Comment on In Between the Pages, The Devil lives

1. Trickster32 on Chapter 4 Thu 20 Feb 2025 04:22AM UTC

   

   I would say that the context is *extremely important*...no matter their age...as they currently believe that Snape used that slur out of the blue...and that's not true...
   Even when you comfort something, this just isn't okay...

   Well, surprise me :3

   Comment Actions

   • Thread
   • Parent Thread

2. 1. Capricornicis on Chapter 4 Thu 20 Feb 2025 05:03AM UTC

      

      It would've derailed the conversation nor is it relevant to the moment. I didn't include it because it wouldn't be about Hermione being called a mudblood it would turn into about Snape. This would be jarring

      Also they don't know it's Snape. They just know a former friend called Lily a mudblood

      And I disagree at 12, Harry doesn't need to know his father was a sexual assaulter. Its not the time for the conversation

      Comment Actions

      • Thread
      • Parent Thread

   2. 1. Trickster32 on Chapter 4 Thu 20 Feb 2025 07:12PM UTC

         

         Okay, I can accept your decision...although Harry still needs to know, that the Marauders were bullies, and didn't accept *any boundaries* - be it sexual assault, breaking the law or a clear murder attempt!

         Ah, but maybe they can guess, after all, how many other Slytherins were among Lily's friends?

         Let's agree to disagree...

         Comment Actions

         • Thread
         • Parent Thread

      2. 1. Capricornicis on Chapter 4 Fri 21 Feb 2025 02:08AM UTC

            

            I would say just keep reading and see where the story goes ^^

            Comment Actions

            • Thread
            • Parent Thread

         2. 1. Trickster32 on Chapter 4 Fri 21 Feb 2025 04:50AM UTC

               

               You can be such a tease^^

               Comment Actions

               • Thread
               • Parent Thread