't know what I'm supposed to do with these emotions…with old wounds that won't heal no matter how much time has passed.

…

What would my brother think of me? Would he hate me? Would he laugh in my face for being so stupid?

…

He had a gift for songwriting. His melodies were some of the loveliest…and the most painful.

…

I wish I could forget him. I wish I could forget the monsters that haunt my dreams and the depravity that lingers in the vestiges of every soul I've ever known…including my own.

My beloved should have been different. I thought he was different.

…

He isn't.

Every human is beautiful and grotesque all at once.

…

Painting is the only way for me to unleash my fury safely. There's no consequence in expressing one's heart in an image…especially when everyone acts as if your work is nothing more than a mindless hobby.

…

Unfortunately, creating hasn't helped lately.

…

My beloved's face haunts my dreams in various forms.

…

I hate him. I hate him because he inspired a hope in humanity that ultimately came to nothing.

…

Many have told me that time is cruel.

I disagree.

…

The greatest cruelty is hope in a world as ugly as this.


The journey to Seafront was altogether uneventful and took half the time it would have on a cloudy day. Of course, Nier was also sprinting faster than normal, anxious to get this job over with. Weiss floated after him quietly, and, although it was obvious to the book that something deeper was bothering the young man, he opted not to ask questions just yet.

After all, time has a way of revealing things.

Entering through the gate of the sun-kissed town, he slows his pace to examine the address he'd been given while ignoring the pungent smell of fish he's learned to get used to over the years of traveling here.

"Nier."

Taken aback by the book's use of his name, the warrior stops in their walk through the winding alley.

"Yeah, Weiss?"

"Does the idea of the hussy's image being put to canvas bother you?"

…

"A little bit," he admits, resuming his navigation toward their client's house despite his heightening nerves at how familiar the path ahead of them is becoming. "I don't know if it's something Kainé would appreciate, but…a painting of her could be a good addition to the house, especially if we end up rescuing Yonah first."

"Oh yes, a picture of a woman in revealing lingerie is the perfect addition to any bachelor's home," Weiss grumbles sarcastically.

Nier grimaces at the comment. "There's nothing vulgar about wanting to have a picture of our friend in the house. Besides, what Kainé wears isn't any of our concern."

"Let me put it this way then, lad," the book answers with a sigh. "Would you want your sister to emulate her look?"

…

"Do you think she would!? Please say no."

…

"Given how much you admire the hussy, I have no doubt she would." Weiss answers seriously, noting Nier's increasingly horror-stricken expression as they draw near the street written out on the paper in his hand. "She might start repeating that woman's vile profanities too. I shudder to even think of it. One Kainé is enough for several lifetimes."

Distracted, Nier simply shakes his head. "I guess we'll cross that bridge when we get there. Right n-now…"

Weiss notices the sudden shift in his companion's demeanor as they reach the front gate of their client's house.

"What is the matter now, lad?"

Nier doesn't speak. His throat goes dry. His heartbeat fluctuates as a torrent of images from a time before Weiss, Kainé, Emil, and Yonah's capture rush violently to the forefront of his mind.

…

In the days following their parents' deaths, it was just him and Yonah trying to get by.

Then she came down with the Black Scrawl - just like they had.

He was scared. So scared.

…

They'd been out of money and on the verge of having to sell their family home, the only home either of them knew, the home that once held happy memories of warmth, laughter, and safety.

…

And in those days, he had come here…and seen those eyes.

"N-No… N-No… This isn't… It c-can't be..."

"Nier! Pull yourself together!"

Weiss's cry of concern draws him back to the present, but not before his fist collides with the iron gate and a harsh expletive rolls off his tongue. His knuckles, though protected by thick gloves, tingle with an immediate ache he'll feel more prominently tomorrow, not that he cares.

This place. This place…

…

"I'm…alright, Weiss," he murmurs shakily, fighting to compose himself as he digs in his pocket for the key to the gate and the house beyond. "E-Everything is…"

"Enough," the book interrupts, his tone soft. "We have traveled, fought, and lived together as friends for three years now, and I will not stand for you to insult my intelligence with this act for a second longer. You forget that I am an ancient being of arcane magics the likes of which you still don't comprehend even after having had them at your disposal for all this time. Your meager attempts to hide your despair are pointless. Tell me the truth. What is troubling you?"

"Weiss… I don't…"

"Confound it, man! Unburden yourself! What is the point in having friends if you do not allow them to assist you in moments like this?"

…

Nier inhales slowly, steeling himself as he unlocks the gate and pushes it open.

"W-We have a job to do," he mutters, unwilling to look back. "Let's just get it done and get out of here, okay."

The grimoire sighs heavily but offers no other words as they venture to the front door. With a quick twist of the key into the lock, they're inside. Weiss pauses at the threshold, but Nier is across the room and ascending the stairs within a few quick strides.

He knows the layout of the place well enough to know exactly where their client's supplies would be kept.

Weiss follows him with some hesitance, maybe even a shred of hurt, but the young warrior can't bring himself to catalog that properly while fighting against the little triggers every second spent within the house brings. He walks past the bedroom and into an office area that used to serve as a storage space for weapons. On the table he sees a large, open leather bag stuffed with glass vials of oddly thick paint, some dirty paint palettes that have an odd crust clinging to them, clean brushes of varying sizes, and three small mounds of charcoal. He makes a quick search of the other compartments in the wooden desk and withdraws a different art kit holding chalk and oil pastels. He stuffs everything he finds related to any style of artwork into the bag as neatly as he can, zips it up, then throws it over his shoulder.

"That should be everything…"

"She said she needed a blank canvas as well," Weiss cuts in, his cover facing different paintings littering the floor on the other end of the room. "I must say, her work is quite incredible."

Though Nier is more interested in getting what they came for and leaving, the book's sudden curiosity compels him to glance at some of the canvases littering the space. There are several portraits of Seafront's citizens, including one of the Lighthouse Lady inside her home, the Postman at his usual station, and even one of the red-bag couple caught mid-argument.

Gazing at them, he feels his breathing ease into something calmer, so he keeps looking. There are paintings of women laughing by the town's fountain, paintings of seamen loading up cargo in boats, paintings of children running across the shoals, and a striking portrait of an older boy with the same golden hair as the woman who sent them on this quest. In it he's holding out a familiar heart-shaped locket. The gold gleams from a light cast from off the surface of the canvas - a light that is only outshined by the brightness of the boy's smile.

Nier's gaze stays on this painting the longest…because something about it brings back memories of Yonah.

He remembers her failed attempts at cooking and all the times she had begged him to stay home.

...

He thinks now that he should have listened to her more. His goal had been to cure her, to keep her alive, but…

…

Time together had been lost long before she was plucked from his side.

"Our client is talented," he whispers faintly, his heart settling a little as he turns to watch Weiss hover toward the room's back corner. A cluster of canvases are nestled backwards against the wall.

He remembers her saying the blank canvases were supposed to be by the desk, but a quick glance around the wooden table proves fruitless.

I guess she misremembered?

"I believe one of these should do."

Nodding, Nier strides over and picks up a random canvas from the space with the assumption that there is nothing to be found across its surface…

…

…until Weiss releases a sharp gasp of surprise.

"Hmm? What is it?"

The book's response holds a teasing warmth.

"It's…a painting of us."

Nier raises a brow, perplexed as he turns the canvas around. Sure enough, there he is on the shoal with the seals at his feet and a fishing pole in hand. In the painting he's already caught a fish and is holding it out in front of himself in examination. Weiss hovers next to him, his cover perfectly captured in the light of the sunshine coming from somewhere off the page.

"This is from when we caught that Shaman fish for Yonah," he murmurs, confused. "But there was no one on the beach with us that day."

"And yet every detail of that moment is captured perfectly here," the book answers. "Perhaps this image would be a better one to display in the house as it represents the start of our adventures."

"I don't think it'd be a good idea to take it without getting her permission…" He trails off. "And honestly, as talented as she is, I think it's a little weird that this one painting was tucked out of sight…like she was hiding it deliberately."

"A fair point, lad." The book hums, clearly in deep thought before muttering, "There are certainly some missing pieces to this startling puzzle."

Nier doesn't miss the extra message in those words.

Weiss isn't dumb. He was a witness to his near mental breakdown and saw how easily he navigated her house like he'd lived in it.

…

One could say he had.

But that story isn't one he can share…with anyone.

…

Their eyes are the same. Exactly the same.

…

Nier can't shake the feeling that his past has returned to haunt him, and that feeling is only cemented when he reaches for another canvas he believes will be blank only to find another painting of himself. In this one he's talking to the seasick merchant he helped three years ago.

One painting could be excused as a coincidence, but two?

"Has this woman been…no that's preposterous."

As Weiss speaks, Nier picks up another canvas and flips it over. Just like the other two, this one showcases a piece of his life, only this time it's from one of his more recent trips to Seafront.

"This is when we came to pick up a package for Popola," he whispers, a slight tremor buzzing through his hands as he examines the image. "It's from a year ago at most."

"Oh… I do not like the look of this."

With a new sense of panic beginning to overwhelm him, the young warrior begins turning every canvas facing the wall. Each one holds a different image of him, and not all of them are realistic either. Some are more abstract works.

In one he's sitting amidst a field of roses staring up at a sky composed of a mixture of gold and crimson.

In another he's smiling, but his eyes are empty voids of darkness leaking blood.

Several more depict him as a ravenous demon with sharp claws and jagged teeth stained scarlet with remnants of Shades lying in heaps at his feet.

However, the most chilling painting shows him lying across the wooden plank of a familiar hut, sleeping soundly with tear stains on his cheeks and a single, jagged streak of crimson across his chest – near his heart.

The wound leaks with petals rather than blood…and his hair is down.

He never ever wears his hair down.

…

He can't stand how it feels when it touches his neck - can't stand the memories of when it was touched.

…

This painting is vile. The vilest thing he's ever seen.

…

"We need to get back to the village. Now."

"Lad, are you…"

"No. I'm not." He grits his teeth and grabs hold of the painting of him in Kainé's hut. "Weiss…I'm sorry. I just… There are things I've done. T-Things I…can't talk about."

The images and sensations return in full force and it's all he can do to just stay standing.

"I just… I just…"

…

"You needn't apologize or explain yourself further," Weiss offers after a heavy moment of silence. "No matter the sin, you have done all for the sake of your loved ones. That alone makes you more honorable than any man I have known."

Tears, hot and fast, roll down Nier's cheeks.

"T-Thank you, Weiss."

"A better way of thanks would be to stop abbreviating my name," the book offers, trying and failing to alleviate the tension in the air. "At any rate, let us return to your village and settle this matter quickly."

After rubbing his eyes free of the tears, Nier drops the bag of supplies back on the desk and departs with the singular painting in hand.

He needs answers.

Who is this woman?

What is she?

And why…?

…

Why is her work filled with such hatred.


No one can live without purpose. It's a need ingrained into every human that walks this earth.

Mine was to kill the man that took my brother from me.

…

My parents never listened to his cries for help. They were more concerned with protecting our family's reputation than us.

…

Eventually he stopped writing songs on paper – said it felt better to carve lyrics into his skin. The instant he told me that, I begged him to run away, to seek refuge in the neighboring village across the plains. His refusals were fueled by a noble determination I couldn't understand back then.

He just kept saying someone else would carry the mantle of torment if he didn't.

At first, I thought it was because he was worried about me. I was more than prepared to take his place. I had already offered myself to the monster several times for that exact purpose, but my willingness to become its plaything proved futile.

The monster didn't want me. It would never want me.

My brother knew this before I did.

He was sacrificing himself to protect the other boys in town, the ones the monster would undoubtedly target if he wasn't around.

I kept trying to tell him to run away anyway. It wasn't his responsibility to protect anyone. He was my little brother, and if our parents weren't willing to do anything to save him, I had to be the one to fix it.

The problem was that I didn't know how. I was barely fourteen then, and every attempt to convince our parents that our uncle was molesting their twelve-year-old son was met with scorn and brutal chastisements I still bear the scars of.

They knew we were telling the truth but chose to root themselves in denial, even when the signs became obvious. Our father was running for mayor at the time, and I assumed he didn't want any scandal from his brother, a renowned and respected mercenary of Shades, to undercut his chances at victory.

Maybe I would have accepted that if he had done something after he claimed that coveted office, but nothing changed.

…

Two months into his first term, I stumbled upon a written agreement between my father and uncle. It turns out the monster held a powerful sway over the citizens here, more than I thought possible, and his word alone had given my father a staggering advantage over the competition...but claiming that edge came with a steep asking price.

My brother.

The document was signed by both our parents.

They signed away his innocence and well-being for power in a world doomed to crumble away.

…

By then I knew there'd be no more talking to my parents. I stashed the document under a loose plank of wood beneath my bed then got to work writing a letter to the leader of the neighboring village.

The plan had been to mail the letter and that document immediately, but…

…

Looking back on it now, the Black Scrawl delivered a mercy no one had been able to give my brother in life. Of course, such an outlook could never erase the grief or rage over the evil that was done to him.

Vengeance is a vow I made on my brother's grave, but its colors were never to my liking. They're the same mixture of moss green, ebony, and gold that consumes the monsters terrorizing these lands. A fleeting beauty can only be found when they burst apart in a shimmering veil of crimson…and then it fades into shadow and gnarled voices.

Many of those voices haunt me whenever my brush streaks across a canvas.

…

A year after my brother's death is when my beloved was chosen as the next victim, but he was fortunate enough to escape the monster's clutches that first day.

The letter and document remained in the hiding spot I'd chosen, forgotten in my grief.

…

Once more I offered myself as a sacrifice to no avail.

The monster didn't want me. It would never want me, yet on this singular occasion it found my request amusing enough to turn me into an unwilling witness the instant my beloved returned seeking gold for medicine by whatever means necessary.

…

I can still remember the roughness of his hands as he tied me up, put a gag in my mouth, and threw me into his bedroom closet with a harsh instruction to stay quiet or end up on the wrong end of his blade. Terror at what he could do to prolong my suffering kept me silent as I waited for the inevitable horror. It didn't take long for two sets of footsteps to enter – large footfalls accompanied by quieter steps and the shakiest of exhales.

…

Silent tears ran down my face as the quiet turned into a miserable clamor.

…

This is what my brother endured while thinking he was protecting others.

He never knew he was sold into it with the flourish of a pen on paper.

…

I could have saved my beloved from this if I had remembered to send that letter.

…

But time and distance made me forget until that moment, and by then it was too late. The damage was done and there would be no salvation for the boy whose colors gave my heart a reason to hope again.

The monster had stolen them…just like it had stolen everything else good and pure in my life.

…

That night cemented my purpose. I would kill the wretched beast masquerading as a human. It didn't matter that we shared blood or the same eyes. From that point on I would dedicate every ounce of my being to ensure the monster's life ended as slowly and painfully as possible.

He would know the exact anguish and terror my brother had known…that my beloved inherited.

But murder didn't come as naturally to me back then.


Popola reads constantly.

Whether it be reports, letters, documents pertaining to the old world, project notes, or a worn collection of periodicals of past eras, the leader of Nier's village has her eyes on pages more often than what should be humanly possible.

But then Devola, in her usual teasing manner, asked on a random afternoon if she could go a single day without having to read something. Popola had laughed it off at first because…of course she could. It's not like her propensity to have her head stuck in books was an addiction or anything. Shade activity has settled into a predictable pattern and there's no plan of action she has to attend to immediately, so taking a day off from her usual duties would pose no issues either.

And what luck! Seven days of glorious sunshine have given her all the reason to slow down a little…

…

Except she's been reading every one of those days…all day long.

…

Maybe it is an addiction.

This is why Popola finds herself puzzling over knitting needles to weave some manner of clothing – a scarf maybe - but the monstrosity of dark yarn on her desk looks more like a tumbleweed than anything wearable.

"This is ridiculous," she mumbles, irritated while trying to undo the knot she just created. "Why does Devola think I need a hobby anyway…"

"GOOD GRIEF! WHAT IS TAKING THEM SO LONG!?

The shrill shout from downstairs rattles the village leader so badly that she ends up snapping both large needles in half.

"AT THIS RATE I'M GONG TO HAVE TO START DRAWING ON THE FLOOR!"

Popola releases a sigh while setting what's left of her disastrous knitting project down then silently rises from her desk to retrieve her staff before heading to the door.

What on Earth could that be?

Once outside her office, she strides over to the balcony to peer at the bottom floor where she immediately spots a blonde woman pacing in circles.

She looks familiar. Very familiar.

"Ms. Tanner?"

The young woman pauses in her movement and shifts her harsh gaze up until a flash of recognition flashes through those unnaturally green eyes.

"Popola!" She raises her hand in a wave. "Good to see you again! What are you doing here?"

"I…live here," Popola answers slowly, raising a brow upon noticing the subtle shakiness of the blonde's movement. "What brings you here? You still live in Seafront, right?"

She offers a nod after dropping her hand. "Just here for a visit after hearing about this woman here. The rumors didn't disappoint. She's absolutely stunning."

Unsure of how to respond, Popola gestures for the woman to wait a moment. She leans her staff against the wall next to her office door then quietly makes her way down the stairs.

Even with several days of sunshine as a factor, the trip from Seafront to this village remains a dangerous one. The valley between the two locations is home to hostile animals and some large, venomous spiders near the mansion overlooking the area.

Though her uncle was once a famous mercenary, Abigail Tanner, the daughter of Seafront's previous mayor, makes her living as a painter. She doesn't have the build or skill of a warrior, and no one should be traveling between towns alone, sunshine or not.

Shades can adapt. Popola knows that all too well.

"I needed some inspiration," Abigail continues after a moment, studying Kainé's face. "The last three years have been an adjustment after…well everything. Most of my would-be clients are more interested in saving their gold for food in case another shortage happens, so I imagine I won't be able to make a living painting for much longer. Had a bad creative slump in the middle of everything too. I suppose my parents were right about the profession being unstable."

Popola listens while recollecting the details she knows about Abigail's life. Her brother passed six…almost seven years ago now. She remembers attending the funeral - remembers giving her a handkerchief when tears and snot began to overwhelm her small face.

A year after that, she received an anonymous letter explaining how the boy was abused by his uncle, the famed mercenary that had been instrumental in many hunts for the village. The letter came with a separate document showcasing how that abuse was part of a deal orchestrated by the mercenary and the mayor.

She had no doubt Abigail was the letter's sender. The words carried too much passion and desperation for it to have come from anyone else.

Nier had been traveling to Seafront a lot around that time…and each time he would return with bags weighed down in gold, but he grew more despondent with every day that passed, only coming to life briefly when he saw Yonah's condition improving.

The instant she and Devola realized what was happening, they made the arrangements for a major hunt…with the intent to ensure the mercenary's demise one way or another.

Nier was part of that hunt, but that information wasn't included in the official death notice sent to the mayor and his family.

Popola had hoped the notice had served as a discreet message to Abigail, that the monster she hated was gone and that repercussions for her father would come in due time.

And it did, eventually. She received the death notice of the former mayor two years ago.

"Coming here was definitely the right move," Abigail continues, heedless of the fact that Popola had been deep in thought. "But I should have brought my art supplies with me." With a shake of her head she adds, "Now I'm waiting for the village errand boy to bring them and he's taking FOREVER and a day to get back!"

"Are you…talking about Nier?"

The woman's haughty demeanor instantly drops into something calmer, more forlorn.

"Is that his name? Nier?"

Popola hesitates to answer and she isn't sure why.

…

Something just feels…off.

"Yes. It is."

The corners of the girl's lips quirk upward but quickly fall back into the angry frown from before.

"Well, Nier is taking forever and a day to get back," she drawls dramatically, placing a hand on her hip. "At this rate, what little motivation I have to paint is going to be up in smoke."

Again, Popola isn't sure how to answer.

Luckily, or unluckily, she doesn't have to, for at that very instant a sharp creak erupts through the room as a lone figure and the silhouette of a familiar floating book appears.

The village leader thinks that maybe she's been too paranoid over the last few minutes.

…

But she can't help but notice…

"There you two are!" Abigail wails, tapping her foot along the floor. "What took you so…"

She trails off and that pause in her speech causes Popola to shift her attention to Nier.

He's only taken a few steps inside when the heavy doors of the library close behind him. His expression is a quiet fury that sucks all the air out of the room as he holds up a canvas covered in paint.

Popola barely has time to take in the image before Abigail's breathing sharpens. The village leader pivots, her apprehension climbing while she watches the young woman back away by several steps.

"I… W-Why do you…"

"Explain to me what this is?" Nier demands, his voice dripping with a rage Popola has never heard from him before. He hasn't even noticed her standing there. His entire focus is on Abigail's face, a face that's contorting into an expression of pure torment.

"Well," Grimoire Weiss bellows. "Out with it, woman! The lad deserves an answer after stumbling upon your depraved collection."

That singular word sends a jolt through the blonde.

Popola glances between her and Nier before moving to stand between them.

"Everyone, please calm down. There's no reason to…"

Her words are interrupted when she's dragged backward suddenly. An instant later, the sharp edge of a blade is positioned near her throat.

"POPOLA!"

"Don't move," Abigail whispers into her hair. "I don't have any intent to harm you, but I might if you don't cooperate. Understand?"

Nier withdraws his sword while Weiss opens his pages to prepare an onslaught of magic.

Abigail's response is to press the blade closer to Popola's exposed neck.

"Let her go!" the warrior shouts, his voice a vicious snarl. "She has nothing to do with whatever issue you have with me, got it!"

"Oh, but she does." A soft giggle rings in the red-head's ear. "Don't you, Popola?"

She knows. She knows everything.

The soft laughter that follows is confirmation of her suspicion, but she doesn't understand the reasoning behind it - behind any of this.

Neither does Nier. He stands with an expression of terror as the painter's chuckles become a hysterical clamor.

The sound sends a bitter chill through his heart.

"I didn't want things to end this way," she wheezes in between giggles. "I really did want to paint your friend, to forget how much I despise you for what you did to me."

"What nonsense are you blithering on about?" Weiss questions harshly. "We only just met you today."

Abigail laughs again.

"You think that matters? You saw my collection. I have been watching him for a very long time."

"Why?" Nier asks, taking a hesitant step forward, his sword still raised. "What do you want with me?"

She tightens her grip on the knife.

"At one time…I wanted to save you."

Those words send a wave of invisible chaos through the room. No one speaks as the dust settles around them, but the quiet is little more than an eerie calm as emotions twist and whirl around the memory of a single man, a monster whose actions dismantled countless lives beyond those present in this room.

A beast Grimoire Weiss has absolutely no knowledge of.

That is why he asks:

"Save him? From what?"

Nier's hands start shaking along the hilt of his sword as he peers pleadingly into Abigail's eyes.

She stares back at him, her own heart pounding at the memory of his screams.

…

Tears flow from her eyes in a sudden rush, but the knife in her hand remains steady.

"It's a secret that's been kept for far too long."

Another wave of panic surges through the warrior's blood.

"W-Who are you!? How do you know…"

"He was my uncle," she cuts in, her voice a sharp rasp of rage. "And you killed him."


My father received word from Popola about an important hunt his brother was needed for a few weeks after my sixteenth birthday. The monster left promptly, only offering me a sinister smile to remind me of the secret we shared.

…

That was the last time I ever saw him.

…

I should have been happy when word of his death reached us, but such news didn't settle my heart at all.

Too easy. Far too easy.

He should have had his entrails ripped out inch by miserable inch. Every limb and appendage of his should have been cut off and fed back to him. Both his eyes should have been ripped from the sockets and stomped on until they were mush.

...

My hands wanted nothing more than to paint with his blood.

...

Was it not my divine right to put an end to him, to turn what was foul into something beautiful?

Is it not what I promised my brother – what I vowed to my beloved?

…

The idea that a few lousy, brainless Shades ended him never sat right with me. How could a mercenary known for his proficiency in all things violent be the only man that didn't return alive from an expedition in which hordes of those creatures had been present? He certainly wouldn't have sacrificed himself for the greater good of the people around him. If anything, he would have used someone as a human shield to save himself if things got too rough out there.

Even the letter containing his death notice was strangely suspect, so I sent letters to the two witnesses listed on the document.

They told me there was a third person on that hunt. A kid of around fourteen, close to fifteen, with white hair and stormy blue eyes. During the fray with the Shades the two guards had gotten separated from my uncle and the boy.

…

The boy returned alone. They didn't see how my uncle died. Just assumed the Shades were responsible.

How convenient for my uncle's killer that Popola deliberately left his name off the documentation.

But not convenient enough.

The physical description alone gave it all away to me.

I knew his face, his eyes, and all his colors with an artistic clarity that made it impossible for me to suspect anyone else.

…

No one can live without purpose. It's a need ingrained into every human that walks this earth.

Mine was stolen.

…

His justice created shapes and textures of blood in the dirt.

What hue did it have? Crimson? Scarlet?

Perhaps it was a dark maroon bordering on black?

I'll never know. I'll never know what my colors of justice were supposed to be.

…

Creating is a better outlet than violence. I firmly believe this, and yet…

…

…these hands have taken many lives now.

…

It started with my parents. I can still envision the wild fear shining in their eyes as the effects of the poison constricted their every movement and, eventually, airflow to their lungs.

Sometimes I feel the sensation of my mother's weak grip around my throat while the echo of my father's gurgled curses repeat endlessly.

…

Satisfaction and pride for my innovation in producing a clean means to extract and collect "ink" from the human body were prevalent in my thoughts while purifying the metallic stench with cleaning agents and scented oil.

…

Two years of aimless killing have come and gone since then, but it's not enough. It's never enough.

...

The fury stays. The anguish stays. I can't make it go away. I try to bury it, to suppress every emotion, but nothing helps.

…

That's why…anyone with the same depravity as the monster becomes another hue in a never-ending sea of red on my canvas.

I can't find anything beautiful in these portraits of death.

They only show how hatred mars the mind and soul…until there's nothing left but another monster.

…

How would it feel to paint with the blood of my beloved? Would that heal me? Could it release me from the burden of grief and shame?

…

I don't know anymore.

I only know that I like how his eyes shine too much to want him dead to hurt him with any conviction.

Granted…I did drug him once.

That incident happened a few months ago while I was volunteering at the local tavern. Helping the owner in the kitchen provided the best opportunity to scope out the city for any new targets.

I was analyzing one suspicious patron through the small window in the kitchen door when my beloved arrived with two large bundles of eggplants and three fresh bream. He was too engaged in his discussion with the owner and the quick exchange of items for gold to notice me watching. After another handful of seconds he took a seat, shyly agreeing to stay and eat.

Within seconds I had an order to make one of the tavern's special dishes.

My heart had pounded in my chest from anticipation.

Fate had handed my uncle's murderer over to me, and in eliminating him, I could…

…

Except I couldn't. The idea of his eyes losing that special glimmer was too revolting to stomach, but I didn't want him to leave the place completely unscathed either, so, I sprinkled a tiny amount of my least potent poison into his food. The amount given would dull his senses and make him dreadfully sleepy within the hour. I surmised that he would go straight home to rest.

The idea was to follow him there but…

…

My eyes sought his face through that small window as he ate, a sudden nervousness prickling at my skin.

The floating book wasn't with him.

…

The instant he left, I cleaned up my cooking station and made up an excuse to leave to follow him. Doing so led me through the Southern Plains, through his village, and across the Northern Plains until he disappeared into a cave containing a path of old tracks.

Again…I was nervous.

…

What was I doing? What did I even want if revenge wasn't on the table?

…

When I found him again, he was asleep inside a dilapidated hut, and I was struck once more by his beauty and the sorrow clinging to every inch of him.

An exquisite palette of suffering too tantalizing to resist. I drunk in the image of his silent anguish and deferred hope for as long as I dared then hurried back to Seafront, to the house where my uncle had stripped so many of their innocence and worked without touching the vials of paint I'd created from the blood of my victims.

…

There was still an angelic quality to him that couldn't be captured in hues of death.

But to truly depict it meant altering the truth of what I'd seen.

…

The first time I saw my beloved, his hair blew in the breeze, unkempt and free.

I needed to see him that way once more...even if it was nothing more than a self-serving lie.

…

…

…

The woman sealed in stone has colors that compliment his perfectly. Though pain lies in her expression, the shape of her eyes conveys something…almost peaceful.

I want that. I want to know what that looks like…what it feels like to know the serenity of a life well-lived despite all the hardships, sin, and sorrow.

One glance at her replaced the haze of crimson clinging to my heart.

This woman is a heroine clothed in hues of baby blue, powder pink, luminous eggshell, dull tones of grey, and the onyx of lingering shadows.

Capturing her essence will be my magnum opus, my apology for failing to avenge the people most precious to me.

…

I'll make something beautiful…one last time.

That's all I want now.


"But you'll deny me of even that, won't you!"

Abigail shoves Popola away from her, reaches beneath the folds of her dress to withdraw the second silver hunting knife from the holster around her thigh, and dashes forward in a flurry of movement Nier blocks with the flat edge of his rusty sword. The grimoire hovering near him charges up magic in spirals of red and black, a swirl of color she knows all too well.

"Popola! Get out of here! Warn the villagers!"

The village leader dashes out of the library quickly, leaving the two of them to battle to the death.

Violence is the only outlet she has now.

I'll make him see it! I'll make him see how desperately I…

"Graaaaaaaaaaaaaah!"

Flipping her knives in her hands, Abigail moves with a sharp fluidity that forces him to evade. Weiss fires off a series of dark blasts that she ducks under while Nier returns to the fray with a swing of his sword that collides against her twin blades.

She struggles against his strength, her wrists shaking to the point of pain.

Don't give in to it! FIGHT BACK! DON'T MAKE IT EASY FOR HIM!

The artist twists to the right and manages to slice him mid-thigh, but he retaliates with a knee to her stomach without a thought toward the injury, like he'd felt it all before and knew not to let anything slow him down when his survival depended on sharp reflexes.

Abigail experiences the full brunt of his strength, and there's no retaliation she can make while every nerve folds in submission to it.

Agony… It's pure agony.

Her accompanying wail sends a jolt through Nier's heart. He knew from the instant their battle began that she wouldn't be able to withstand a major blow. He is a seasoned warrior, and the woman staggering away from him is…

"C-Cheap shot," she rasps, her breath a dry wheeze when she tightens her trembling grip on the knives.

Nier withdraws a step.

Abigail widens her stance in anticipation for his continued assault, but he keeps still for a moment, his gaze narrowing on…

…

Her lips?

"Are you serious?" she mutters, biting out the words in pure disgust. "You can't be turned on by this."

Nier raises his sword but hesitation clouds his expression.

Does he…?

"Don't look at me like that!" she screams, dashing forward again with another flurry of movement. Weiss sends out additional bursts of magic but she can instantly tell the book is using his magic more defensively now.

No matter. They're the one's who forced her into this predicament by being so nosy in the first place. She sent them to that house to grab paint, brushes, and a canvas. How on Earth did they manage to screw up such a simple task this badly?

All I wanted was to paint her. That's it. Why can't I just…

She feels her stomach lurch as a thick substance races up her esophagus.

No! Swallow it! Swallow it down!"

"GRAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH!"

Nier focuses entirely on defense as Abigail bops and weaves around him with the hope of slashing him to pieces. He could easily take her down and she knows it, but he's holding back and she can't figure out…

…

She flicks her tongue over to the side of her mouth.

A metallic tang greets her tastebuds.

It doesn't matter. Keep going!

But her movement is beginning to falter, she can feel it with every collision of her knives against his sword, and though there's still a hint of anger on his face, his stormy eyes tell a different story…one of pity.

"STOP GAWKING AND FIGHT ME!"

Her blade nicks his cheek and the thin streak of blood that oozes from the wound startles her into stillness.

…

She's watched him fight before. She's seen wounds mar his skin from a distance many times.

But it was never done by her hand until this very instant, and the realization knocks nearly all the remaining air from her lungs.

I never wanted this. I never wanted to be the one to…

"Y-You… I…"

An involuntary lurch goes through her body again, and this time she can't stop what comes up.

No! NO!

Thick, black blood splatters onto the stone by her feet. It stains her dress, her shoes, her mouth.

Dizzy… Really dizzy… But I can't…not yet. I'm not…done."

Her body says otherwise. As new tears stream down her face, Abigail drops to her knees and releases another vicious cough that sets her chest and throat on fire.

The same disease that had taken her brother…is slowly destroying her from the inside out.

"Y-You d-did this…t-to me…"

Her words come out hollow. She can't blame him anymore. Not truly.

"I w-was supposed to be the one…that k-killed him. H-He took…my b-brother…and he m-made me watch when…"

Abigail is certain she's going to fall over dead right then, but the clatter of a sword hitting stone keeps her upright just long enough for her to notice the blurry image of Nier kneeling before her with his arms outstretched.

Through the fog of agony she feels his warmth fold around her.

"Hold on! I'll get you help."

Abigail stares into his eyes.

He's not seeing her. He's seeing someone else - the sister he always sacrifices himself for.

…

"I-I wanted to…avenge you both so b-badly," she whispers, leaning her forehead against his chest as her knives slip from her hands. "T-That was my dream. T-That…was …the only reason…for me to live in this stupid, stupid world and y-you t-took that away."

Silence hovers between them for a long moment as she fights for precious oxygen. In that time, Abigail listens to the rhythm of his heartbeat and wonders if her brother would have been able to find the words to capture its gorgeous melody.

She wishes she could hate this man, wishes it with all her heart.

"I've d-done horrible things." Her body sags against his. "Such terrible things and I'm…so ashamed of it all. T-That's why…"

Pivoting slightly, her eyes strain to see the woman trapped in stone.

"I thought if I p-painted her…that m-maybe I could…that I could forgive everything from back then but…b-but it's t-too late, isn't it? Too late for…f-forgiveness…for r-redemption…f-for…anything at all, yeah? T-This world is just…h-hopeless."

Nier tightens his hold.

Her words reflect feelings he's been at war with. There are many things he can't forgive, and he isn't sure if his heart will ever find the healing it truly needs.

If he can't save Kainé and bring Yonah back home…what point is there in living on?

His survival is tied to a fleeting hope for happiness, but even if he reclaims everything he lost, there remains a reality no human can escape.

The woman is on the threshold of that fate, but…

"K-Kill me…" she begs, thin trails of scarlet sliding out from the corners of her mouth. "I d-don't…want t-this anymore."

Nier closes his eyes.

There will be no peace for her soul if she can't fulfill the final purpose she chose. What's broken within her can still be used to share a perspective of beauty, courage, and resilience amidst a wretched world.

He can't think of a better person to send that message through than Kainé. There are things about her past she never shared with him, but what little he knows are strong reminders to keep going – to keep living no matter how difficult it becomes to do so.

That's why…

"What are we to do with her, lad?"

Weiss's question makes him sigh.

Abigail Tanner has never known peace or the comfort of family.

She's a killer. A devil living in an angel's skin.

But as her quiet tears become breathless sobs, Nier experiences the depth of the love she felt…and still feels for him.

In the end, regardless of how sinful and lost the inhabitants of this Earth are, love still conquers everything. No force is stronger.

…

"She's going to live with us."

Abigail's fingers clutch at the fabric of his shirt.

"I'm sorry…what?" Weiss questions, aghast. "Have you gone mad!? This barbarian was out to murder you less than a minute ago!"

"She's not a threat anymore," he mutters in reply, looping one of his arms beneath her legs before gently raising her up from the floor. Her arms immediately fold around his neck, and for a moment he stiffens, not used to receiving hugs from anyone but Yonah.

"Dear Lord, don't tell me that you're still smitten with this creature after all this."

Nier peers at Kainé's stone face briefly and offers a silent prayer to any deity that will care to listen.

There is no woman, in this world or any other, he loves and yearns for more than her.

But right now...that love is needed elsewhere.

"I'll get you medicine and your art supplies," he says to Abigail, adjusting his hold around her body. "Then you can paint Kainé…just like you wanted."

The woman sighs against him, her body shuddering as if a weight had finally been lifted from her shoulders.

"T-Thank you, and…I'm s-sorry. For everything."

Nier doesn't offer a response beyond a solemn smile.


Time has a way of revealing things.

With an impassioned letter, Abigail Tanner saved me and countless others, but that act of love was swallowed up by her hatred.

To cut down the monster with her own hands was all she wanted.

I stole her vengeance away from her just like the Shadowlord stole Yonah from me.

She became a monster in the aftermath. That's what hatred does to people, I guess.

A part of me would like to condemn her for it. She murdered her parents and countless civilians in Seafront then used their blood as a medium for her art, but my own hatred for the Shades burns too potently for me to judge her actions as harshly as others would.

Popola nearly had a panic attack when I told her the painter turned serial killer was going to stay with me indefinitely. Weiss isn't a fan of the arrangement either, but our former client has the Black Scrawl and…it won't be much longer before the disease takes her.

In the two weeks that have passed since she began living with us, I've been at Abigail's side almost constantly. She won't let me call her by her full name, insisting on "Abby" because the nickname brings back happy memories of her brother…the one who was tormented by her uncle long before I ever came into the picture.

Her knowledge of what that man did to me is…oddly comforting.

I've carried the shame of those incidents alone for all this time, had even buried them beneath layers of quiet optimism and relentless activity to keep my mind occupied. Those efforts doubled after Yonah was taken.

Abigail…Abby…is constant reminder of what will never be forgotten.

Her actions saved me. Mine destroyed her.

…

We talk about it in the late hours of the night while Weiss is in his meditative state. She's sketching and painting with supplies free of diluted blood during those conversations. The slow progress of Kainé's portrait lightens the tense atmosphere between us.

She never brings up her feelings for me. She knows my heart belongs to the woman she's painting.

It's enough for her to be together. I'm fine with giving her that.

…

The days pass by peacefully, brightened by the continuous sunshine.

It's like taking care of Yonah again.

…

Except she…

…

When she isn't coughing or doubled over in pain, Abby sits on the stool behind her canvas with a paintbrush in hand.

…

She's running out of time. The medicine helps her with the pain, but her symptoms are getting worse by the day.

I try not to think about it.

…

Little by little, Kainé comes to life on he canvas in Yonah's old room. It's a perfect likeness down to the subtle elegance that softened the raw edges of her fierce persona. Even the imitation of the Lunar Tear in her hair glows with a warm light.

Emil sends more letters. I write to him with more enthusiasm than before.

Abby asked me for a physical description of him while I was writing one day and drew up a sketch of his likeness within seconds. She made another of Yonah a few minutes later then drew Weiss and I from memory.

Those simple sketches brought tears to my eyes when she presented them to me as small presents – a thank you for letting her live with me. I keep the loose pieces of paper next to my hunting clothes to ensure I see them every day.

They're a tangible reminder to keep moving forward – to hold on to those dreams of happiness.

…

Time is cruel. Memory more so.

But time and memory give us reasons to stay, to love, and appreciate what's most precious with every moment that passes by.

…

The golden luster of her hair slowly fades.

Her skin loses its alabaster hue.

Even the vibrant intensity of those piercing, emerald-green eyes dull into a soft, flickering ember.

…

Another week passes.

Her work on Kainé's portrait stalls. Even when she has energy to paint, she won't let me watch anymore.

…

With strained breaths, she wanders into the kitchen to cook one evening. I watch her prepare a lavish meal with the meager ingredients I have on hand until her knees buckle.

I tell her to rest.

She laughs in my face.

…

Hours later she creeps down the stairs with trembling steps and tears rushing over her cheeks.

…

Outside the atmosphere shifts.

…

There'll be rain soon. I feel that truth radiate through my veins when my arms curl around her waist. Her breath is a weak shudder across my neck as her nails dig through the fabric of my night tunic and into my chest.

She whispers apologies – apologies I don't need to hear anymore.

The past is over and the monster of old is dead.

I took his life and have no regrets in doing so…even now after knowing that action sparked the creation of another blood-thirsty beast.

...

She never spoke a word about her feelings for me, but that night I was willing to give in to them, to let her have every part of me if she wanted.

Her response to my offering was a gentle smile and a soft kiss to my cheek.

She refused to take anything else from me, and I was grateful.

Lying side by side, we held each other until sleep claimed us.

…

Our togetherness was a time of healing for us both.

But time can't be saved or wasted. It moves forward without pause regardless of how we choose to spend it. No one told us how much of it we're allowed to have either, so it's practically impossible to make the most of it.

The only choice left is to live moment by moment until the end.


Abigail Tanner sets down her paintbrush to examine the finished portrait of Nier's beloved. With two, jagged-edged swords, the female warrior stands amidst the sloping hills of the Northern Plains wearing a delicate, baby-blue gown that ends just below her hips. Her left arm and left leg are wrapped in bandages that are present to hide the evidence of the Shade inhabiting those limbs. High-heel shoes adorn her feet and a Lunar Tear is tucked behind her left ear. The petals look as if they sprouted from the woman's luminous hair, which is held up in a circular braid at the back of her head while loose strands frame her face.

The painter is most proud of the fierce determination she captured within the woman's brown eyes. Her mouth is set in a snarl, but the gleam of her teeth give off a subtle joy for the thrill of battle.

Next to her another figure stands...the one whose colors brought her peace.

She can't wait for Nier to see it.

He and Weiss left for the village to buy groceries for that night's dinner about an hour ago. They would return soon.

"Better move this…"

Trailing off, Abigail focuses on standing upright. It takes way more effort than it should, but she manages it. Then, with a slightly shaky grip, she moves the easel holding the canvas away from the bed as carefully as possible.

There we go. Perfect.

With a sigh of contentment, the painter takes a few steps back to take in the full view of her work while pressing her fingertips against the locket her brother gave her so many years before.

Her heart swells with pride and a hint of sadness.

"B-Beautiful..."

She twists slowly on her heel with the intent to lay back down…

…

...but the room sways.

She reaches out a hand, hoping to catch herself on the edge of the bed or the nearby stool but she misses them both and ends up crashing down against the hard surface of the floor. An immediate heat sears through every cell inside her chest as she lays there, convulsing from spasms she can't stop.

A soundless gasp forces her mouth open and then…

"SPLAT!"

That sound... She knows that sound.

Well... This is...happening...

With a raspy chuckle escaping, Abigail fights through the spasms to roll onto her side. Her fingers slide over globs of thick mucus and clots of dark blood in a blind panic as another burst of heat lurches inside her stomach, making her gag.

There's...more. Oh God...there's more coming up.

"SPLAT!"

The putrid stench of vomit and blood makes her nose sting and her eyes water.

This is it.

She won't last until dinner…might not even last until Nier returns.

No... I don't... I don't…want to...

Downstairs she hears the telltale sounds of the door opening accompanied by a book's loud complaining.

Relief floods through her system, but she can't vocalize it.

"Abby! You awake?"

She strains to reach her hand toward the doorway.

The instant she opens her mouth another gush of goop comes out.

"SPLAT! SPLAT! SPLAT!"

Her hurling spell is a continuous agony for several seconds, but the noise of it is drowned out by a loud crash downstairs accompanied by a rush of harsh footsteps.

He's coming. Good. At least I won't...be alone.

Through the fog she sees his boots as he makes his way inside.

"Good Lord…"

"ABBY!"

She's barely cognizant of his hands as he lifts her from the floor to set her back onto the soft mattress.

The pain… There's so much…pain.

"Weiss, go get Popola!"

The book doesn't move.

"WEISS!"

"Lad, there is nothing Popola…or anyone else can do for her now," he whispers, his tone grave. "She's..."

Abigail manages a bitter chuckle and a curt, "D-Dying..."

But Nier isn't as accepting of the inevitable, his deep blue eyes welling up with tears when he yanks the nightstand drawer open in search of her medicine. He's hurling quiet expletives in seconds, his heart pounding in horror when he can't find anything.

The painter, delirious from a mixture of agony and blood loss, gently shifts her head along the pillow to watch his colors of terror dance across her mind's eye.

He won't find anything. She threw out the remaining vials of medicine yesterday…because she knew the painting would be finished today.

Survival isn't necessary now, but she had hoped to last another day or so.

Oh well.

He's sacrificed enough of his time for her.

"Abby! Hang on!"

His hands cup her face.

Her gaze stays on his eyes.

Serene droplets of cool land along her cheeks.

"N-Nier…"

Fighting against the heaviness overwhelming her senses, Abigail raises her hand, wanting to trace the path of his tears.

The instant her palm brushes over his cheek, his head dips forward and a sob comes out, one she never would have expected him to give on her behalf.

Kind. So kind…my beloved.

His colors always were the most beautiful to her…but something still isn't right yet.

Yes...something is...out of place.

"Don't die," he begs, leaning his forehead against hers. "Please… Abby…"

"S-S-Sorry."

Her apology is a dry wheeze that makes his tears fall faster, and the incoming wave of grief is so intense that he almost misses the subtle movement of her hand.

Inch by inch, her fingers find purchase in the bands holding his hair.

This is…all I can do...to give back…what was stolen from you…

With the last of her strength, Abigail Tanner pulls apart the bands.

…

His hair falls in a rush against his neck, but Nier doesn't feel it.

His eyes stay on hers.

"T-There," she murmurs, her final ember of life fading as she drinks in the full scope of his beauty. "T-That's…h-h-how...I like...y-y-you best."

"Abby..."

She smiles for him one last time.

"K-Keep it...t-that w-way..."

...

...

...

An eerie silence takes hold of the room.

Nier remains frozen, his eyes locked within empty voids of green.

…

...

...

"She's gone, lad. She's gone."

The words take several seconds for him to absorb, but then, by painfully slow increments, Nier lifts her torso off the bed to draw the painter in for one last embrace.

Her fingers remain entangled within the loose strands of his hair as he weeps.

…

...

...

...

...

He digs through the hard ground in his yard a couple hours later in silence. As he works, the sky darkens and then rain comes to drench the soil beneath him, making the solemn task of burial easier.

…

The days following Abigail's death are all overcast…as if the sun itself had perished with her.


~Five days later~


At the squawking of a perturbed rooster, Nier awakens, his heart rate climbing in a fierce panic before the following quiet forces it to sink into a calmer rhythm.

There's no danger to address – no immediate problem to solve.

He heaves out a shaky breath and carefully pulls back the thin blanket covering his body while glancing around at the familiar space, a home that holds a torrent of memories, good and bad, that he'd rather not think about in the silence of the early morning, and yet his heart pours over every little detail of how Abigail's presence had filled this house with something new.

Weiss, in his meditative state, rests on a nearby table.

Neither of them have ventured into the upstairs bedroom since the painter's death, but Nier knows he'll have to go up there to clean what's left of her presence eventually, and the sooner he puts the task behind him, the better.

With a sigh, he leans over the side of his bed to open the dresser where he keeps his usual hunting clothes and smiles faintly at the sketches resting next to them as his hands lazily clutch at the fabric.

He's not sure if there's a point to anything anymore, but the usual movements of his routine are so hardwired into his body that he's in the house's small washroom before his mind registers that he got out of bed.

He undresses, tosses his night tunic and the loose work pants he'd slept in into a basket for washing later, then sets about cleaning himself.

However, today he stares at his reflection to take in the sight of his loose hair.

The strands scratch at his skin, but the sensation doesn't plunge him back into old traumas.

Now he remembers a loving caress and a faint smile.

…

Once clean and dressed in his hunting gear, Nier steps out of the washroom and lets out an exaggerated yawn to signal to his friend that he's ready for a new day.

He doesn't anticipate anything new or meaningful actually happening, but such thoughts are things Nier is content to keep to himself as Weiss shakes himself out of his resting stage.

"Hmm? Ah! Good morning, lad."

Nier nods at the book. "Morning. I'm…going to clean the upstairs room today. Mind keeping me company?"

Weiss scoffs. "Do I do anything else, lad?"

The warrior responds with a soft chuckle while moving to the kitchen to gather up cleaning supplies.

A few minutes later, the two of them ascend the stairs and enter the unoccupied room. Dried blood clings to the floorboards and across the thick blanket on the bed.

The young warrior walks forward. All his thoughts are centered on the task ahead, but Weiss pivots upon entry and...

"My word…that's…"

The book's words make Nier pause in his task. With a raised eyebrow, he looks toward the back corner of the room.

There, cast in the glow of the day's faint sunlight, is the completed portrait of Kainé...except standing tall by her side is another warrior dressed in complimentary hues of grey, faded green, and black. His sword is poised toward an unseen enemy, yet there is gleam of pure love in his stormy gaze while his unkempt, snow-white hair flows freely.

A foreign feeling of joy swells in Nier's heart when he gently presses his fingertips against the surface of the art. He relishes in the texture of layered paint and in the sharp vision of the future the work instills in his mind.

When he met Abigail Tanner, he thought of art as a wasteful thing, that it held no meaning in a world on the brink of death.

Now he understands.

Art is the means in which one immortalizes the human experience.

Abigail's emotions, her love, her anguish, hatred, and passion mingle with his determination, Kainé's courage, and those hills of radiant wind.

He will free Kainé and rescue Yonah someday. That's a truth he now knows from the depths of his soul.

"It's a stunning piece," Weiss remarks. "Truly."

Nier withdraws his hand from the painting with a renewed spirit.

"Y-Yeah. It is. Thank you, Abby."

He may not ever be able to let go of the hatred polluting his heart or forgive all the errors of the past, but he will never again relinquish hope for the future…because the possibilities given by time are endless.

…

From that day forward, Nier, with his hair free from its bindings, basks in the brightness of the sun whenever it comes.

Notes:

Thank you for reading. Once more, I hope you guys were able to find something meaningful and healing in this piece. It took me a while to get a feel for what I wanted this to say, and I'm still not 100% certain it says everything I wanted it to, but I'm very happy with how it turned out overall. This piece was a rough one, but it was definitely a healing piece for me. To all who may be struggling, continue to stay strong. Never lose hope for a brighter future. Life has many things that are tough, but you're not alone in any of it. We're all a little lost and a little broken, but together we can find healing. I believe that and pray for that for everyone who reads this work. Thank you. God bless you all.