Fenniks ShadowVanilla fics (of all kinds, shapes, and sizes.)

Series Metadata

Listing Series

• Bad things happen to good cookies, Good things happen to me by FenniktheFox

  Fandoms: Cookie Run (Video Game)  

  • Not Rated
  • Graphic Depictions Of Violence
  • M/M
  • Complete Work

  12 Jul 2025

  Tags

  • Graphic Depictions Of Violence
  • Pure Vanilla Cookie/Shadow Milk Cookie (Cookie Run)
  • Black Sapphire Cookie/Silverbell Cookie (Cookie Run)
  • Pure Vanilla Cookie (Cookie Run)
  • Shadow Milk Cookie (Cookie Run)
  • Black Sapphire Cookie (Cookie Run)
  • Candy Apple Cookie (Cookie Run)
  • Plushies
  • Voodoo
  • Voodoo Doll
  • Needles
  • Sewing
  • Crochet
  • Shadow Milk Cookie Needs a Hug (Cookie Run)
  • Soul Jam (Cookie Run)
  • Cookie Run Characters Are Cookies
  • Cookie Run Characters Have Jam Instead of Blood
  • Plush kisses
  • Shadow Milk plush
  • touch starved shadow milk
  • But he denies it
  • My First AO3 Post
  • My First Fanfic
  • Not beta read we die like Shadow Milk crème de la crème
  • Mild Vomiting
  • Past purelily
  • Shadow Milk crashes out
  • Fluff
  • kiss
  • Pure Vanilla Cookie Needs a Hug (Cookie Run)
  • Blackbell side plot

  Summary

  Shadow milk just recently finished a voodoo doll of himself he plans to hide in the ancient meeting room. Little does he know, that’s not where it ends up.

  Or

  Pure vanilla accidentally tortures Shadow Milk via Bluetooth.

  Season 1 is finished! I only gave a brief summery of the last episode in s2, sorry! Ran out of motivation lol.

  Series

  • Part 1 of Fenniks ShadowVanilla fics (of all kinds, shapes, and sizes.)

  Language:

  English

  Words:

  14,516

  Chapters:

  13/13

  Comments:

  391

  Kudos:

  1,345

  Bookmarks:

  106

  Hits:

  21,446

• The Witches the stake, you the dopamine. by FenniktheFox

  Fandoms: Cookie Run (Video Game)  

  • Teen And Up Audiences
  • Graphic Depictions Of Violence, Major Character Death
  • M/M
  • Complete Work

  07 Apr 2025

  Tags

  • Graphic Depictions Of Violence
  • Major Character Death
  • Pure Vanilla Cookie/Shadow Milk Cookie (Cookie Run)
  • Pure Vanilla Cookie & Shadow Milk Cookie (Cookie Run)
  • Shadow Milk Cookie (Cookie Run)
  • Pure Vanilla Cookie (Cookie Run)
  • Original Cookie Run Character(s)
  • Ancient Heroes (Cookie Run)
  • Five Beasts (Cookie Run)
  • Hurt/Comfort
  • Fear of Death
  • puremilk
  • Shadownilla
  • ShadowVanilla - Freeform
  • They’re already in a relationship
  • ugh i suck at tagging
  • Redeemed Shadow Milk
  • still kinda rude though
  • Not beta read we die like Shadow Milk crème de la crème

  Summary

  Shadow Milk and Pure Vanilla are happily sending their days in The Vanilla kingdom, years after Shadow Milk accepted truth. Suddenly, he’s informed that all the other beasts are crumbled. With basic pattern recognition, he’s able to figure out that he will be next.

  This scares him. He’s only lived with Pure Vanilla for a few years, and now he’s at deaths door? Just when he had found happiness?

  There are two different endings! Both are finished.

  Series

  • Part 2 of Fenniks ShadowVanilla fics (of all kinds, shapes, and sizes.)

  Language:

  English

  Words:

  6,999

  Chapters:

  9/9

  Comments:

  219

  Kudos:

  255

  Bookmarks:

  17

  Hits:

  4,802

• Far too late came far too soon. by FenniktheFox

  Fandoms: Cookie Run (Video Game)  

  • Not Rated
  • Graphic Depictions Of Violence, Major Character Death
  • M/M
  • Complete Work

  25 Apr 2025

  Tags

  • Graphic Depictions Of Violence
  • Major Character Death
  • Pure Vanilla Cookie/Shadow Milk Cookie (Cookie Run)
  • Shadow Milk Cookie (Cookie Run)
  • Pure Vanilla Cookie (Cookie Run)
  • Black Sapphire Cookie (Cookie Run)
  • White Lily Cookie | Saint Lily Cookie
  • Bad Ending
  • Inspired by OMORI
  • OMORI Spoilers
  • Theres spoilers in the tags too okay? Don’t read them if you’re gonna play Omori.
  • Spoilers
  • Suicide Attempt
  • Suicide
  • Sad Ending
  • Hurt No Comfort
  • Hurt
  • Hallucinations
  • Depression
  • Guilt
  • Mental Exhaustion
  • This fic made my beta reader cry!
  • So be warned
  • Inspired by TheRealSMCFan

  Summary

  A few months after Shadow Milk had been redeemed, and he moved into the Vanilla Castle with Pure Vanilla, he gets into an argument with Pure Vanilla. It ends badly.

  MIND THE TAGS.

  (Btw, I kind of find myself disliking this fic recently, so only read it if you’re like super bored or something and don’t take it as the standard for my writing.)

  Series

  • Part 3 of Fenniks ShadowVanilla fics (of all kinds, shapes, and sizes.)

  Language:

  English

  Words:

  2,908

  Chapters:

  1/1

  Comments:

  34

  Kudos:

  108

  Bookmarks:

  7

  Hits:

  1,722

• Amnesia was her name by FenniktheFox, Suffering6636

  Fandoms: Cookie Run (Video Game)  

  • Not Rated
  • No Archive Warnings Apply
  • F/M, M/M
  • Work in Progress

  19 Aug 2026

  Tags

  • No Archive Warnings Apply
  • Pure Vanilla Cookie/Shadow Milk Cookie (Cookie Run)
  • Shadow Milk Cookie (Cookie Run)
  • Pure Vanilla Cookie (Cookie Run)
  • White Lily Cookie | Saint Lily Cookie
  • Black Sapphire Cookie (Cookie Run)
  • Candy Apple Cookie (Cookie Run)
  • There’s technically some Purelily here so be aware
  • Amnesia
  • Redeemed Shadow Milk
  • Kind Of
  • Shadow Milk Cookie Needs a Hug (Cookie Run)
  • Shadow Milk Cookie-centric (Cookie Run)
  • Minor Pure Vanilla Cookie/White Lily Cookie | Saint Lily Cookie
  • Black Sapphire Cookie And Candy Apple Cookie Are Siblings (Cookie Run)
  • Candy Apple Cookie is a Little Shit (Cookie Run)

  Summary

  After Shadow Milks redemption, he admires Pure Vanilla cookie. Really, really admires him. He gets butterflies in his stomach when he’s around. From admiration.

  He gets a letter that Pure Vanilla is marrying White Lily. And he cannot handle that. (Really, really can’t handle it. If only he could make Pure Vanilla’s memories of White Lily disappear!)
  -
  The storyline and draft for this were written before the silent salt beast yeast, and certainly before beast yeast 14-15. Keep this in mind when reading.

  Series

  • Part 4 of Fenniks ShadowVanilla fics (of all kinds, shapes, and sizes.)

  Language:

  English

  Words:

  5,193

  Chapters:

  4/5

  Comments:

  37

  Kudos:

  42

  Bookmarks:

  5

  Hits:

  801

• Fenniks Oneshot collection by FenniktheFox

  Fandoms: Cookie Run (Video Game)  

  • Not Rated
  • Creator Chose Not To Use Archive Warnings
  • M/M
  • Work in Progress

  12 Jan 2026

  Tags

  • Creator Chose Not To Use Archive Warnings
  • Pure Vanilla Cookie/Shadow Milk Cookie (Cookie Run)
  • Shadow Milk Cookie (Cookie Run)
  • Pure Vanilla Cookie (Cookie Run)
  • Candy Apple Cookie (Cookie Run)
  • Black Sapphire Cookie (Cookie Run)
  • no actual story
  • One Shot Collection
  • I don’t wanna tag. I’ll do it later

  Summary

  Hey hi hello I’m Fennik and I like to write about ShadowVanilla. But I suck at writing for long periods. So here’s some one shots.
  (Or actually just one right now.)

  Each one will be tagged either comedy or tragedy depending on the feel.

  Series

  • Part 5 of Fenniks ShadowVanilla fics (of all kinds, shapes, and sizes.)

  Language:

  English

  Words:

  488

  Chapters:

  1/?

  Comments:

  1

  Kudos:

  6

  Bookmarks:

  2

  Hits:

  80