Work Text:
Lottie Matthews had always been the picture of control. As the captain of the college soccer team, she thrived on discipline and structure, her life carefully orchestrated like a finely tuned clock. Yet beneath that polished exterior, she struggled with a storm of emotions that threatened to break free.
It all began during their freshman year, when she first caught Nat’s eye during a particularly brutal soccer practice. Lottie had been running drills, her focus unyielding, but Nat’s raw energy was magnetic. The way Nat tackled opponents, fierce and unapologetic, drew Lottie in. There was a spark—a connection that made Lottie’s heart race and her palms sweat.
But as the months turned into years, Lottie buried those feelings, convincing herself that they were nothing more than a passing crush. Nat, with her wild spirit, was everything Lottie was not. While Lottie sought perfection and order, Nat thrived in chaos, often getting into trouble and pushing boundaries. They were polar opposites, and Lottie told herself that was a good thing.
Yet, the tension between them only grew. The playful banter turned into something charged, laden with unspoken words. Every shared glance lingered just a moment too long, and every accidental touch ignited a fire that Lottie desperately tried to extinguish. She could feel herself getting pulled into Nat’s orbit, and it terrified her.
Now, standing in the empty locker room after practice, Lottie felt that familiar pull again. She had lingered behind, needing time to think about everything that had been unsaid between them. The air was thick with tension, and she could feel it crackling like electricity, especially when Nat walked in.
“Didn’t expect you to stay late,” Lottie said, her voice a mix of surprise and longing.
Nat shrugged, her dark hair falling into her eyes as she moved closer. “Yeah, well, I needed some space. Things have been rough at home.” Her tone was casual, but Lottie could see the storm brewing beneath the surface.
“Want to talk about it?” Lottie asked, trying to keep her voice steady, though her heart raced at the sight of Nat’s tension.
Nat shook her head, but her eyes didn’t leave Lottie’s. “Not really. But I’ve been thinking… about us.”
Lottie’s breath hitched. “What do you mean?”
Nat stepped closer, the distance between them evaporating. “I’m tired of pretending. We both know there’s something here. Something we can’t ignore.” Her voice was low, intense, filled with a raw honesty that sent shivers down Lottie’s spine.
“I can’t—” Lottie began, but the words felt hollow. Deep down, she knew she wanted this, wanted Nat. But the fear of losing everything she had built held her back.
“Just… let me show you,” Nat pleaded, her gaze piercing through Lottie’s defenses.
Before Lottie could respond, Nat closed the gap, capturing Lottie’s lips in a desperate kiss. It was fierce and hungry, igniting every suppressed feeling that Lottie had tried to keep at bay. Lottie gasped, her mind racing, caught off guard by the intensity of it all.
Lottie pulled back, her heart pounding. “Nat, we can’t…”
“Why not?” Nat interrupted, her breath mingling with Lottie’s. “Why do we have to pretend? I want you, Lottie.”
The raw honesty in Nat’s voice broke through Lottie’s reservations. She felt herself slipping, losing the battle she had fought so hard to maintain. “I want you too,” Lottie confessed, her voice barely above a whisper. “But this… this could change everything.”
“It doesn’t have to,” Nat replied, her determination unwavering. “We can’t keep dancing around this.”
With a sudden urgency, Nat grabbed Lottie’s waist, pulling her close again, their lips crashing together. The kiss was electric, a collision of desire and desperation. Lottie felt her control slipping, her body responding to Nat’s every move as if it were an instinct.
“God, Nat…” Lottie breathed as Nat trailed kisses down her neck, leaving a trail of heat in their wake. Every touch ignited a fire within her, a hunger she hadn’t allowed herself to feel.
“I’ve wanted this for so long,” Nat murmured, her voice thick with desire. “You have no idea how much.”
Lottie felt her control slipping, that careful mask she wore cracking at the edges. "Nat…" she began, trying to keep her voice steady, trying to hold onto whatever composure she had left.
Nat’s eyes darkened, and for the first time, she let the mask fall. She leaned forward, her voice low, raw with emotion. "I’m done pretending, Lottie. I know you feel it too."
Lottie swallowed hard, her breath catching in her throat. The words she wanted to say got stuck, tangled up in the heat rising between them. She had no more denials left, no more excuses. All she could do was stare back at Nat, her heart pounding against her ribs.
And then, in one sudden, reckless moment, Nat closed the distance between them once more. Her lips crashed into Lottie’s, the force of it making Lottie gasp as she was shoved back against the lockers. The kiss was more rough this time, full of all the things they hadn’t said. All the tension, the frustration, the need—it poured into that kiss, consuming them both.
Lottie moaned into Nat’s mouth, her hands gripping Nat’s shoulders, pulling her closer, needing more of her. She didn’t care anymore. She didn’t care about control, about perfection, about keeping her distance. All she cared about was this—Nat’s body against hers, Nat’s hands exploring her skin, the overwhelming heat of their connection.
Nat’s lips trailed down Lottie’s neck, biting and sucking, leaving marks that would linger. Lottie arched into her touch, her breath coming in shallow gasps as Nat’s hands roamed over her body. She felt like she was burning from the inside out, her body thrumming with a need so intense it was almost painful.
Lottie’s fingers tangled in Nat’s hair, tugging, desperate to feel more of her. Nat responded in kind, her hands sliding down to Lottie’s hips, gripping them tightly as she pressed her harder against the locker.
"You’re killing me, Lottie," Nat growled, her breath hot against Lottie’s ear.
Lottie’s heart raced as Nat’s hand dipped between her thighs, fingers brushing over the wet heat through her shorts. She gasped, her hips jerking instinctively against Nat’s touch, desperate for more.
“God, you’re so fucking wet,” Nat whispered, her voice husky, full of dark amusement as she slid her fingers along Lottie’s slick folds. “You’ve been thinking about this, haven’t you? Thinking about me.”
Lottie whimpered, her body trembling as Nat’s fingers continued their torturous exploration. She could barely form words, her mind foggy with desire. “Yes… fuck, yes…”
Nat grinned wickedly as she hooked her fingers into the waistband of Lottie’s shorts, yanking them down in one swift motion. Lottie kicked them off, her body already shaking with need as Nat knelt before her. The sight of Nat on her knees, her eyes dark with lust, was almost enough to make Lottie lose it right there.
But Nat wasn’t done. She reached into her bag, pulling out a strap-on harness. The sight of the black silicone toy gleaming in the dim locker room light sent a fresh wave of heat flooding through Lottie’s body.
Lottie watched, breathless, as Nat strapped it on, tightening the harness around her hips with a practiced ease. Her eyes never left Lottie’s, that dangerous glint in them only intensifying.
“Is this what you want?” Nat asked, her voice low and rough, filled with a predatory hunger that made Lottie’s knees weak.
Lottie nodded, unable to speak, her body already arching toward Nat in anticipation. “Please…”
Nat didn’t hesitate. She stood, grabbed Lottie’s thighs, and lifted her effortlessly, pinning her back against the cold metal lockers. Lottie gasped, her legs wrapping instinctively around Nat’s waist as Nat positioned herself at Lottie’s entrance.
And then Nat thrust into her.
Lottie cried out, her head falling back against the locker as Nat filled her completely. The stretch, the fullness—it was overwhelming, too much and not enough all at once. Nat didn’t give her time to adjust, didn’t slow down. She began thrusting hard and fast, her grip on Lottie’s thighs tight, bruising.
Lottie’s body moved with Nat’s, her hips grinding against her, chasing the friction, the intensity. Each thrust sent a shockwave of pleasure coursing through her, building higher and higher, until Lottie thought she might explode from it.
“You feel so fucking good,” Nat growled, her breath hot against Lottie’s neck. Her hand slid between them, fingers finding Lottie’s clit and rubbing it in time with her thrusts. “So tight around me.”
Lottie’s moans grew louder, her body trembling uncontrollably as Nat drove her closer and closer to the edge. She could feel the orgasm building, a white-hot coil of tension deep in her belly, ready to snap at any moment. But Nat wasn’t letting her off easy.
“Nat i’m so close…fuck”
But she kept the pace relentless, her fingers working Lottie’s clit with perfect, punishing precision.
“Come for me,” Nat whispered, her voice dark and commanding. “I want to feel you fall apart.”
And with that, Lottie shattered.
Her orgasm hit her like a tidal wave, crashing over her in waves of pleasure so intense she couldn’t breathe. She screamed, her body convulsing as the pleasure ripped through her, every nerve ending on fire. Nat followed soon after, her own body trembling with release as she groaned into Lottie’s neck.
For a moment, they stayed like that, their bodies still entwined, breathing heavy, hearts pounding in sync.
When Nat finally pulled away, her eyes met Lottie’s, and for a second, they both just stood there, staring at each other, chest heaving, the reality of what had just happened slowly sinking in.
But neither of them said a word.
Because they both knew—this wasn’t the last time.