Chapter Text
Lila liked the corner table by the window.
It wasn’t really a window, just a long strip of glass set high in the wall of the community center’s after-school room, but it let her see pieces of the outside world. Tree branches sometimes brushed against it when the wind blew. On sunny days, thin bars of light stretched across the floor like quiet little ladders.
She liked those ladders.
Today she sat there with a sheet of paper and a dull green crayon, drawing a dog that looked more like a blob with four sticks for legs. She didn’t mind. The dog made her smile anyway.
Around her, the room buzzed with the usual after-school sounds. Chairs scraping, kids arguing over markers, a volunteer reminding someone to clean up glitter. Lila kept mostly to herself. She had learned that if she stayed quiet and didn’t ask for too much, adults seemed less tired when they looked at her.
“Is that a puppy?” Lila looked up. The woman standing beside the table had soft gray hair pulled into a low bun and wore a long brown coat even though she was inside. Her voice was gentle, almost warm, like the librarians at school.
Lila nodded. “It’s a puppy,” she said softly. The woman crouched beside the table, lowering herself slowly like she didn’t want to scare anything away. “He looks very friendly,” the woman said.
Lila studied her for a moment before sliding the paper across the table. “He doesn’t have a name yet.” The woman tilted her head thoughtfully. “That’s a big responsibility,” she said. “Naming someone.”
Lila considered this very seriously. “I like Daisy,” she said finally.
“Daisy is perfect.” The woman smiled, the kind that made small lines appear around her eyes. “I’m Margaret.”
Lila didn’t offer her own name right away. The caseworker had once told her she didn’t have to talk to strangers if she didn’t want to. But Margaret didn’t feel like a stranger in the scary kind of way. She felt… calm.
After a moment, Lila said quietly, “I’m Lila.”
“Hello, Lila.” Margaret reached into the canvas tote bag hanging from her shoulder. “I brought something today,” she said. She pulled out a small box of brand-new crayons, bright ones, not the short broken kind that lived in the center’s supply bin. Lila’s eyes widened.
“For the art table,” Margaret added quickly, placing them between them, but she pushed the box a little closer to Lila. “Would you like to try them first?” Lila looked toward the other kids. Nobody seemed to notice.
Slowly, she opened the box. The crayons were perfect, sharp tips, smooth paper wrappers, colors she hadn’t even seen before. She carefully picked a sky-blue one.
Margaret watched her draw for a while, quiet and patient. “You’re very careful,” Margaret said after a moment. Lila shrugged a little. “If I mess up, I have to start over.”
Margaret nodded like that made complete sense. “Well,” she said softly, “sometimes careful people make the best artists.” The compliment made warmth bloom somewhere in Lila’s chest.
Across the room, one of the staff members called out that pick-ups would start soon. Kids began packing their bags, and Lila’s stomach twisted a little. She never liked pick-up time. It meant waiting and wondering if someone would remember to come get her.
Margaret noticed the way she glanced toward the door. “Do you know who’s picking you up today?” she asked gently. Lila shook her head. “Maybe Miss Karen,” she said. “Or the other lady.”
Margaret’s expression softened even more. “That must be confusing.” Lila didn’t answer. She kept coloring Daisy’s ears.
After a moment, Margaret said quietly, “Would you like to see something outside before everyone leaves?” Lila looked up. “There’s a little garden behind the building,” Margaret continued. “I help take care of it sometimes. There’s a swing there too.”
A swing.
Lila’s heart gave a hopeful little jump. “Just for a minute,” Margaret said reassuringly. “We’ll be right outside the door.” Lila hesitated. The room was loud and busy, and Margaret’s voice felt safe in comparison.
She carefully placed the crayon back in the box. “Okay.” Margaret stood and offered her hand. Lila slipped her small fingers into it.
The hallway outside the classroom was quiet. Their footsteps echoed softly on the tile as Margaret led her toward the back exit.
Lila felt a tiny flutter in her stomach. “Is the swing big?” she asked. Margaret smiled down at her. “Oh yes,” she said. “Plenty big.” They pushed through the metal door into the cool afternoon air.
Behind the building, the parking lot stretched mostly empty. The garden Margaret had mentioned sat off to one side, but Lila noticed something else first.
A van that was parked close to the side door. Lila slowed a little when she saw it. The garden Margaret had mentioned sat farther back, past a chain-link fence, and there was definitely no swing nearby.
Margaret’s hand rested lightly on her shoulder. “Just a moment,” Margaret said. Lila frowned. “I thought the swing—” The van door slid open with a harsh metallic scrape.
Something inside Lila’s chest tightened instantly. The sound didn’t feel right. Neither did the way Margaret’s hand suddenly pressed more firmly against her back.
Lila took a small step away. “Wait,” she said, her voice thin. “I wanna go back.” Margaret’s fingers closed around her wrist, too tight.
Lila froze.
“Come on,” Margaret said quietly. Her voice had changed. It wasn’t warm anymore. Lila pulled her arm back instinctively. “You’re hurting me,” she said. Margaret’s expression stayed calm, but her grip tightened again. “It’ll only take a moment.”
Something cold and prickly spread through Lila’s stomach. She twisted harder, trying to slip free. “I don’t want to,” she said, louder now. Margaret’s patience snapped like a thread. Her hand shot forward, grabbing Lila around the shoulders and pulling her toward the open van.
Lila screamed, the sound tore out of her throat before she even realized she was making it. “Help!” She kicked wildly, her sneakers scraping against the pavement as Margaret tried to lift her. “Stop it,” Margaret hissed under her breath.
Lila thrashed harder, and her elbow connected with Margaret’s ribs, and the woman grunted in surprise. For a split second, Margaret loosened her grip.
Lila bolted.
She only made it three steps before Margaret caught the back of her jacket. The fabric jerked tight around her throat as she was yanked backward. “Let go!” Lila screamed, twisting and clawing at the woman’s arm.
Margaret dragged her toward the van again, breathing harder now. “Stop fighting.”
“I want Miss Karen!” Lila cried. “I want to go back!” Her small hands clawed at Margaret’s coat, nails digging into the fabric. She kicked again, her heel slamming against the side of the van with a loud clang. The sound echoed through the empty lot.
Margaret’s eyes darted toward the building, irritation flickered across her face. “Enough,” she muttered. With one arm pinning Lila against her side, Margaret reached into the pocket of her coat. Lila saw the movement and fought harder, twisting her body and trying to bite the hand holding her.
Margaret pulled out a small cloth, before Lila could turn away, the cloth was pressed firmly over her nose and mouth. A sharp, chemical smell flooded her senses. Lila jerked violently. Her muffled cries turned into panicked gasps as she tried to hold her breath. Her legs kicked wildly, sneakers thudding uselessly against Margaret’s hip.
The world began to wobble. “No—” Lila tried to say, but the word came out slurred and weak. Her arms felt heavy, and the parking lot tilted sideways. Margaret held the cloth in place, her grip steady despite Lila’s fading struggle. “Shhh,” she said quietly.
Lila’s movements slowed, her small hands slipping weakly against Margaret’s coat. The edges of her vision blurred. The sky above the building swam into gray. Her last attempt to fight came as a weak shove against Margaret’s shoulder. Then her arms fell limp.
Margaret caught her easily before she could collapse. The van door slid open again. She lifted the unconscious child inside and laid her carefully across the back seat. The cloth disappeared back into her pocket.
Margaret paused for a moment, studying the girl’s still face. “Such a stubborn one, hopefully we can fix that quickly.” she murmured, then she slid the door shut.
The engine started a moment later, the low rumble filling the quiet lot, as the van pulled away from the community center, the afternoon returned to its ordinary rhythm.
Inside the classroom, Lila’s drawing still rested on the corner table, and Daisy the puppy stared up from the paper, her sky-blue ears still unfinished.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
The first thing Lila noticed was the light. It wasn’t sunlight, sunlight moved. It warmed things. It made shadows stretch and crawl across the floor. This light didn’t move at all, it buzzed. A faint humming sound filled the room, like a trapped insect living inside the ceiling.
Lila’s eyes fluttered open slowly. Her head felt heavy, like it was stuffed with cotton. When she tried to move, a dull ache pulsed behind her eyes. For a moment she didn’t remember where she was, then the van came rushing back.
Margaret, the cloth, the smell. Lila shot upright with a sharp gasp, the room around her was unfamiliar. Concrete walls painted a dull gray surrounded her. The ceiling hung low above her head, lined with long fluorescent lights that hummed softly.
The air smelled strange. Clean, but stale, like a place where windows were never opened. She was sitting on a narrow bed, not the bed from her foster home. A small blanket pooled around her legs. Lila’s chest tightened.
“Where am I?” she whispered. Her voice sounded small in the quiet room, for a moment, nothing happened. Then a soft voice spoke nearby, “She’s awake.”
Lila’s head snapped toward the sound. Three girls sat and stood near the far side of the room, they had been watching her. Lila shrank backward against the wall.
The oldest stepped forward first.
She was taller than the others, thin and pale, with long brown hair pulled into a loose braid that hung over one shoulder. She looked about thirteen, maybe older, though her face carried a tiredness that made her seem older still.
Her movements were slow and careful, like she didn’t want to scare Lila. “I’m Piper,” she said gently.
Behind her stood a girl with dark hair tied tightly into a low ponytail. Her posture was straight and alert, her eyes studying Lila with sharp attention, she looked around ten. “My name is Samira,” she said.
The third girl leaned against the wall with her arms crossed.
She was smaller than Samira but stood with a kind of stubborn confidence, like she refused to let anything push her around. Her dark hair was cut unevenly at her shoulders, and her eyes held a fierce, guarded expression. “Trinity,” she said shortly.
Lila stared at them, three strangers, three kids. Her heart began racing again. “Where am I?” she asked, louder now. The girls exchanged a look.
Piper knelt beside the bed. “You’re in the basement,” she said quietly. Lila shook her head. “No.” Her breathing quickened. “I want to go back to the foster house.” Piper didn’t answer right away, instead, she gently pulled the blanket higher around Lila’s shoulders.
“I know,” she said softly. Lila looked past them, finally noticing the rest of the room. It was bigger than she first realized. The bed she sat on was one of four lined along the wall.
Across the room sat a small table with three mismatched chairs, and one old stool. A narrow kitchenette occupied the far corner, just a sink, a microwave, and a tiny refrigerator.
There was a door too, a heavy metal door, and Lila’s eyes locked onto it instantly. She slid off the bed. “I’m leaving.” She ran toward it, before she could reach it, Trinity stepped in front of her.
“Don’t.” She said, but Lila tried to push past her. “I want to get out of here!” Trinity grabbed her shoulders, not roughly but firmly. “You can’t.”
“Yes I can!” Lila reached for the handle, but it didn’t move. She pulled harder. The metal rattled loudly but stayed locked. “Please,” Lila cried, yanking at it again.
Samira stepped closer. “It won’t open,” she said. Lila shook her head violently. “You don’t know that!” She slammed her hands against the door. “Let me out!” The sound echoed sharply through the room.
All three girls flinched.
“Lila.” Piper’s voice was gentle but urgent. “Stop.”
Lila kept pounding. “Someone will hear me!”
Samira glanced up at the ceiling, then she quietly said, “She’ll hear you.” The words hung in the air, before Lila could ask what she meant, a loud mechanical click echoed through the room. The metal door unlocked, and every girl froze, the door slowly swung open.
Margaret Vale stepped inside. She looked exactly the same as before, same brown coat, calm expression, and in her hands she carried a plastic tray with four small bowls of food. Lila backed away instinctively.
“You’re awake,” Margaret said, her voice warm again, like nothing had happened. She set the tray on the table.
The other girls moved immediately.
Samira stepped forward first, taking the bowls and placing them carefully on the table, Trinity pulled out chairs, Piper gently guided Lila away from the door. They moved quickly, quietly, like they had done this many times before.
Margaret watched them with quiet approval. “Good,” she said. Her eyes turned to Lila. “You’ll learn the routine soon enough.” Lila shook her head, trembling. “I want to leave.” Margaret tilted her head. “This is your home now.”
“No!” The word burst out before Lila could stop it. Margaret’s smile faded slightly. She crouched so they were eye level. “There are rules here,” she said calmly.
Behind her, the other girls sat at the table, silent and perfectly still.
“You will eat when food is brought.”
“You will sleep when lights are turned off.”
“You will keep the space clean.”
“And you will not scream.”
Lila glanced at the other girls, none of them spoke, none of them looked at her. “You will listen to the older girls,” Margaret continued. “They understand how things work.” She stood again.
“If you behave,” she said lightly, “things will be much easier.” Margaret turned toward the door, before leaving, she looked back once more. “Eat your dinner.”
The door shut, and the lock clicked again. Silence returned to the basement. For a long moment, no one moved, then Piper quietly slid a bowl toward Lila. “You should eat,” she said gently.
Lila stared at the door, then at the girls sitting around the table, and slowly, horribly, the truth began to settle in.
She wasn’t leaving.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
The first night, Lila barely slept.
The fluorescent lights hummed overhead until Margaret returned later and switched half of them off, leaving the basement in a dull, gray half-light. It wasn’t dark enough to hide in, but it wasn’t bright enough to feel safe either.
Every sound made her jump, the refrigerator motor clicking on, the pipes in the ceiling groaning. Someone turning over in their bed. She kept expecting the door to open again. By morning, her eyes burned from staying awake.
Samira was the first one up. She moved quietly, like she had practiced doing everything without making noise. She folded her blanket neatly and went to the kitchenette, filling a small kettle with water.
“We make tea in the mornings,” Samira said when she noticed Lila watching. Lila blinked at her. “Tea?”
“It’s one of the things she gives us.” Samira’s voice was careful when she talked about Margaret, like even the name had edges.
Soon the others stirred too.
Trinity rolled out of bed with a groan and shoved her hair out of her face, Piper stretched slowly, her long braid falling over her shoulder, Lila sat up, hugging the blanket around herself.
The basement looked different in the morning light, if it could even be called morning. The room was small but organized. The four beds lined one wall, each with folded blankets and a pillow that looked thin from years of use.
Across from them sat the table and chairs, in the far corner was the kitchenette, but what caught Lila’s attention were the shelves. Books, dozens of them. Some were children’s books with bright covers. Others were thicker novels that looked like they belonged in a school library.
Next to them sat a tiny television no bigger than a laptop, with a stack of DVDs leaned beside it. Lila slid out of bed and wandered closer. “Where did those come from?” she asked. “She brings them,” Piper said gently. Lila picked up one of the DVDs. It was scratched along the edges.
“We’ve seen that one about fifty times,” Trinity said, leaning back in her chair. “What is it?” Lila asked. Trinity smirked, “Some cartoon about a dog who solves mysteries. It’s not terrible.” Samira poured tea into mismatched mugs. “We rotate the movies,” she explained. “Otherwise people get tired of them.”
Lila noticed their clothes next, none of them matched. Samira wore an oversized sweater that hung off one shoulder. Trinity’s jeans were too short at the ankles. Piper’s shirt had clearly once belonged to an adult. “Where do you get those?” Lila asked.
“She brings them sometimes,” Piper said. “From thrift stores probably,” Trinity added. Lila tugged at the sleeve of the shirt she’d woken up in, it still smelled like the detergent from her latest foster home. “Do you ever leave?” she asked.
The room went quiet for a moment, then Trinity snorted softly. “No.” Samira set her mug down. “We’ve tried things,” she said carefully. Lila looked up immediately. “What things?” Trinity leaned forward. “The door’s reinforced with a keypad. If you guess the wrong code three times the power goes off down here till Margaret turns it back on…and she changes the code everyday.”
“Windows?” Lila asked. “There aren’t any,” Samira replied. Piper added quietly, “There’s a camera upstairs. We hear it click sometimes when she checks on us.” Lila stared at them. “But you could run when she opens the door.” Trinity gave a humorless laugh. “Yeah. Tried that.”
“What happened?” Lila asked, but Trinity didn’t answer. Samira spoke instead. “It didn’t work.” Piper rested a hand gently on Lila’s shoulder. “You’ll understand things soon,” she said softly.
The days settled into a strange rhythm.
Breakfast, reading, movies. Samira organized lessons like a tiny school. She made Lila practice reading from one of the books. Trinity complained but secretly helped with math problems. Piper told stories at night.
They had built small pieces of comfort out of what little they had, a folded blanket turned into a pillow fort, old magazines became decorations taped to the walls, someone had even drawn flowers on scraps of paper and taped them near the beds.
It wasn’t home, but it was something. By the end of the week, Lila stopped asking where the stairs led. She knew the answer.
On the seventh night, the door unlocked again. The sound froze the room instantly. Margaret stepped inside. “Good evening, girls.” They all stood automatically. Lila hesitated. Piper squeezed her hand. “Stand,” she whispered.
Margaret’s eyes scanned the room, then they landed on Lila. “You,” she said gently. Lila’s stomach dropped. “Come with me.” Lila didn’t move. Trinity leaned closer. “Just go,” she murmured.
“But—” Lila said, and Samira knelt in front of her. Her voice was calm but urgent. “Listen to me.” Lila’s breathing started to shake. “What happens?” she whispered. Samira didn’t answer the question directly. Instead she said softly, “Do what she says.”
Piper brushed Lila’s hair away from her face. “It will be over soon.” Trinity crossed her arms but her voice softened. “And when you come back, we’ll be right here.” Lila looked between them, fear twisted in her chest.
Margaret waited by the door. “Lila,” she said patiently. Slowly, Lila stepped forward. Piper squeezed her hand one last time before letting go. “Remember,” she whispered. “You’re not alone.”
Lila walked toward the door. Margaret placed a guiding hand on her shoulder. The door closed behind them, the lock clicked.
The three girls sat in silence, Samira quickly turned the TV on and turned the volume up as high as it would go, no one spoke, they just waited, because they always waited together. And when the screams stared, Piper covered Trinity’s ears. Samira hugged her legs to her chest, and buried her face into her knees, blocking out as much of the sound as she could.
Later that night, the lock clicked again. The sound echoed through the basement like it always did. Samira’s head lifted instantly, Trinity straightened in her chair, Piper stopped pacing. They all looked toward the door.
For a moment nothing happened, then the handle turned, the door opened slowly. Lila stepped inside.
Her eyes were red and swollen, her small hands clenched tightly in the sleeves of the oversized shirt she wore. The clothes she had on before were gone. She didn’t look up as she walked back into the room, just stood there near the door like she wasn’t sure what to do next.
Margaret walked out, holding Lila’s clothes and walked over to the big metal door, opening it and walking out of the room. Behind her, Margaret’s voice floated down the stairs. “Go to bed.”
The door shut, and the lock clicked again. Silence fell over the basement. For one long moment no one moved.
Then Piper crossed the room. She didn’t ask questions. She didn’t rush. She just wrapped her arms around Lila. The little girl collapsed into her instantly. The sobs came out of her in sharp, shaky breaths, like she’d been holding them in the entire time. “I want to leave,” she cried.
Piper held her tighter. “I know,” she whispered softly. Samira pulled one of the blankets from the bed and wrapped it around Lila’s shoulders. Trinity hovered nearby for a second before awkwardly kneeling beside them. “It’s okay,” Trinity muttered, though her voice carried a quiet anger under the words.
Lila clung to Piper’s shirt. “Why did she do that?” None of the girls answered. Samira brushed Lila’s hair back from her face. “You didn’t do anything wrong,” she said quietly. Lila shook her head, crying harder. “I don’t want to go back in there.”
“You won’t tonight,” Piper said gently. She guided Lila toward the bed. “Just rest.” The girls stayed close as Lila curled under the blanket. Piper sat beside her. Samira turned the lights down slightly. Trinity pulled the small chair closer to the bed and sat with her arms crossed, watching the door like it might open again.
Eventually Lila’s crying softened into exhausted breathing. Piper kept a hand resting lightly on her back until she fell asleep. No one spoke for a long time.
The next afternoon, the door unlocked again. The sound made Lila freeze mid-step. Margaret stepped into the basement carrying a small plastic bag. “Good afternoon, girls.” Samira stood immediately, Trinity followed, Piper rose more slowly. Lila stayed where she was.
Margaret set the bag on the counter and looked around the room. Her eyes settled on Piper. “You.” Piper’s shoulders tensed slightly. “Come with me.” She stepped forward without arguing. Lila suddenly darted across the room. “No!”
Everyone froze, and Margaret blinked. Lila grabbed Piper’s arm with both hands. “You can’t take her!” Lila cried out. “Lila—” Samira started, but Lila shook her head violently. “Leave her alone!”
The room went very quiet, and Margaret’s expression changed. Slowly, she walked toward them. “Step aside.”
“No!” Lila cried. The slap came fast. A sharp crack echoed through the basement. Lila staggered sideways, her hand flying to her cheek as the sting exploded across her face. For a moment she looked too shocked to even cry.
Margaret’s voice turned cold. “You will not interfere.”
Samira and Trinity rushed forward immediately. Samira grabbed Lila’s shoulders while Trinity pulled her back against her chest. “Stop,” Samira whispered urgently. Lila struggled in their grip. “Let go!”
Margaret watched her calmly. “Because you couldn’t follow the rules,” she said quietly, “Piper will stay longer today.”
Lila froze, and her breathing hitched. Margaret turned to Piper. “Come.” Piper hesitated only long enough to look back at the girls. “It’s okay,” she said softly. Then she followed Margaret toward the second door at the far side of the basement.
The door opened, they disappeared inside, then the lock clicked. Lila started crying immediately. “I’m sorry,” she sobbed. “I’m sorry.” Trinity held her tightly. “Hey,” she said gently. “It’s not your fault.”
“Yes it is!” Lila cried. Samira knelt in front of her. “Listen to me.” Lila shook her head. “I made it worse.” Samira’s voice stayed calm but firm. “No. Margaret chooses what she does.” Trinity wiped at Lila’s tears with the sleeve of her sweatshirt. “She says stuff like that to scare us,” she muttered.
Lila leaned against Trinity, shaking. “I didn’t want her to take Piper.” She sniffled. “I know, none of us do.” Trinity said quietly. They sat there together on the floor.
Time moved slowly, the lights hummed, Once they could start to hear Piper struggle Samira walked over to the television and turned it on.
Eventually the second door opened again, and Piper stepped back into the room. She looked tired, her braid had come loose, strands of hair falling across her face, but she was standing. The moment she appeared, the girls moved.
Samira reached her first, wrapping an arm around her shoulders, Trinity guided her toward the bed, Lila hovered nearby for a second before rushing forward. “I’m sorry,” she blurted. Piper blinked down at her. “For what?”
“I made it worse.” Lila whispered, guilt taking her voice. Piper crouched carefully in front of her. “You didn’t make anything worse.” She pulled Lila into a hug. “You were trying to help.”
Samira handed Piper a cup of water. Trinity sat beside them, her expression tight but protective. The four of them stayed close together on the bed, no one said much, they didn’t need to.
Sometimes the only thing they could give each other was presence, and in the quiet basement, that had to be enough to get through another day.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
The days began to blur together after a while. At first, Lila tried to count them.
She scratched tiny lines with a pencil on the inside corner of the bookshelf when no one was looking. One for each day she woke up in the basement instead of the foster house she barely remembered.
But after a few weeks the lines started to feel meaningless. The lights overhead never changed, the door opened at the same times, and the air always smelled faintly like detergent and dust.
Time didn’t move normally down there. It just… settled. Still, the girls made their own rhythm.
Samira was always the one who started the mornings. She woke before the others, carefully folding her blanket and tidying the small kitchenette like it was a real kitchen in a real house. When the others stirred, she would already have tea ready in the mismatched mugs Margaret had brought down over the years.
“Morning meeting,” Samira would announce most days. Trinity groaned every single time. “We are not a company,” she muttered once, dragging herself to the table. Samira ignored the comment. “We need structure,” she insisted.
And somehow the structure worked. Samira turned the mornings into school. She taught Lila reading using the children’s books on the shelf, sounding out words patiently while Lila traced letters with her finger.
“Try again,” Samira would say calmly. Lila squinted at the page. “Ad…ven…ture?” Samira nodded approvingly. “Adventure.” Trinity pretended she hated the lessons. She slouched in her chair, tossed pencils, and made sarcastic remarks about homework.
But she still did the math problems, and when Lila struggled with numbers, Trinity was the one who leaned over and whispered shortcuts. “You don’t need to count all of them,” she murmured once. “Just group them.”
Lila stared at the page. “Oh.” Trinity shrugged. “Yeah. I know things.”
Piper watched these exchanges quietly most of the time. She spent a lot of afternoons reading or sitting cross-legged on the floor with a notebook Margaret had once brought down.
She wrote in it often, stories, lists, little reminders. Sometimes she helped Lila braid her hair, patiently untangling knots and weaving the strands together until Lila sat proudly with the neat braid hanging down her back.
“You look older now,” Piper told her once. Lila beamed.
Evenings were quieter.
The girls gathered around the small television, choosing from the limited stack of DVDs. The mystery dog movie still played the most. Trinity could quote entire scenes. “You’ve watched this too many times,” Samira said one night.
“Impossible,” Trinity replied. Lila curled against Piper’s side on the couch while they watched. At some point, without anyone saying it out loud, they began saving a seat for her automatically.
The basement itself slowly changed too, not physically. Margaret still controlled everything that came in, but the girls had found ways to make it feel less like a cage the years they were here.
Drawings covered the walls, flowers, animals, stars. Samira organized the books into neat rows like a tiny library. Trinity fixed the wobbly table leg by stuffing folded paper underneath it. Piper turned one corner of the room into what she called the “quiet spot,” piling extra blankets there so anyone could sit and think when they needed space.
It wasn’t freedom, but it was something that belonged to them. Lila started laughing again after a few months. The first time it happened, all three older girls stopped talking. Trinity blinked at her. “What was that?”
Lila covered her mouth. “Nothing.”, but Piper smiled softly. “No,” she said. “That was good.” Samira pretended she hadn’t noticed the moment, but the next morning she brought out a coloring book she had been saving.
“New assignment,” she announced. Lila took the crayons eagerly. Little changes began appearing in Lila too. She stopped flinching at every sound, she stopped asking about the stairs, and slowly, painfully, she stopped waiting by the door.
Her world shrank to the basement, but inside that world, the girls grew closer. Trinity became the one who protected her. When Lila had nightmares, it was Trinity who climbed down from her bed and sat beside her until she fell asleep again.
“Bad dream?” Trinity muttered once. Lila nodded. “Yeah.” Trinity sighed and leaned against the bedframe. “Dream about punching Margaret next time,” she suggested. Lila giggled weakly.
Samira handled the rules. She kept track of what Margaret expected and quietly reminded the others when something might cause trouble. “Don’t leave dishes out,” she would whisper. “Lights off means lights off.”
It wasn’t obedience, it was survival.
Piper remained the center of everything. When arguments broke out, which they did sometimes, Piper was the one who calmed them down. When Trinity got angry and snapped at Samira, Piper stepped between them. When Lila got overwhelmed, Piper was the one she ran to.
And when the basement felt too small, Piper told stories, stories about rain, about school buses, about parks and libraries and grocery stores. Places the younger girls barely remembered anymore.
One night Lila asked a question that made the room quiet. “Do you think someone’s looking for us?” Samira hesitated, Trinity stared at the floor, Piper took a long moment before answering. “I hope so,” she said.
Lila nodded slowly. Then she leaned against Piper’s shoulder. “Even if they’re not,” she whispered, “we found each other.” Trinity pretended not to react to that, but she quietly passed Lila the blanket anyway.
Life continued like that. Days folding into weeks, and weeks folding into months. The basement became a strange little world of routines and quiet resilience.
And somewhere along the way, the four girls stopped feeling like strangers, they became sisters, not by blood, but by survival.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Six months after Lila arrived, the basement felt different, not safe… familiar.
The hum of the lights had become background noise. The refrigerator clicking on in the middle of the night no longer made Lila jump. Even the heavy metal door at the bottom of the stairs had stopped feeling like a surprise. It was simply part of the world now, like the gray walls, the small television, the shelves of worn books.
But the nightmares still came, and tonight’s had started the same way most of them did.
Running.
Hands grabbing.
The van door slamming shut.
Lila had woken up gasping, her blanket tangled around her legs. She hadn’t cried this time. Instead, she slipped quietly out of bed and padded across the basement to the quiet corner, since Piper was already there.
She sat cross-legged on the pile of blankets, the small notebook balanced on her knee. A pen moved steadily across the page under the soft yellow glow of the reading lamp they’d convinced Margaret to bring down months ago.
Piper glanced up as Lila approached. “Nightmare?” she asked softly. Lila nodded. Piper shifted the blankets, making space beside her. Lila climbed into the corner and curled against Piper’s side, tucking her head under Piper’s arm like she had done dozens of times before.
Piper’s sweater smelled faintly like laundry soap, safe. For a few minutes, neither of them spoke. The pen continued moving across the paper.
Scratch.
Scratch.
Scratch.
Lila watched the page curiously. She had seen Piper writing in those notebooks for months now. Sometimes late at night like this, sometimes in the afternoons when the others were reading or watching movies. There were several of them stacked neatly beside Piper. All filled.
“What are you writing?” Lila asked quietly. Piper didn’t answer right away. She finished the sentence she was working on, closed the notebook gently, and rested the pen between the pages. “You’ve asked me that before,” she said.
Lila nodded. “Lots of times.” Piper smiled faintly. “That’s true.” Lila traced the edge of the notebook with her finger. “Is it stories?” Lila asked. “Not exactly.” Piper leaned back against the wall, thinking for a moment.
“It’s a journal,” she said finally. Lila frowned. “Like a diary?” Lila asked. “Sort of.” Piper picked up the notebook again and flipped through a few pages. The writing inside was small and careful, filling every line. “I write down everything that happens here,” she explained. Lila blinked. “Everything?”
“Everything I can remember.” Piper said. Lila tilted her head. “Why?” Piper’s expression changed slightly. She looked down at the pages for a long moment before answering. “In case someone finds us one day.”
The words settled quietly in the room. Lila sat up a little straighter. “Finds us?” Piper nodded. “Police. Social workers. Anyone.” Her voice was calm, but there was something steady underneath it. “If that ever happens, I want them to know exactly what Margaret did.”
Lila stared at the notebook again, and Piper flipped to another page. “These are dates,” she said, pointing to a column of numbers. “Dates?” Lila asked. “I keep track of the days as best as I can.” Lila’s eyes widened. “You know what day it is?”
“Most of the time.” Piper tapped another section of the page. “And here I write down what she does. What she says. When she brings food. When she takes someone into the other room.”
Lila’s stomach twisted slightly, and Piper’s finger moved to another paragraph. “I write down how we’re feeling too. When someone gets sick. When someone gets hurt.” Lila was very quiet. “You remember all that?”
“I try to.” Piper closed the notebook again. “Margaret thinks no one will ever know what happened here.” Her voice was soft, but firm. “She’s wrong.” Lila looked up at her. “What if nobody comes?”
The question hung in the air.
Piper didn’t answer immediately. Instead, she wrapped an arm around Lila’s shoulders again and pulled her a little closer. “Then at least the truth still exists,” she said gently. Lila rested her head against Piper’s shoulder. “Like proof?” Lila asked. “Exactly.”
Piper reached over and stacked the notebook carefully with the others. “They’re our story,” she said. Lila’s eyelids were already starting to droop again. “Do you write about me?” she asked sleepily. Piper smiled. “Of course I do.”
“What did you write?” Lila asked, Piper thought for a second. Then she said quietly, “That you’re brave.” Lila shook her head weakly. “I’m not brave.” Piper brushed a hand through her hair. “You came here and kept going,” she said. “That’s brave enough.”
Lila yawned, the tension slowly leaving her small body as exhaustion crept back in. The quiet corner felt warm under the blankets, and her breathing slowed. Piper reached over and switched off the reading lamp. The basement returned to its dim nighttime glow.
Within minutes, Lila was asleep again, curled against Piper with one small hand gripping the sleeve of her sweater. Piper stayed awake a little longer. She picked the notebook back up, flipped it open, and wrote one more line beneath the last entry.
Then she closed it gently, and sat there quietly, keeping watch while the others slept.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
About a year after Lila arrived, the basement had learned the language of bad nights. They didn’t talk about it openly, but everyone knew the signs.
The heavy silence after the door closed, the way the lights suddenly felt too bright, the way someone rushed to turn on the television.
That night, the signs were worse than usual, the second door had stayed closed for a long time. Lila had been sitting on the floor with one of the mystery dog DVDs paused on the screen. Piper sat nearby with a book open in her lap, though she hadn’t turned a page in nearly twenty minutes.
Samira paced. She didn’t do that often.
Back and forth.
Back and forth.
Every few steps she glanced toward the locked door. Trinity had been gone for almost an hour. The lock finally clicked. All three girls froze. The door opened slowly.
Trinity stepped out, but she didn’t look at them. She just walked straight across the basement toward her bed. Her steps were stiff. Something about the way she held her arm made Samira move immediately. “Trinity.” No answer.
Samira followed her to the bed. “Let me see.” She said, “I’m fine.” Trinity’s voice was sharp, clipped. She tried to pull her arm away, but Samira caught her wrist gently. “Stop.” Samira’s tone wasn’t loud, but it carried the quiet authority she used during lessons.
Trinity glared at her. “I said I’m fine.” Samira didn’t let go. “Sit down.” Trinity’s jaw clenched. For a moment it looked like she might argue, then she dropped heavily onto the bed. Samira knelt in front of her and carefully rolled up the sleeve of Trinity’s shirt.
Lila’s stomach twisted when she saw the bruising already forming along Trinity’s forearm. It wasn’t the first time someone had come back hurt, but it never got easier to see. Samira stood and went to the kitchenette. Their “medical supplies” were a small plastic box Margaret had once brought down months ago.
It held, bandages, a nearly empty bottle of antiseptic, some gauze, and not much else. Samira soaked a cloth with warm water. “This is going to sting,” she warned. Trinity snorted. “Wow. Thanks for the heads up.” But when the cloth touched her skin, she sucked in a sharp breath anyway.
“Hold still.”
“I am holding still.”
Samira carefully cleaned the scrape along Trinity’s arm. Lila hovered nearby, unsure if she should help. Piper watched from the edge of the bed. The tension in the room slowly tightened, and Trinity’s patience was already gone. “You’re doing it wrong,” she snapped suddenly.
Samira blinked. “I’m cleaning it.”
“You’re pressing too hard.”
“I’m not.”
“Yes you are.”
Samira paused, clearly trying to stay calm. “Trinity—”
“You always think you know everything!” Trinity burst out. The words hit the room like a dropped plate. Samira’s hands froze. “What does that mean?” she asked quietly. Trinity jerked her arm away. “It means you’re bossy!”
“I’m trying to help you.”
“No, you’re trying to control everything!”
Samira’s calm expression cracked slightly. “I’m keeping us safe.”
“You’re keeping us miserable!”
The argument was escalating quickly now. Lila’s chest tightened. Trinity stood up abruptly, pacing across the floor. “I don’t need a lecture every time something happens!” Samira stood too. “I’m not lecturing you!”
“Yes you are!”
Piper moved before the argument could explode any further. “Hey.” Her voice cut through the tension. Both girls looked at her. “Take a breath,” Piper said calmly. Trinity crossed her arms. “I am breathing.”
Piper raised an eyebrow slightly. “Are you?” For a moment, no one spoke. Trinity’s anger was still simmering, but Piper’s presence had slowed the spiral. Samira rubbed her temples. “I just wanted to help,” she said quietly.
“I know,” Piper replied. She turned to Trinity. “And you’re hurting.” Trinity looked away. “I’m fine.” Piper didn’t push. She simply gestured back toward the bed. “Sit down.”
Trinity hesitated, then, reluctantly, she sat again. Samira carefully finished wrapping the bandage around Trinity’s arm. The silence returned. Lila had been watching the whole time. Her small hands twisted nervously in the hem of her shirt.
Finally, she spoke. “Trinity?” Trinity looked up. “What?” Lila stepped closer. Her voice was soft, but steady. “You don’t have to be strong all the time.” Trinity blinked. “What?” Lila shrugged a little. “You can be mad,” she said. “But Samira’s still helping you.”
Trinity stared at her. “You’re like… the toughest person I know,” Lila added quietly. The words landed unexpectedly. Trinity looked down at her bandaged arm. Then she sighed. “Yeah, well.” She rubbed the back of her neck awkwardly. “Sorry.”
Samira blinked. “What?” Trinity rolled her eyes slightly. “I said sorry.” Samira’s shoulders relaxed. “Thank you.” The tension in the room finally loosened.
A few minutes later Trinity climbed into bed, and Samira sat beside her. “Do you want the lights dimmed?” Samira asked. Trinity shrugged. “Whatever.” But when Samira reached over and switched off one of the lamps, Trinity leaned slightly toward her.
Samira didn’t comment. She just stayed there, her arm loosely around Trinity’s shoulders. Within minutes Trinity’s breathing began to slow. Eventually she fell asleep with her head resting against Samira’s shoulder.
Across the room, Piper sat in the quiet corner. Lila joined her a moment later. They watched the others quietly. After a while Piper nudged Lila gently. “You handled that well.” Lila looked surprised. “I did?” Piper nodded. “You helped them calm down.”
Lila glanced across the room, where Trinity and Samira were both asleep now. “I didn’t do anything.” Lila said, shrugging her shoulders. “You did,” Piper said softly. She smiled at her. “You reminded them they’re on the same team.”
Lila leaned back against the wall. The basement was quiet again, and the tension had faded. In the quiet corner, Piper squeezed Lila’s shoulder gently. “You’re really part of this family now,” she said.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
A year and a half after Lila arrived, the basement had settled into its familiar evening quiet. The lights hummed softly overhead. The small television sat dark for once, and the stack of DVDs remained untouched on the shelf.
Samira and Trinity sat on the couch together, a book spread between them. It was one of the longer novels from their shelf, the cover faded from years of rereading. Samira had insisted they read it again because she said it helped keep their minds sharp.
Trinity pretended she didn’t care, but she had turned every page. Samira read aloud quietly. “…and when Mary stepped into the garden, she felt the wind move through the roses…” She stopped mid-sentence.
Trinity leaned forward slightly. “What do roses actually smell like?” she asked suddenly. Samira blinked. “What?” Trinity shrugged. “I mean really. Not the fake soap kind.” Samira thought for a moment. “I think they’re… sweet.”
“That’s not helpful.”
“Well, what do you remember?”
Trinity leaned back against the couch, staring at the ceiling. “I remember grass.” Samira smiled faintly. “Grass?”
“Yeah.”
“What about it?”
Trinity scrunched her nose. “It smells… green.” Samira laughed quietly. “That’s not a real description.”
“It is in my head.”
Samira leaned her chin on her hand, thinking. “I remember wind.” Trinity glanced at her. “Wind?” Samira nodded, “The kind that moves your hair.” Trinity snorted. “All wind moves your hair.” She said with a smirk, “No, I mean the kind that comes across a field,” Samira said, gesturing vaguely. “The kind that makes the whole place feel big.” Trinity was quiet for a moment. “I remember that,” she said softly.
Across the room, Lila had been sitting on the floor with a coloring book, her crayon stopped moving, she looked up slowly. “What does grass smell like?” she asked, both girls turned toward her. Trinity shrugged again. “Like… outside.”
Lila’s brow furrowed. “I don’t remember.” The words came out smaller than she meant them to. Samira’s smile faded slightly. “You do,” she said gently. “You just have to think.” Lila stared at the crayon in her hand. “I used to know.” Her voice wobbled. “I think I’m forgetting.”
The room went quiet, making Trinity look uncomfortable. “That happens,” she muttered. Lila’s eyes filled with tears. “I don’t want to forget.” Before the silence could get heavier, Piper closed the book she had been reading in the quiet corner. “Well,” she said casually, standing up, “I think we should fix that.”
Three pairs of eyes turned toward her. “Fix what?” Trinity asked. Piper smiled. “We’re going outside.” Trinity blinked. “Piper.” Piper clapped her hands once. “Adventure time.” Samira tilted her head. “What are you doing?”
Piper walked to the shelf and pulled out a familiar book. ‘The Secret Garden.’ She held it up. “Field trip,” she announced. Trinity groaned. “Oh no.” Piper pointed to the couch. “That’s the garden gate.” Trinity crossed her arms. “That’s a couch.”
“Use your imagination.”
Samira raised an eyebrow. “You’re serious.” Piper nodded with a grin, “Very.” Then Piper turned to Lila. “Miss Mary Lennox,” she said with a small bow. Lila blinked. “Me?” Piper grinned, “Of course.” Lila’s sad expression softened slightly.
“And you,” Piper said, pointing to Samira, “are the gardener.” Samira snorted quietly. “That seems like a stretch.” She whispered, “And Trinity,” Piper continued. “What am I?” She asked, “The grumpy robin.” Trinity stared at her. “The what?”
“The robin that leads Mary to the garden.” Trinity rolled her eyes dramatically. “Absolutely not.” Piper crossed her arms. “You said you remembered grass.” Piper said. “That doesn’t mean I’m a bird.” Piper walked over to Trinity, voice lowering,“Just pretend for five minutes.”
Trinity glanced at Lila, the little girl looked hopeful again. Trinity sighed. “Fine.” Piper grinned. “Excellent.” She pointed to the couch. “Mary must find the secret gate.” Lila slowly stood. “Like this?”
She tiptoed across the floor, peeking dramatically behind the couch. “Oh look!” Piper announced. “The gate!” Samira covered her mouth to hide a laugh. Trinity leaned against the wall. “This is ridiculous.”
“Robin,” Piper said firmly. Trinity groaned. Then she hopped once across the floor. “Chirp.” Samira lost it. She burst into laughter. “Did you just chirp?” Trinity pointed at Piper. “This is her fault.”
Piper clapped. “Perfect robin behavior.” Lila giggled. “Robin Trinity!” She said with a smile. “Do not call me that.”, but she chirped again anyway. Piper grabbed one of the blankets from the couch and spread it across the floor. “The grass.”
Lila stepped onto it carefully. “Oh,” she whispered. “What does it smell like?” Piper asked. Lila closed her eyes. “Fresh.” Samira nodded slowly. “Yes.” Trinity crouched beside them. “Green,” she added.
They wandered the imaginary garden together. Piper described tall hedges, Samira pretended to water flowers with an invisible watering can, Trinity dramatically chased away imaginary weeds, Lila spun in circles, arms outstretched. “The wind!” she said.
Piper waved a blanket like a breeze, Lila laughed, real laughter. For a while the basement disappeared. There were roses.
And birds.
And grass under their feet.
Eventually the game slowed. The girls collapsed onto the couch, breathless and smiling. Trinity wiped sweat from her forehead. “I hate to admit it,” she said. “But that was kind of fun.” Samira nodded. “Agreed.” Lila curled between them. “I remembered the wind,” she said sleepily.
Piper smiled from the quiet corner. “See?” Lila looked at her. “We didn’t forget.” Piper shook her head gently. “No,” she said. “You just needed to visit the garden again.”
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
By the time they reached a year and eight months together in the basement, the routines of survival had become second nature.
They woke, they studied, they read books and watched the same DVDs, they waited. Waiting had become its own kind of skill, but illness was something none of them knew how to handle.
It started quietly.
Piper woke one morning later than usual. That alone was strange. Piper was almost always the first or second awake, sitting in the quiet corner with one of her notebooks before the younger girls even stirred.
That morning she was still curled under her blanket. Samira noticed immediately. “Piper?” she asked softly. Piper opened her eyes slowly. “Morning,” she said, though her voice sounded rough. Samira frowned. “You didn’t get up.”
“I’m just tired.” But when Piper sat up, she swayed slightly. Trinity noticed that. “You look terrible,” she said bluntly. Piper gave a weak smile. “Thanks.”
By afternoon the fever had started.
Piper lay on her bed with a blanket pulled to her chin while Samira sat beside her with a damp cloth. The small plastic medical kit sat open on the table nearby. It didn’t contain anything useful. Samira dipped the cloth in water again and placed it carefully on Piper’s forehead. “You’re burning up.”
Piper gave a quiet laugh that turned into a cough. “I noticed.” Lila hovered nearby, worried. “Will she be okay?” Samira didn’t answer right away. “Yes,” she said eventually, but her voice carried a tension the others recognized.
That evening the door unlocked.
Margaret stepped into the basement. Her eyes scanned the room before settling on Piper. “Well,” she said mildly. “What happened here?” She asked, “She’s sick,” Samira replied immediately. Margaret stepped closer to the bed. Piper tried to sit up straighter.
Margaret studied her face for a moment. “Fever,” Samira added. Margaret hummed thoughtfully. Then she reached into the bag she carried and pulled out a small bottle of pills. She tossed it onto the table. “Give her that.”
Samira picked up the bottle, but her brow furrowed. “These are adult tablets.” Margaret shrugged. “She’ll be fine.” Samira turned the bottle in her hands. “It says two tablets for adults,” she said carefully. “Yes.” Margaret said, “But she’s thirteen…ish, I think…” Samira replied. Margaret was already turning toward the door.
“How much should I give her?” Samira asked quickly. Margaret paused, then she looked back over her shoulder. “You’re the smart one,” she said lightly. “Figure it out.” And then she left.
The door locked behind her, and for the next several days, she didn’t return. Those days blurred together into a slow, frightening stretch of time.
Piper’s fever climbed higher, she shivered under layers of blankets even when the room felt warm, Samira barely slept. She sat beside Piper constantly, measuring the medicine carefully by breaking tablets in half and watching Piper’s breathing.
Trinity filled cups of water from the sink. Lila sat nearby, holding Piper’s hand. “Drink,” Trinity urged. Piper forced down small sips, but it wasn’t enough. By the second night Piper could barely sit up. Her skin was pale and damp with sweat.
Samira pressed the cloth to her forehead again. “We need her to drink more,” she said quietly. “She’s trying,” Trinity muttered. Lila looked at the cup in her own hands, then she pushed it toward Piper. “Take mine.”
“You need it too,” Samira said. “I’m not thirsty.” That wasn’t true, but Lila didn’t argue. Trinity followed a moment later. “Here.” She shoved her own cup toward the bed.
Samira hesitated. “You both need water.”
“We’ll be fine,” Trinity said. Samira finally nodded. “Okay.” Samira said, voice weak. Piper drank what she could. Still, the fever didn’t break, by the third day, the girls were scared. Piper’s breathing had grown shallow. She barely woke when they spoke to her.
Lila sat beside the bed with tears running silently down her face. “Please wake up,” she whispered. Samira squeezed Piper’s hand. “You’re not allowed to leave us,” she said quietly. Trinity paced the room. “Margaret needs to come back.” But she didn’t.
Not until the fourth morning. The door finally unlocked. Margaret stepped inside as if nothing had happened. Samira stood immediately. “She’s been sick for days,” she said. Margaret walked to the bed and looked down at Piper. Piper’s eyes were barely open.
Margaret watched her for a moment, then she placed a hand lightly against Piper’s forehead. “Hmm.” Samira held the medicine bottle tightly. “She’s not getting better.” Margaret tilted her head. “She will.”
Samira frowned. “What if she doesn’t?” Margaret didn’t answer the question. Instead she stepped back. “You’ve kept her alive this long.” Samira stared at her. Margaret’s lips curved slightly. “You’re very capable.”, then she left again.
But sometime later that evening, Piper’s fever finally began to drop. The change came slowly, her breathing deepened, her skin cooled. When she finally woke properly the next morning, Lila burst into tears.
“You scared us.” She said through tears. Piper blinked at her weakly. “Sorry.” Samira leaned back in relief. Trinity muttered something about never doing that again.
Piper recovered slowly over the next week. The fever never returned, but she was different afterward. She tired more easily. Sometimes she had to sit down after walking across the room.
Her cough lingered, even Margaret noticed. One evening she stood watching Piper write in her notebook. “You’re weaker now,” Margaret said casually. Piper didn’t look up.
Margaret smiled faintly. “But you survived.” There was something strange in her voice, almost pleased. As if Piper’s survival had been an experiment she enjoyed watching unfold.
She rested a hand briefly on Piper’s shoulder. “My resilient girl.” Then she walked upstairs again, leaving the girls alone in the basement. Piper kept writing. Her pen moved slowly across the page.
Across the room, Samira watched her carefully. Trinity handed Lila a cup of water, and though Piper had recovered, all of them knew something had changed. The illness had taken something from her. Something that wouldn’t come back.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
By the time nearly two years had passed, Lila had learned something complicated about Margaret Vale. She was the one who locked the door, she was the one who hurt them.
But she was also the one who brought food, medicine, blankets, books, and the little television that played their scratched DVDs over and over again. In the strange, twisted world of the basement, Margaret was both their captor and their provider.
And the girls had learned how she liked things to be. They stood when she entered, they kept the room clean, they said thank you when she brought things. Not because they believed she deserved it, but because survival meant understanding the rules.
One afternoon, Margaret came down with a grocery bag. The door opened and all four girls looked up immediately. Samira stood first. “Good afternoon,” she said politely. Piper followed, slower than the others but steady. Lila slid off the couch. Trinity stood last, leaning against the table with her arms crossed.
Margaret’s eyes swept across the room. “Good,” she said. She set the bag on the table and began pulling items out. A loaf of bread, a jar of peanut butter, two cans of soup. Lila watched carefully. Margaret always noticed when they seemed grateful.
“Thank you,” Samira said. Margaret gave a small nod of approval. “I take care of you girls,” she said. Trinity muttered under her breath. “Yeah. Sure.” Margaret’s head snapped toward her. “What was that?” Trinity froze. Samira shot her a warning look.
“Nothing,” Trinity said quickly. Margaret stepped closer. “I heard you.” The room felt suddenly smaller. Trinity’s jaw tightened. “You said you take care of us,” she said, trying to sound casual. “Yes.” Trinity gestured vaguely around the basement. “You mean like locking us down here?”
Samira’s stomach dropped, Piper’s eyes widened slightly, Lila grabbed the edge of the couch, and Margaret stared at Trinity. For a long moment, no one spoke, then Margaret smiled, but it wasn’t a kind smile.
“Oh,” she said softly. “I see.”
She walked to the wall, before anyone could react, she reached up and typed three wrong codes into the keypad, and the lights went out instantly. The television went dark, the refrigerator stopped humming, the basement fell into thick, suffocating silence.
Margaret’s voice floated through the darkness. “I give you light.” Her footsteps moved toward the door. “I give you heat.” The door opened. “I give you entertainment.” Samira’s voice shook slightly. “Margaret—”
Margaret paused at the top of the stairs. “And I can take it all away.” The door shut, the lock clicked, and darkness swallowed the room. For a while, none of them spoke. Without the ventilation system running, the basement grew still and heavy. Lila eventually whispered, “Trinity?”
“I know,” Trinity muttered. Samira found the flashlight they kept for emergencies. A weak beam cut through the darkness. They gathered near the air vent on the wall. It was the only place that still felt like it connected to the outside world.
Piper leaned against the wall carefully, her breathing slower than usual. The illness months earlier had left her weaker. Samira noticed immediately. “Sit,” she said gently. Piper slid down beside the vent. The air drifting through it was faint, but it was cooler than the rest of the room.
Lila curled up beside her. Trinity sat on the other side. “I’m sorry,” Trinity said quietly. No one answered right away. Samira finally sighed. “You can’t say things like that to her.”
“I know.”
“She likes control.”
“I know.”
Trinity leaned her head back against the wall. “I just hate when she talks like she’s doing us a favor.” Samira rubbed her eyes. “We know she isn’t.”
“Still.”
Lila rested her head on Piper’s shoulder. “It’s getting cold.” She said. “I know,” Piper said softly. They stayed like that through the long hours. Without the lights, time felt strange again.
They slept in short bursts, they shared the little water they had left. Piper coughed more than usual. Each time, Samira checked her breathing carefully.
The first night passed slowly.
The second day felt longer.
The air grew thicker in the basement. Lila spent most of the time curled against Piper, trying to keep her warm while Samira and Trinity fanned the air near the vent with books. “Still breathing okay?” Trinity asked quietly.
Piper nodded weakly. “I’m fine.”
“You’re not fine.”
“I’ve been worse.”
That didn’t make Trinity feel better. They stayed by the vent again that night. Four small shapes huddled together in the dark, and the basement felt endless.
Then, sometime during the third morning…The lights flickered, the refrigerator hummed back to life, the ventilation system kicked on with a rush of air.
Lila sat up instantly. “It’s back!” Samira let out a breath she hadn’t realized she’d been holding. Trinity leaned her head against the wall with relief. Piper closed her eyes briefly as the air moved through the room.
The door upstairs unlocked a few minutes later. Margaret stepped down the stairs like nothing had happened. “Well,” she said pleasantly. “Looks like everyone survived.” The girls didn’t answer.
Margaret smiled faintly. “Remember something, Trinity.” Her voice stayed calm. “I provide everything you have.” She gestured around the basement. “And that means I decide when you get it.” Then she set a bag of groceries on the table. “Lunch time.”
The girls slowly stood. They moved automatically now. Samira unpacked the food, Trinity grabbed the bowls, Lila helped Piper to the chair, and Margaret watched them with quiet satisfaction. Just the way she liked them.
Obedient.
Grateful.
Dependent.
And for now, the lights stayed on.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Snow had started falling somewhere above them. They couldn’t see it, of course. The basement had no windows, no sky, no way to watch the seasons change. But the girls knew winter had arrived by the way the concrete floor held the cold and how the air drifting through the vent had turned sharp and dry.
A few weeks before the worst of the cold set in, Margaret had come down the stairs carrying more supplies than usual. Two grocery bags instead of one. The girls noticed immediately.
Samira stood like she always did when Margaret entered. Trinity and Lila followed, while Piper stayed seated, writing slowly in one of her notebooks.
Margaret began unloading the bags onto the table. Cans of soup, crackers, extra bottled water, even a few blankets. “I’ll be away for a while,” Margaret said casually. Samira’s head lifted. “How long?”
Margaret shrugged. “A week. Maybe longer.” The girls exchanged a glance. Margaret noticed. “You’ll manage,” she said lightly. “You always do.” Then she turned toward the stairs. “Oh,” she added, pausing halfway up. “Try not to break anything while I’m gone.”
The door shut, the lock clicked, and Margaret disappeared for longer than she ever had before.
At first, things continued normally. Samira carefully rationed the food, Trinity stacked the extra blankets near the beds, Lila tried to treat it like a strange camping trip, but the cold kept getting worse.
Without Margaret coming down regularly, the basement heater never got adjusted. The concrete walls held the winter like ice. They wore every layer of clothing they had. Still, the cold seeped in.
Piper began coughing again.
Samira noticed it first. “You’re getting sick again,” she said quietly one evening. Piper shook her head. “Just the cold.”, but the cough grew deeper.
Within a few days the fever returned. This time it came faster, and stronger. Samira tried everything she could think of. She wrapped Piper in blankets. She boiled water to make steam in the kitchenette. She gave her the last of the medicine Margaret had left months ago.
Trinity kept bringing cups of water. “Drink,” she insisted. Lila sat beside Piper almost constantly, holding her hand. “You’re going to get better,” she whispered. Piper smiled weakly. “Of course I am.”
By the fourth day, the fever had climbed too high.
Piper’s breathing had grown shallow and uneven, each inhale coming with a faint rasp that made Samira’s chest tighten every time she heard it. Samira sat beside the bed, her back aching from leaning forward for so long. A damp cloth rested in her hand, though it had already warmed again against Piper’s skin.
“I don’t know what else to do,” she whispered. Trinity stood across the room, staring at the locked door like she could force it open if she tried hard enough. “She has to come back,” Trinity muttered.
Lila sat beside the bed, both of her small hands wrapped around Piper’s. “Please wake up,” she whispered. For a moment nothing happened, then Piper stirred. Her eyes fluttered open slowly, unfocused at first. She blinked once, twice, as if trying to remember where she was.
Then she saw them, all three girls sitting there. “Hey,” she whispered. Samira leaned forward immediately. “Hey. Stay with us. Don’t fall asleep again.” Piper gave a faint breath that might have been a laugh before it turned into a weak cough. “Bossy as always.”
Trinity tried to smile. “You started it.” Lila’s tears were already running down her cheeks. “You have to get better,” she said. Piper looked at her gently. “I’m tired, kid.” Samira shook her head quickly. “No. No, you’re not allowed to be tired.”
Piper reached out weakly and squeezed her hand. “You did everything right,” she said softly. Samira’s voice cracked. “Stop talking like that.” Across the room Trinity rubbed at her eyes, frustrated. “You promised we’d get out,” she muttered. Piper turned her head slightly toward her. “I know.”
Lila climbed carefully onto the edge of the bed. Piper managed to lift her arm enough to wrap it loosely around her shoulders. “Remember the garden?” Piper whispered. Lila nodded through her tears. “The wind,” Piper said quietly. “And the grass.” Lila pressed her face into Piper’s shoulder. “I remember.”
For a while they just stayed there. Piper drifted in and out of sleep. Sometimes she murmured things that didn’t make sense. Sometimes she squeezed their hands weakly, but her breathing never got easier.
It kept coming in those shallow, uneven pulls. Samira watched every one. Minutes stretched into hours. At some point Trinity slid down the wall and sat on the floor beside the bed. Lila stayed curled next to Piper. Samira never left her chair.
The fever didn’t break, the breathing only grew slower, and slower, at some point, Piper stopped responding when they spoke to her. Her chest still moved, but the space between each breath grew longer.
Samira leaned closer. “Piper?” No answer. Lila looked up. “Is she sleeping?” “I think so,” Samira said quietly, but she didn’t believe it.
They waited.
One breath.
Then another.
Then a long stretch of silence. Samira leaned forward, her eyes fixed on Piper’s chest.
Waiting.
Waiting.
Another breath came.
Weak.
Barely there.
Then the next pause lasted longer.
Too long.
Samira held her own breath without realizing it. “Come on,” she whispered.
Nothing.
She leaned closer, her hand hovering near Piper’s shoulder. “Piper?”
Still nothing.
Samira’s stomach dropped. “No.” She pressed two shaking fingers against Piper’s neck the way she had seen doctors do on television once. There was no pulse. “No,” she said again, louder now. Her voice cracked. “Piper?”
The word came out as a scream. “PIPER!”
Lila jerked upright. Trinity scrambled to her feet. “What—?” Samira grabbed Piper’s shoulders, shaking her gently. “No, no, no, no—” Her voice dissolved into sobs. “You can’t do this!” She shook her again, desperate. “Wake up! Piper, wake up!”
But Piper’s body stayed still, her chest didn’t rise, her eyes didn’t open. Samira collapsed forward against the bed, crying so hard she could barely breathe. “It’s not fair!” she sobbed. “I tried!”
Across the bed, Lila had frozen. She stared at Piper’s face, not understanding at first. Then the truth hit. “No,” she whispered. Her voice was small. “No, she’s just sleeping.” Trinity grabbed Lila and pulled her into a tight hug.
Lila struggled. “No! Let me go!” Trinity held on tighter. “She’s not—” Trinity started, but the words broke apart in her throat. Lila buried her face in Trinity’s shoulder, crying.
Samira was still at the bed, clutching Piper’s hand. Her sobs echoed through the basement. “I’m sorry,” she cried. “I’m so sorry.”
Trinity sat on the floor, holding Lila while the little girl trembled against her. None of them knew what to do. The basement felt impossibly quiet, and Piper didn’t breathe again.
Margaret returned two days later. The door unlocked, and her footsteps came down the stairs. She stopped when she saw the bed. Piper’s body still lay there under the blanket.
Samira stood immediately. “She got sick,” she said hoarsely. Margaret walked closer. She pulled the blanket back. Her expression barely changed. “How long?” She asked, voice horse.
“Two days,” Trinity said quietly. Margaret turned slowly toward Samira. “You were responsible for her.” Samira’s stomach dropped. “I tried.” Margaret’s hand struck her across the face. The sound echoed sharply through the basement. “You let her die.” Margaret hissed at Samira.
Lila gasped, and Trinity stepped towards her instinctively. Margaret raised her hand again. Samira didn’t fight back. She just stood there, taking the blows in silence. Finally Margaret stopped, and her breathing steady.
“Useless,” she muttered. She glanced once more at Piper’s body. Then she turned away. “I’ll deal with it later.” She left the room. The door locked again, and Piper remained there, for two more days.
The girls stayed close to the bed. Lila held Piper’s notebook, Trinity refused to leave the bedside, and Samira sat beside Piper’s body in silence.
When Margaret finally returned again, she didn’t say a word, but she wrapped Piper in a sheet, and carried her up the stairs. The door shut behind them. Leaving the basement quieter than it had ever been before.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
The basement felt different without Piper, not just quieter, wrong. The quiet corner looked empty without the stack of notebooks beside it. The fourth bed sat untouched, the blanket folded the way Samira had left it after Margaret carried Piper away.
No one wanted to move it, for two days after Piper was taken upstairs, the girls barely spoke. Samira stopped doing morning lessons, Trinity stopped pacing the room, Lila kept drifting toward the quiet corner like she expected Piper to still be sitting there with her pen and notebook.
Sometimes she caught herself looking up, ready to ask a question, then she would remember, and the silence would settle back over the room.
The third night, the door unlocked again. Margaret stepped into the basement carrying a bag. The girls looked up automatically. Samira stood, though slower than usual, Trinity stayed sitting, Lila didn’t move at all.
Margaret noticed everything immediately, the untouched television, the quiet table, the empty fourth bed. She set the bag down harder than usual. “You girls are acting like someone died,” she said sharply.
No one answered.
Margaret’s eyes flicked toward the bed again, and her jaw tightened. “I told you before,” she said, looking directly at Samira, “you were responsible for taking care of her.” Samira didn’t argue. Her cheek was still faintly bruised from when Margaret had hit her days earlier. “I tried,” she said quietly.
Margaret paced once across the room. Her movements were restless, agitated. “You’re supposed to be the smart one,” she muttered. Samira stared at the floor, Trinity watched Margaret carefully. There was something different tonight, Margaret wasn’t calm, she wasn’t smiling. She was angry, but not in the same way she usually was.
Margaret stopped beside the empty bed. For a moment, her hand hovered over the blanket. Then she yanked it straight like she was fixing something out of place. “You girls can’t just… fall apart like that,” she snapped.
Her voice rose. “Do you know how much work it takes to keep this place running?”
No one answered.
“I bring food,” Margaret continued. “I bring medicine.” Her voice sharpened further. “And then you let one of my girls die.”
Lila flinched.
‘My girls.’ Margaret said it like ownership. Like Piper had been something valuable she’d lost. Samira finally looked up. “She was sick,” she said. Margaret turned on her. “I know she was sick.”
For a brief second something flashed across Margaret’s face, frustration, not grief exactly, but something close to it. “She should have told me sooner,” Margaret muttered. Trinity’s eyebrows pulled together. She had left them for almost two weeks. How could they have even contacted her?
Margaret paced again. “She was strong,” she said suddenly. Her voice had softened without her realizing it. “Resilient.” Then she caught herself, and her expression hardened again. “You three will not end up like that.”
She pointed toward the beds. “You will eat.” She gestured toward the sink. “You will drink water.” Her eyes moved to Lila. “And if you are sick, you tell me.” The words came out more forcefully than usual.
Lila nodded automatically, and Margaret seemed to relax slightly. “I take care of what belongs to me,” she said. Then she grabbed the bag from the table and began pulling out food, canned soup, bread, and more medicine. She placed the bottle firmly in front of Samira.
“If anyone gets sick again,” she said sharply, “you use the speaker on the keypad and leave me a message. I’ve turned it on just for that purpose.” Samira blinked, Margaret had never allowed that before.
Margaret turned toward the metal door, but halfway up she stopped. For a moment she looked back at the empty fourth bed again. Her voice dropped slightly. “I’m not losing another one.” Then she left.
The door locked, and the basement fell quiet again, but something had shifted. Because for the first time since they had known her, Margaret had admitted something she had never said before. She didn’t want them to die.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
The basement never felt the same after Piper was gone.
For the first few days, the silence was thick and constant. It pressed against the walls and filled the spaces Piper used to occupy. The quiet corner, the chair beside the bed, the spot at the table where she used to sit with her notebooks.
The girls still moved through their routines, but everything felt slower, heavier. Samira tried to keep things normal, that was the first thing she did after Margaret left them alone again.
“Breakfast,” she said one morning, her voice stiff. She lined the bowls up on the table the same way she always had, she made tea.
She even opened one of the books Samira used to use for lessons, but when she started reading aloud, the words tangled in her throat. After a few sentences she closed the book again. “I can’t,” she said quietly.
Trinity didn’t argue, and Lila just nodded and pushed the book aside.
From that day forward, Samira stopped pretending she could run things the way Piper had helped her do. Instead she carried a quiet, constant guilt. Every time she walked past Piper’s empty bed, her shoulders tightened.
She replayed those last days over and over in her head, maybe she should have given more medicine, maybe she should have forced Piper to drink more water, maybe she should have done something different.
Anything.
Sometimes Trinity caught her staring at the empty bed. “You couldn’t have fixed it,” Trinity muttered once. Samira didn’t look at her. “I was supposed to.” She said, emotionless. “You’re not a doctor.” Trinity said. “But I was the one taking care of her.”
Trinity didn’t answer, because there was no argument strong enough to change Samira’s mind.
Trinity handled the grief differently. On the surface, she seemed almost the same. Still sarcastic, blunt, quick to snap if someone annoyed her, but the girls noticed small changes.
She stopped sitting in Piper’s quiet corner, she started staying awake later than the others. Sometimes Samira woke in the middle of the night and saw Trinity sitting on the edge of her bed, staring at the floor.
She never said what she was thinking, and slowly, quietly, she began hurting herself again, not where the others would easily see. She kept the marks hidden high on her thigh where clothing covered them.
It was the same place she had struggled before, a way to push the anger somewhere outside of her chest, a way to deal with feelings she didn’t know how to talk about.
She never mentioned Piper when she did it, but Piper was always there in the silence afterward.
Lila grieved in the quiet corner. Piper’s notebooks were stacked there exactly where she had left them, for the first few days Lila was afraid to touch them. Like opening one might somehow erase Piper completely, but eventually curiosity won.
She opened the first notebook slowly. Inside were pages and pages of careful handwriting. Dates, events, notes about Margaret, notes about the girls.
Sometimes small observations about things that had happened in the basement, sometimes stories, sometimes just simple sentences about the day.
Lila read them all, every page. Then she opened the last notebook Piper had been writing in. The final entry ended abruptly in the middle of a line. Lila stared at it for a long time.
The next morning, she picked up Piper’s pen, and wrote the next entry. Her handwriting was messier than Piper’s, but she tried to copy the same style. She wrote about the day, about how quiet the basement felt, about how Samira hadn’t finished the lesson, about how Trinity kept pretending she was fine.
Every day after that, Lila added another entry. Sometimes she read Piper’s old notes out loud, sometimes she wrote new ones. The journals slowly became her way of keeping Piper present. If the notebooks kept going, Piper wasn’t completely gone.
Margaret noticed the change in the room too. The girls were quieter, more obedient, and fragile. For reasons only Margaret truly understood, she began coming downstairs more often.
Sometimes she brought food, sometimes new clothes, sometimes medicine, but many nights she came for a different reason. The door to the second room opened more frequently. Margaret would choose one of them and lead her away.
The others would sit silently in the basement while they waited. When the door opened again, they would comfort each other the way they always had. Except now there were only three of them. The loss made them cling to one another more tightly.
Trinity started sitting closer to Lila during the evenings, sometimes she would braid Lila’s hair the way Piper used to. Samira began reading the journals with Lila at night, sometimes they would add entries together.
“We should write this part,” Lila said once. “What part?” Samira asked. “That Trinity actually helped with math today.” Trinity rolled her eyes. “Don’t document that.” Samira smiled faintly for the first time in weeks.
Slowly, painfully, the three girls grew closer, their grief didn’t disappear, but it changed shape. Instead of breaking them apart, it tied them together.
Samira still carried the guilt.
Trinity still carried the anger.
Lila still carried Piper’s memory.
But together they carried the basement too, and in the quiet corner each night, Lila continued writing. Keeping the story alive, just like Piper had started.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Two months after Piper died, the cold finally began to loosen its grip on the basement.
The air drifting through the vent didn’t bite the same way it had during winter. Sometimes it even carried a faint smell of damp earth, like somewhere above them the snow had melted and the ground was waking up again.
Spring.
Lila had written it in Piper’s journal the first day she noticed. ‘The air smells different today. Like dirt and rain.’ For a moment it had almost felt hopeful.
Then Lila got sick, it started small. A cough, a sore throat. Samira noticed immediately. “You’re warm,” she said one morning, pressing the back of her hand to Lila’s forehead. “I’m fine,” Lila muttered.
But by the evening she wasn’t fine. The fever climbed quickly. Trinity watched Samira move around the kitchenette with the same tense focus she had seen months earlier with Piper. “Not again,” Trinity muttered. Samira didn’t answer.
She filled a cup of water and handed it to Lila. “Drink.” Lila obeyed, but her hands were shaking, by the next morning the fever was worse. Lila could barely sit up. Samira’s stomach twisted. “Margaret needs to come down,” she said.
But Margaret hadn’t returned in two days. Samira ran to the keypad by the door. The small intercom system crackled faintly when she pressed the button. “Margaret,” she said, trying to keep her voice steady. “Lila’s sick.”
Silence.
She pressed it again. “We need help.”
Nothing.
Trinity paced behind her. “She’s not there.”
Samira pressed the button a third time. “If you can hear this, you need to come back.”
Still nothing.
By the second day, the basement was tense with fear. Lila lay curled in her bed, sweat dampening her hair. Samira barely left her side. Every hour she checked Lila’s temperature, every hour she made her drink water. “I’m okay,” Lila whispered weakly. “You’re not,” Samira said. Her voice trembled despite her best efforts.
Across the room Trinity paced like a caged animal. “We should try the door,” she said suddenly. “It’s locked.” Samira said, not looking away from Lila. “What if we break something?” Trinity asks.
Samira shook her head. “That will make it worse.” She said. “How could it be worse?” Trinity snapped. Samira didn’t answer, because they both knew.
Piper.
The word hung between them without being spoken. Trinity slammed her fist lightly against the wall. “We can’t just sit here!” Samira’s hands shook as she dipped the cloth into water. “I’m not losing someone else.” Her voice cracked on the last word.
Trinity stopped pacing, for a moment neither of them spoke. Then Trinity sat on the floor beside the bed. “Hey,” she said quietly. Lila opened her eyes. “You remember the garden?” Lila nodded faintly.
“The wind.” Trinity said. “And the grass,” Lila whispered. Trinity forced a smile. “Yeah.”, but the smile didn’t last.
By the third day, Lila was barely awake. Samira hadn’t slept. She sat beside the bed, watching every breath. “Margaret!” she shouted into the keypad again. Her voice cracked through the intercom. “You need to come back!”
Hours later, the door finally unlocked. Footsteps came down the stairs. Margaret stepped into the basement. Samira stood so fast the chair behind her tipped over. “She’s sick,” she said immediately Margaret frowned. “How long?”
“Three days.” Trinity said, sounding angry. Margaret walked closer to the bed. Lila barely stirred. Her breathing was shallow but steady. Margaret touched her forehead. “Fever.” Samira’s voice was shaking now. “You have to help her.”
Margaret glanced at the medicine cabinet. “You know what to do.”
“No.” The word came out sharp. Margaret looked at her. Samira stepped forward. “You said you weren’t losing another one.” The room went still. Margaret’s eyes narrowed slightly.
Samira swallowed hard but didn’t back down. “You said if someone got sick we tell you.” Margaret stared at Lila again, for a long moment she didn’t move. Then she swore quietly under her breath.
Trinity’s eyes widened. Margaret began pacing. “This is inconvenient.” Samira’s hands clenched. “Inconvenient?” Margaret stopped pacing “She needs a doctor,” she muttered. The words sounded like they hurt to say. Trinity blinked. “You’re taking her out?” Margaret shot her a look. “Not you.”
She grabbed a bag from the counter, went into the private room, opening a desk drawer, and began stuffing things into it. Papers, a small folder, a wallet.
Samira watched carefully. “What are those?” Margaret glanced at her. “Insurance cards.” Samira frowned. “But—”
“They’re fake,” Margaret snapped. She turned toward Lila. “I’m taking her to the hospital.” Samira’s chest tightened with relief. Margaret crouched beside the bed. “Listen to me,” she said sharply. Lila’s eyes opened weakly.
Margaret’s voice softened slightly. “You are my foster daughter.” Lila blinked. “What?” She asked, “You fell sick suddenly,” Margaret continued. “You’ve had a fever for a day.” Samira noticed the lie immediately. “You understand?” Margaret asked Lila, and she nodded slowly.
Margaret grabbed a jacket and wrapped it around her. “You do not talk about this place.” She looked directly into Lila’s eyes. “You do not mention the other girls.” Lila glanced at Samira and Trinity. “Okay.” Margaret nodded, “You say your name is Lily.” Lila nodded again. Margaret lifted her carefully into her arms.
“If you do what I say,” Margaret murmured, “this will go very smoothly. And the other girls stay alive.” Lila’s blood turned cold as Margaret turned toward the stairs. Samira stepped forward. “Wait.” Margaret paused. “She’ll be okay, right?” Samira asked.
Margaret didn’t answer, instead she walked up the stairs with Lila in her arms.
The door shut.
The lock clicked.
And for the first time in over two years, one of them was leaving the basement.