Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Category:
Fandom:
Relationships:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2026-01-03
Updated:
2026-11-16
Words:
249,964
Chapters:
27/?
Comments:
789
Kudos:
937
Bookmarks:
296
Hits:
39,167

Tell Me I’m The Worst (Tell Me You’ll Love Me Anyway)

Summary:

“You’re the one who kissed me!”

“I didn’t mean to!” Mike shouted back, his voice booming across the apartment.

“Look, I—” Mike ran a hand through his hair, pacing.

“Get out.” Will was already moving toward the door, hand on the knob. He needed Mike gone before he said something irreversible—before the words spilled out sharp and unforgiving.

Or

After defeating Vecna, the party agreed to host a get-together every other month, rotating between them. It worked—until the first letter arrived at Will’s dorm. love, Mike scribbled along the edge. And then Mike couldn’t stay away. Literally.

So Will told himself he was over Mike. Over reading into every word, every pause, every letter. With every gathering and every exchanged letter, and every confusing touch. The tension tightened, coiling toward something inevitable.

A lip ring, a pair of pink lace boxers and multiple gay erotica letters and a gut wrenching lie —is enough to give Mike wheeler a well deserved crash out.

Through his panic, love, and devastation, Mike sets on a path of self destruction all the while begging Will to hold him together.

Chapter 1: Too Far AparT Hangouts

Chapter Text

 

Will was royally fucked.

This was the third time he’d slept in this week—and the third time he’d been late to his Introduction to Western Art class. Entirely his fault. He’d stayed up far too late working on a project for another course, convincing himself he had time to spare.

He didn’t.

He stumbled into the classroom in a spectacularly uncool fashion. A few students near the door shot him annoyed looks; others didn’t bother hiding their eye rolls.

“Nice of you to finally grace us with your attendance today,” Mr. Markley crooned, bending slightly and peering at Will over his glasses.

“Sorry,” Will muttered, already weaving toward the nearest empty seat. He dropped into the chair beside a girl with more facial piercings than Will had ever seen on a single person—one glinting through her eyebrow. He fumbled for his textbook and pencils, acutely aware that Mr. Markley had paused mid-lecture to watch him struggle.

“See me after class, Mister Byers,” the professor said once Will finally settled.

Great.

Later, Will stared at the calendar taped to his door, the crisp white paper stark against the yellowed wood. Three days until Friday. He tried not to smile. He’d be lying to himself if he pretended he wasn’t desperate to see his friends after two months of no updates.

Lucas and Max attended the same college—the farthest from the rest of them. Rutgers had been the only school that accepted Max after her two-year coma, and Lucas hadn’t hesitated to follow. He’d earned a basketball scholarship; Max was studying education. Lucas still hadn’t quite learned how to let her out of his sight, and Max pretended not to notice.

Dustin, of course, went to NYU. He claimed it had the best physics program in the country and dared anyone to argue. Jonathan studied there too, which meant that whenever gatherings were hosted at Dustin’s dorm, Will got the added comfort of seeing his brother.

Mike studied literature—after the rest of them practically bullied him into it. He had a gift for words; his D&D campaigns alone were proof. Columbia’s acceptance letter arrived the day after Mike resigned himself to a local community college, which his mom treated like divine intervention. She threw a party so extravagant it spilled onto the sidewalk. She liked to joke that even if Mike hadn’t chosen Columbia, she would’ve stuffed him into a suitcase and handed him to Will at the front gates herself.

The first semester hit Will harder than he expected. After his mom and Jonathan unloaded his things and said their goodbyes, he stood alone in his apartment, unsure what to do with the quiet.

By the second week, he realized he preferred staying on campus. He was grateful to live alone—but only when he was painting or studying. Otherwise, the silence pressed in, heavy and dull. Lonely, if he were honest.

He spent time with classmates occasionally, but only when invited. He never initiated plans, never wanted to impose. Most weekends ended at the pub near campus. Clara, his friend from Fundamentals of Drawing, would find him after class and invite him along to Luke’s with the rest of the group. Will always accepted, always grateful, even if he knew he hovered at the edges rather than belonging fully.

Still, they were friends. That counted for something.

Friday couldn’t come fast enough. Seeing his group—his real one—felt like coming up for air. Two months didn’t sound like much, but it felt longer to Will; he didn’t know if the others felt the same and he wouldn’t ask of course.

Well. Almost all of them.

Will and Mike started exchanging letters after the second official get-together. It began with a frantic phone call: Mike, panicking over his composition assignment due in two days that, in his words, “sucked ass.”

Mike read it aloud. Will asked him to read it again. This time, Will wrote alongside him, catching phrases, rearranging sentences, offering edits. They stayed on the phone for two hours, comparing notes, refining ideas—laughing more than either of them expected.

That night, Will’s apartment felt less empty.

The following week, he entered his building and checked his mail, finding an envelope from Mike. Inside were three pages—and a five-dollar bill.

“Cheaper than phone bills.
You can write down your comments and suggestions on it IN RED MARKERS ONLY PLEASE. Send it back when you’re done.
5$ for your troubles, Will the Wise.
Love,
Mike.”

Will stood in the lobby for what felt like five minutes, rereading it. Then he ran upstairs to start reviewing Mike’s work on Pride and Prejudice.

As the semester progressed, their letters gradually shifted. Assignments became less central; their correspondence became a kind of pen-pal ritual. And every time they hung out at one of the designated get-together locations, they seemed to forget about the letters—or at least their contents—in front of the rest of the group. At least, that’s how it felt for Will.

He would get distracted by Dustin’s endless updates about his latest crush from chemistry class, and completely forget to ask Mike about his assignments—or his poetry professor, whom he was convinced was out to get him.

That evening, after brushing his teeth, Will made a note to himself: he had to ask Mike if he was still planning to take French literature next semester. Mike seemed torn, vacillating between French and Asian literature, and Will didn’t want to miss the chance to weigh in.

On Thursday, Will decided to skip Clara’s invitation and pick up snacks and beer for his friends—it was his turn to host the hangout. His budget wasn’t as tight as it had been the last time they’d come over. He’d taken a part-time job at the bodega wedged between his apartment and campus.

Between rent and his constant need for new art supplies, he needed a hustle. Especially after finding out Jonathan had started working too—making Will the only one still taking money from their mom, which felt entirely unacceptable.

Spring in New York was interesting, to say the least. People seemed so sick of winter that they were, in Will’s opinion, wildly underdressed for the weather. He hadn’t hesitated to grab his jacket that morning, but as he walked down the street, he passed multiple guys in T-shirts—even as the sun dipped lower in the sky.

When he reached the store, Will couldn’t help the smile that spread across his face at the sight of Mr. Harris behind the register. The old man wore a white T-shirt with a black apron slung over one shoulder. He looked up from the bills he was counting when the bell above the door rang.

“You workin’ tonight, Will?” Mr. Harris asked, a cigarette dangling from his mouth.

“Hey—no,” Will replied, already heading for the shelves. “Just grabbing some stuff for the weekend.”

“Oh, have a nice one, kid,” Mr. Harris said, stepping away from the register. “Ring yourself up when you’re done, okay?”

“Thanks, Mr. Harris. I’ll call you when I’m about to leave,” Will called over his shoulder.

“I told you to call me H, William,” Mr. Harris shot back.

Will barely heard him. He was too busy hunting for the honey barbecue chips Mike requested at every hangout that wasn’t hosted in his dorm. He found the bag where he’d hidden it so it wouldn’t sell out, then headed toward the fridge.

“Will?”

He turned to see a guy around his age approaching with a smile.

He wore pale jeans, a black leather jacket, and a dark shirt underneath. He looked familiar—uncomfortably so—but Will couldn’t quite place him.

“Hi,” Will managed. The guy’s face was too handsome to forget, if he was being honest with himself. He had a straight white smile, a dimple on one of his cheeks and bright blue eyes that are so mesmerizing combined with his jet black hair. He could probably give Steve a run for his money with how smooth and shines his hair is.

“Right—sorry,” the guy laughed softly. “You don’t know me yet.”

That made Will blush, and he hoped it was emotional rather than physical.

“I’m Connor. From your sculpting class?”

Recognition clicked instantly. Connor—the one whose sculptures looked effortlessly better than the models they were supposed to replicate, while Will’s always came out slightly crooked.

“Oh—yeah. Hi!” Will extended his hand. Connor shook it firmly.

“How’s it going?”

“Good,” Connor said. “Just grabbing beers for a party at my friend’s dorm at NYU. You?”

“Oh—nice. I’m good.” Will hesitated, then added, “I’m getting stuff for a get-together with my friends from home tomorrow.”

“That’s cool.” Connor slipped his hands into his back pockets. “So… what are you doing tonight?”

“Nothing, really. I was just gonna drop this off at my apartment and—”

“Great, then you should come with me,” Connor interrupted, smiling wider. “I know I’m being pushy—we literally just met—but you’ve got nothing to do, right? I only know the guy hosting, so we can be awkward and brood in a corner together.”

Will considered it.

He didn’t know Connor. He didn’t know the party or the people there. He had an early class the next morning.

But he only had one class on Fridays. He could nap before his friends showed up. He might even have a story to tell Mike next time they saw each other.

And—he’d never been invited anywhere by a guy before. It was always Clara, her friends, and their boyfriends. And once the drinking started, the boyfriends clung to their girlfriends like vampires. Maybe having a guy friend—especially one in the arts—wouldn’t be so bad. There weren’t many of them.

“Alright,” Will shrugged. “Why not?”

Connor lit up and held out his hand. Will took it.

“But I’ve gotta drop this stuff at my place first. And change,” Will added, gesturing to the counter.

“Cool. Want me to come with you or wait here?”

Will smiled casually. “I’ll be back in ten.”

“Alright,” Connor said. “Don’t leave me hanging.”

Will grabbed the beers, sodas, and—after a moment’s thought—a bottle of vodka. It was cheap enough to experiment with. He rang everything up while Connor waited nearby, then grabbed a pack of Camels. Connor raised an eyebrow.

“Oh—you work here?”

“Yeah,” Will said sheepishly.

After paying, he told Connor to wait inside the store in case Mr. Harris came out. Then he bolted home.

The walk that usually took five minutes took three. He dumped the bags on the metal table by the door and sprinted to his closet. For once, he genuinely didn’t know what to wear.

After three shirts and a GAP hoodie, he settled on a simple striped tee. He added just enough cologne to be noticeable—though he figured Connor would assume he was trying to impress girls.

By the time they headed toward NYU, it was late. Dropping by Dustin’s dorm would only get him kicked out, and Jonathan was probably working. Will decided he’d go to the party, leave at a reasonable hour, and sleep.

“You mind if I smoke?” Will asked.

“Go ahead,” Connor said. Will noticed the quick glances then—nervous ones. It was oddly comforting.

“So the guy hosting is a finance major,” Connor added. “He can be a little…”

“Douchy?” Will offered, cigarette between his lips—then immediately regretted it.

Connor laughed. “Yeah. But he’s cool. I swear.” He nudged Will’s shoulder.

Oh.

They walked in companionable silence, cold air biting at Will’s nose and lips. When they reached the dorm, it was overflowing. The shift in atmosphere was suffocating—music pounding, lights low and colorful. David Bowie played as students spilled out into the hallway, some even opening their dorms to accommodate the crowd.

They squeezed through sideways. The host—Mark—who seemed influenced by more than alcohol, pulled Will into a full hug. Will glanced helplessly at Connor, who only laughed and shrugged.

The rest of the night blurred. Connor kept his promise and stayed close. And Will realized—somewhere between beers and laughter—that he was actually having fun.

They talked about campus stereotypes, their majors. When Connor spoke about his hometown, Will listened.

“I actually suck ass at sculpting,” Will blurted suddenly, far louder than necessary. He set his beer aside, realizing he should slow down.

Connor doubled over laughing—and Will laughed too, because suck ass really was funny.

“It’s fine,” Connor said. “I’ll help you with sculpting if you help me with shading. Deal?”

Will offered his hand. Connor took it. They laughed again.


*************


Will tried to think long and hard the next day about how he’d made it back to his apartment. When his mind came up blank, he gave up. His hangover helped him give up on a lot of things.

He skipped his class that morning and slept in. When he woke up again that afternoon, his head felt noticeably better, and he didn’t regret skipping class much at all.

He remembered leaving campus with Connor and giving him his number. But beyond that, his memory was completely erased.

It was fine. He could just ask Connor about it when he saw him on Monday in class.

The rest of the day was spent tidying up his apartment and airing it out. He didn’t want any of his friends finding out about his smoking habits—though he suspected Max already knew. Every time she came over, she sniffed the air and shot daggers at him.

After spraying the apartment with an excessive amount of air freshener, Will heated up leftover Chinese food and ate it with an uneasy stomach.

At six p.m., there was a knock on his apartment door, and Will sighed with relief. There had been a tuned voice in his head all day telling him they weren’t coming.

He opened the door, and Dustin walked in as if the door were merely a suggestion.

“You won’t believe what happened in chemistry yesterday!” Dustin said by way of greeting. Then he raised his hands beside his head. “Actually—no. I’m not telling you until everyone’s here. Where is everyone?” He looked around the empty apartment.

“Hi, Dustin,” Will said, still standing by the door, holding it open.

“Hey, buddy.” Dustin crossed the room and gave Will a quick hug.

Will closed the door and moved toward the fridge to offer Dustin something to drink when another knock sounded. When he opened the door, Max and Lucas stepped inside holding a bottle of wine.

Well—Lucas was holding the bottle. He handed it to Will along with a hug, while Max entered the room nose first, chin lifted, sniffing the air.

“Jesus Christ,” she said as a greeting. “This place smells like a candle store.”

“It smells like Lucas’s meemaw’s titties,” Dustin offered from the couch at the far end of the room.

Lucas crossed the space faster than lightning, and the second he touched Dustin, Dustin screamed, “I YIELD! I YIELD!”

“Loser,” Max said fondly as she walked over and hugged Dustin.

“Educator of your future children, everyone!” Dustin announced, holding his arms out to no one in particular.

Max rolled her eyes and spun toward Will. The attention reminded him that he was the host, and he started toward the fridge again.

“You look like shit,” Max said matter-of-factly.

Dustin and Lucas both looked up.

“Why?” Max added.

“I was at a party last night,” Will told them, refocusing on the contents of the fridge. “Wine or beer?”

“Beer,” Dustin said, squinting. “Whose party?”

“I don’t know. A friend took me,” Will shrugged as he pulled a beer from the pack. “Well—not my friend. A guy from class.”

“Beer,” Lucas said. Then, suggestively, “A guy friend?”

“Yeah, so?” Will shot back in the same tone, tossing a can in Lucas’s direction.

“Beer,” Max said, giving her boyfriend a look. “So who is this guy who asked you to a party instead of going out with a girl?” Now that Max mentioned it, Will wondered the same thing. Why had Connor taken him instead of bringing a date? Maybe he was already seeing someone, but she was busy and couldn’t come with him.

“Why did you even bring the wine?” Will asked her, earning a shrug in return.They were all sitting on his couch now, watching him intently waiting for an answer.

“His name’s Connor,” Will said. He was just about to explain—his theory half-formed—when a voice came from behind him.

“Who’s Connor?”