1 - 20 of 658 Bookmarked Items in Paper (Inanimate Insanity)
Navigation
List of Bookmarks
-
Tags
Summary
Boredom paves a way for curiosity; the strangest of friends can really be made when there's no one else to turn to. Tissues and Trophy would know it all too well.
-
Tags
Summary
OJ's life was about as close to perfect as it could possibly get. Great friends, great grades, and a very long line of girls all lined up for a shot with the academic, athletic superstar.
So why did he still feel so... hollow?
And more importantly, why did that feeling get so much worse around PAPER, of all objects? After all, they were just friends. They'd been friends since they were kids.
His heart doesn't seem to get the memo, though.
[Fic requested by theblossomingfox on discord!!]
Series
- Part 12 of Lia’s Payjay Fics! <3
-
Tags
Summary
𝓕𝓻𝓮𝓪𝓴𝔂 PayJay fic with my trauma mixed in.
Series
- Part 3 of oscaddict’s Smut Fics
-
Summary
a knife ii darkfic (very knifekel centric!)
- Words:
- 35,877
- Works:
- 2
- Bookmarks:
- 1
-
Tags
Summary
It's Christmas at the hotel, and the party is in full swing! Pepper is on a mission to get Balloon and Nickel to share a kiss under the mistletoe.
Series
- Part 24 of Object Show Oneshots
- Part 7 of Nickloon <3
-
Bookmark Notes:
AWWWHHHHHH
-
Tags
Summary
Salt’s gaze lifted to meet the writer of the mysterious note. Immediately, she took a step back in shock.
This wasn’t OJ.
This was Pepper.
“Hi Salt. You look, uh, pretty tonight.”
(In which Salt is given an anonymous love letter. Turns out she just needed a push in the right direction to see past OJ.)
-
Bookmark Notes:
☹️☹️☹️☹️☹️☹️☹️
-
Tags
Summary
fan struggles with feeling as if everyone dislikes him. after attending a wrap party for the ending of inanimate insanity, he suddenly acts upon a gruesome and intrusive urge. all hell breaks loose, and fan must either deal with the consequences or do whatever it takes to cover it up. fan prefers the latter.
Series
- Part 1 of thinking skills
-
Bookmark Notes:
it's thinking skills
-
Bookmark Notes:
I love this:D
-
Bookmark Notes:
Aaaaa
-
Everyone Can See It (Except Us) by radioosilence
Fandoms: Inanimate Insanity (Web Series)
27 Jul 2025
Tags
Summary
Payjay Highschool AU since I’m seeing this everywhere!
They’re just friends. Totally normal friends who just want to kiss each other.
-
Bookmark Notes:
I need the update,..
-
Bookmark Notes:
PAYJAYYYYY
-
Tags
Summary
OJ has a little bit of a breakdown when he loses another investor.
Series
- Part 9 of PAYJAY!!!!
-
Tags
Summary
It felt like his head was being split in half. It had for the past two hours, actually.
Alphabet of Whump 2025: A is for Aspirin
Series
- Part 1 of Alphabet of Whump 2025 <3
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 793
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 2
- Kudos:
- 18
- Bookmarks:
- 2
- Hits:
- 134
-
Bookmark Notes:
I needed this so badly omg... oj is so me frfr...
-
Tags
Summary
OJ’s been working as a full-time police officer for quite a few years now.
It… wasn’t exactly all it was cracked up to be, but… he’d grown used to his current lifestyle, always being buried under pressure and having to face danger lurking behind every corner. Anything to make sure those criminals ended up behind bars, after all.
But while tracking down a certain ‘Hooded Bandit’ - a mysterious criminal who’d completed heist after heist without fail in just the span of a few weeks, he’s forced deal with the danger of letting the thief steal one of the most valuable things he had to offer; his own heart.
[Cop x Criminal AU, requested by starrless_ on discord!]
Series
- Part 20 of Lia’s Payjay Fics! <3
-
Bookmark Notes:
We love father oj in this
-
Bookmark Notes:
Bcs bcs paper is bcs bcs payjay yes oh gmnnhahaha
-
Tags
Summary
After a long day of work at the hotel, OJ takes a break, but not where you would expect!! He may seem like a stressed, middle aged dad... which is PERFECT!! BECAUSE HE'S AT A BAR! Yeah, but he's literally only drinking water (for now). What a loser, amiright?
After being there for hours, OJ decided to go home, but is met with a disgusting (in his mind) fate on the walk home. But it can't get any worse when he gets to the hotel, right! Right?... WRONG! OJ arrives at the hotel, and is soon to be met with one upset (humanized) piece of paper.
HUGE THANKS TO PAYJAY_ILY FOR THE WORK TITLE NAME!!! ALL CREDITS TO THEM FOR IT!!! 🧡 Everything else is mine though.
-
Tags
Summary
OJ’s been having a great life, until one day he just feels…so tired. He goes to sleep; worst mistake of his life. For the next few weeks, he awakens in such a fatigued state he just goes right back to bed. And every time he does, he dreams. Dreams about an unfamiliar object.
Series
- Part 2 of PAYJAY!!!!
-
Bookmark Notes:
Realy cool concept :0
-
Bookmark Notes:
It’s a peak concept dude I’m so excited
-
Tags
Summary
OJ is sick and refuses to let Paper take care of him.
[Fic originally requested by 1stpin on discord!]
Series
- Part 19 of Lia’s Payjay Fics! <3
-
Tags
Summary
After the events of Season Four's first elimination, Paper asks his boyfriend for a very important favour.
Series
- Part 18 of Lia’s Payjay Fics! <3
-
Tags
Summary
Cherries and Yin-Yang happen to be situated in the room beside OJ and Paper's. For countless nights, the two have been kept up by OJ and Paper's loud sexual activity that never seems to stop. The two decide to get revenge.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 2,840
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 6
- Kudos:
- 17
- Bookmarks:
- 2
- Hits:
- 350
-
Bookmark Notes:
I think this is moots crackfic… I dunnooooo…. -whoopsdaiisy
-
- Words:
- 499
- Works:
- 1
- Bookmarks:
- 1
-
Bookmark Notes:
I want to read more anon265!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
-
Tags
Summary
OJ runs a hotel alone and it’s extremely stressful. So, his best friend, Paper, helps him calm down.
-
It's Cold Outside (but we're warmer than ever) by TallLiar
Fandoms: Inanimate Insanity (Web Series)
07 May 2025
Tags
Summary
The world... had been quite cruel to Paper thus far.
His first friend ended up crushing him with a piano. A piano, for goodness sake. And of course, when he finally makes a connection that's actually meaningful - that person happens to get shot off a cliff by a lemon and dies.
And when he'd finally gotten used to living life peacefully in the hotel, with no competition to worry about.. the end of the world is suddenly approaching him like a freight train.
Could things get any worse?
The answer is… more complicated than what Paper initially expected.
Series
- Part 14 of Lia’s Payjay Fics! <3
-
Just give it time before I let everyone know about us. by Kaden_kade2
Fandoms: Inanimate Insanity (Web Series)
19 Sep 2025
Tags
Summary
Trophy and knife have been in a secret relationship since the end of season two
(this is my au where knife lived and everyone stayed at Hotel OJ!!)
gulps........also yeah their humanized imagine them however enjoy my little gooners
-
Bookmark Notes:
waiting, waiting drives you crazy